Canonical Classics ← 第八十八回
第八十八回
禪chán到dào玉yù華huá施shī法fǎ會huì
心xīn猿yuán木mù土tǔ授shòu門mén人rén

Chan Reaches Yuhua and a Dharma Assembly Is Held · The Mind-Ape and the Wood and the Earth Take Disciples

與中華無異
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

與中華無異 No Different From Home

原yuán來lái那nà關guān廂xiāng人rén家jiā,做zuò買mǎi做zuò賣mài的de,人rén煙yān湊còu集jí,生shēng意yì亦yì甚shèn茂mào盛shèng。觀guān其qí聲shēng音yīn相xiàng貌mào,與yǔ中zhōng華huá無wú異yì。三sān藏zàng吩fēn咐fu:「徒tú弟dì們men謹jǐn慎shèn,切qiè不bù可kě放fàng肆sì。」原yuán来lái那nà关guān厢xiāng人rén家jiā,做zuò买mǎi做zuò卖mài的de,人rén烟yān凑còu集jí,生shēng意yì亦yì甚shèn茂mào盛shèng。观guān其qí声shēng音yīn相xiàng貌mào,与yǔ中zhōng华huá无wú异yì。三sān藏zàng吩fēn咐fu:「徒tú弟dì们men谨jǐn慎shèn,切qiè不bù可kě放fàng肆sì。」


逐句解 Line by line

原yuán來lái那nà關guān廂xiāng人rén家jiā,做zuò買mǎi做zuò賣mài的de,人rén煙yān湊còu集jí,生shēng意yì亦yì甚shèn茂mào盛shèng。 原yuán来lái那nà关guān厢xiāng人rén家jiā,做zuò买mǎi做zuò卖mài的de,人rén烟yān凑còu集jí,生shēng意yì亦yì甚shèn茂mào盛shèng。

It turned out that in the households of the outer suburb, among those buying and selling, the smoke of many hearths gathered close and trade too was flourishing.

關廂 is the built-up strip outside a city gate — the suburb that grows up along the road where the traffic is, and where a traveller meets a town before he enters it. 人煙, people-smoke, means a populated place: you count the households by their cooking fires. 做買做賣 is a matched everyday phrase, doing buying and doing selling, for people in trade.

觀guān其qí聲shēng音yīn相xiàng貌mào,與yǔ中zhōng華huá無wú異yì。 观guān其qí声shēng音yīn相xiàng貌mào,与yǔ中zhōng华huá无wú异yì。

Looking at their speech and their faces, there was no difference from China.

相 is xiàng here, appearance or physiognomy — the same character was read xiāng, mutually, eighty-eight characters earlier when the old man said the prince would meet them. 中華 is China, literally the Central Splendour, and the pilgrims reach for it a dozen times across the novel whenever they want to measure a foreign place against home. Coming from a book that has spent seventy-five chapters on the strangeness of the west, the finding that India looks and sounds exactly like home is a considerable statement.

三sān藏zàng吩fēn咐fu:「徒tú弟dì們men謹jǐn慎shèn,切qiè不bù可kě放fàng肆sì。」 三sān藏zàng吩fēn咐fu:「徒tú弟dì们men谨jǐn慎shèn,切qiè不bù可kě放fàng肆sì。」

Tripitaka gave his orders: "Disciples, be careful. On no account are you to behave outrageously."

吩咐 is to instruct a subordinate, and the choice of word says that Tripitaka is speaking as a master, not a companion. 放肆 means to let oneself go, to be unrestrained — it is precisely the accusation you would level at someone who was about to show a crowd his snout. He is looking at Bajie.


總評 Commentary

The suburb outside the gate is exactly where a traveller would first read a town, and the novel reads it the way an experienced traveller would: hearth smoke for population, market noise for prosperity, faces and accents for whether these are foreigners.

The verdict — no different from China — is the quiet heart of the passage. India has been the goal, the far country, the place where the scriptures are. Standing in it at last, Tripitaka's disciples find a market town like any other.

And Tripitaka's response to arriving in the promised land is to tell his disciples not to embarrass him. He is, among his other qualities, a man permanently worried about what people will think.