Canonical Classics ← 第八十八回
第八十八回
禪chán到dào玉yù華huá施shī法fǎ會huì
心xīn猿yuán木mù土tǔ授shòu門mén人rén

Chan Reaches Yuhua and a Dharma Assembly Is Held · The Mind-Ape and the Wood and the Earth Take Disciples

衝倒泰山
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

衝倒泰山 One Sentence Topples Mount Tai

索suǒ性xìng不bù開kāi口kǒu,便biàn也yě罷bà了le,怎zěn麼me那nà般bān粗cū魯lǔ?一yí句jù話huà,足zú足zú衝chōng倒dǎo泰tài山shān。」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「還hái是shì我wǒ不bú唱chàng喏rě的de好hǎo,也yě省shěng些xiē力lì氣qì。」索suǒ性xìng不bù开kāi口kǒu,便biàn也yě罢bà了le,怎zěn么me那nà般bān粗cū鲁lǔ?一yí句jù话huà,足zú足zú冲chōng倒dǎo泰tài山shān。」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「还hái是shì我wǒ不bú唱chàng喏rě的de好hǎo,也yě省shěng些xiē力lì气qì。」


逐句解 Line by line

索suǒ性xìng不bù開kāi口kǒu,便biàn也yě罷bà了le,怎zěn麼me那nà般bān粗cū魯lǔ? 索suǒ性xìng不bù开kāi口kǒu,便biàn也yě罢bà了le,怎zěn么me那nà般bān粗cū鲁lǔ?

If you had simply kept your mouth shut it would have been well enough. Why be so coarse?

索性 means outright, just plainly — if you had simply not spoken. 便也罷了 is the concessive shrug: that would have been that, no harm done. It is a real and slightly withering construction, the sound of someone telling you that saying nothing was an available option.

一yí句jù話huà,足zú足zú衝chōng倒dǎo泰tài山shān。」 一yí句jù话huà,足zú足zú冲chōng倒dǎo泰tài山shān。」

One sentence out of you, and it is enough to knock Mount Tai over."

The best line Tripitaka gets in the chapter. 泰山 is Mount Tai in Shandong, the eastern peak of the Five Sacred Mountains and the standing Chinese image for something absolutely immovable — the mountain emperors climbed to announce themselves to heaven. 倒 is dǎo here, to topple, and the exaggeration is enormous and affectionate: one word from Bajie could bring down the most solid object in the world.

行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「還hái是shì我wǒ不bú唱chàng喏rě的de好hǎo,也yě省shěng些xiē力lì氣qì。」 行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「还hái是shì我wǒ不bú唱chàng喏rě的de好hǎo,也yě省shěng些xiē力lì气qì。」

Pilgrim laughed and said, "Better that I did not salute at all — and it saves a bit of effort into the bargain."

Pilgrim's contribution is to point out that he said nothing and is therefore blameless, which is true and entirely unhelpful. 省些力氣, saves some strength, is the kind of remark that is funny because it is so obviously an afterthought dressed up as the real reason.


總評 Commentary

The Mount Tai line is a good example of how this novel does affection. Tripitaka is genuinely annoyed, and the image he reaches for is so oversized that the annoyance turns into something closer to a family joke.

Pilgrim's response is worth watching. He does not defend his brother, he does not attack him, he simply observes that keeping quiet worked out well for him. He has spent the whole chapter so far standing slightly to one side of the trouble.

The pattern of the last few scenes is now clear: Bajie acts, everyone reacts, and Pilgrim comments. It is the oldest comic arrangement there is and the novel runs it with complete confidence.