Canonical Classics ← 第八十八回
第八十八回
禪chán到dào玉yù華huá施shī法fǎ會huì
心xīn猿yuán木mù土tǔ授shòu門mén人rén

Chan Reaches Yuhua and a Dharma Assembly Is Held · The Mind-Ape and the Wood and the Earth Take Disciples

卻都心良
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

卻都心良 Ugly of Face but Good of Heart

那nà王wáng子zǐ舉jǔ目mù見jiàn那nà等děng醜chǒu惡è,卻què也yě心xīn中zhōng害hài怕pà。三sān藏zàng合hé掌zhǎng道dào:「千qiān歲suì放fàng心xīn。頑wán徒tú雖suī是shì貌mào醜chǒu,卻què都dōu心xīn良liáng。」那nà王wáng子zǐ举jǔ目mù见jiàn那nà等děng丑chǒu恶è,却què也yě心xīn中zhōng害hài怕pà。三sān藏zàng合hé掌zhǎng道dào:「千qiān岁suì放fàng心xīn。顽wán徒tú虽suī是shì貌mào丑chǒu,却què都dōu心xīn良liáng。」


逐句解 Line by line

那nà王wáng子zǐ舉jǔ目mù見jiàn那nà等děng醜chǒu惡è,卻què也yě心xīn中zhōng害hài怕pà。 那nà王wáng子zǐ举jǔ目mù见jiàn那nà等děng丑chǒu恶è,却què也yě心xīn中zhōng害hài怕pà。

The prince raised his eyes, saw how hideous they were, and was frightened in his heart after all.

卻也 is a small concessive — after all, in spite of everything. It concedes on the prince's behalf what he would rather not admit: he is a worthy and open-minded ruler who has just been handed a fright he cannot govern away. The novel is fond of this moment, where a good man's composure fails him for entirely reasonable reasons.

三sān藏zàng合hé掌zhǎng道dào:「千qiān歲suì放fàng心xīn。 三sān藏zàng合hé掌zhǎng道dào:「千qiān岁suì放fàng心xīn。

Tripitaka pressed his palms together and said, "Set your mind at rest, Your Highness.

千歲 again, a thousand years, the acclamation for a prince — the second of the three times it occurs in this chapter, against not one instance of the ten-thousand-year form reserved for emperors. Tripitaka has been consistent about the man's rank from the moment he walked in.

頑wán徒tú雖suī是shì貌mào醜chǒu,卻què都dōu心xīn良liáng。」 顽wán徒tú虽suī是shì貌mào丑chǒu,却què都dōu心xīn良liáng。」

My unruly disciples are ugly of face, but their hearts are all good."

頑徒, unruly disciple, is Tripitaka's standing self-deprecation about his own household — you belittle your own people the way you belittle your own house. The sentence is built as a concession followed by a correction, ugly but good, and this exact formula is about to come back twice more in the chapter, once from Sha Monk and once in a way that finally convinces somebody.


總評 Commentary

The prince has been generous, competent and welcoming for two full scenes, and then three faces walk into the room and he is simply afraid. The novel does not hold it against him.

Tripitaka's defence is the sentence he has been making in one form or another since the start of the pilgrimage: they look terrible and they are good. He will not be believed today.

It is worth noticing that this is the whole moral machinery of the chapter, stated early and plainly. Everything from here to the weapons in the courtyard argues one question: whether a face tells you what a creature is.