Canonical Classics ← 第三十回
第三十回
xiéqīnzhèng
xīnyuán

The Evil Demon Assaults the True Dharma · The Horse of the Will Recalls the Monkey of the Heart

行者不去
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

行者不去 Wukong's Refusal

èrrénchīleguǒzijiànjiàngāodāizikǒnglejiùtángsēngzhǐguǎncuīdào:「geshīzàipànwàngliwàngzǎozǎoer。」xíngzhědào:「xiánqǐngwǎngshuǐliándòngshuǎshuǎ。」jièjiāndào:「duōgǎnlǎoxiōngshèngnàishījiǔděngláojìndòng。」xíngzhědào:「gǎnjiǔliúqǐngjiùchùfèngbié。」jièdào:「gele?」xíngzhědào:「wǎngzhètiānshōuguǎnyóuzàishuǎzierzuòshénmeshàngshìdànshàngtángsēnggǎn退tuìlezàixiǎng。」dāiziwényángǎnzhǐkǒngxìngzishíshàngliǎnggùnnàizhǐgàozhǎoérèrrénchīleguǒzijiànjiàngāodāizikǒnglejiùtángsēngzhǐguǎncuīdào:「geshīzàipànwàngliwàngzǎozǎoer。」xíngzhědào:「xiánqǐngwǎngshuǐliándòngshuǎshuǎ。」jièjiāndào:「duōgǎnlǎoxiōngshèngnàishījiǔděngláojìndòng。」xíngzhědào:「gǎnjiǔliúqǐngjiùchùfèngbié。」jièdào:「gele?」xíngzhědào:「wǎngzhètiānshōuguǎnyóuzàishuǎzierzuòshénmeshàngshìdànshàngtángsēnggǎn退tuìlezàixiǎng。」dāiziwényángǎnzhǐkǒngxìngzishíshàngliǎnggùnnàizhǐgàozhǎoér


逐句解 Line by line

èrrénchīleguǒzijiànjiàngāo èrrénchīleguǒzijiànjiàngāo

The two ate the fruit, and by and by the sun climbed high.

果子 takes as the suffix zi. The sun climbing is the detail that is making Bajie anxious.

dāizikǒnglejiùtángsēngzhǐguǎncuīdào:「geshīzàipànwàngliwàngzǎozǎoer。」 dāizikǒnglejiùtángsēngzhǐguǎncuīdào:「geshīzàipànwàngliwàngzǎozǎoer。」

The blockhead, afraid of failing the rescue of Tripitaka, kept urging: "Brother, the master is over there watching for you and me. I beg you, let's be off good and early."

Both instances of are pointing ; in 早早兒 the colloquial is er; the vernacular sentence-final is li. Note the lie he is maintaining: the master is watching for us. The master is in a cage on four legs.

xíngzhědào:「xiánqǐngwǎngshuǐliándòngshuǎshuǎ。」 xíngzhědào:「xiánqǐngwǎngshuǐliándòngshuǎshuǎ。」

The Pilgrim said: "Worthy brother, do come along to the Water-Curtain Cave and amuse yourself a while."

水簾洞, the Water-Curtain Cave, is Wukong's ancestral home — the cave behind the waterfall he found as a young monkey and which made him king. He deflects the urgency with another invitation to stay.

jièjiāndào:「duōgǎnlǎoxiōngshèngnàishījiǔděngláojìndòng。」 jièjiāndào:「duōgǎnlǎoxiōngshèngnàishījiǔděngláojìndòng。」

Bajie firmly declined: "Much obliged for my elder brother's kindness — but the master has waited so long, there's no need to trouble to enter the cave."

堅辭 is to decline firmly; 盛意 is gracious intent; 不勞 is "no need to trouble yourself." Bajie holds the line against hospitality, which for him is a considerable feat.

xíngzhědào:「gǎnjiǔliúqǐngjiùchùfèngbié。」 xíngzhědào:「gǎnjiǔliúqǐngjiùchùfèngbié。」

The Pilgrim said: "If that's how it is, I won't presume to keep you — let us take our leave here, then."

奉別 is a courteous formula for taking leave. He is proposing to send Bajie off alone.

jièdào:「gele?」 jièdào:「gele?」

Bajie said: "Brother — you won't come, then?"

The blunt question that forces the refusal into the open.

xíngzhědào:「wǎngzhètiānshōuguǎnyóuzàishuǎzierzuòshénmeshàng xíngzhědào:「wǎngzhètiānshōuguǎnyóuzàishuǎzierzuòshénmeshàng

The Pilgrim said: "Where should I go? Here Heaven doesn't claim me and Earth doesn't rule me; I'm free and my own master. If not to enjoy myself, why be a monk at all?

The character , "where," is the dedicated question-word, distinct from the pointing that has been all over this chapter — and it appears exactly once. 甚麼 takes as shén; in 耍子兒 the suffix is er. Then the creed: 天不收地不管自由自在 — Heaven takes no charge of me, Earth does not govern me, free and at ease. 自由自在 is still ordinary modern Chinese for "footloose."

shìdànshàngtángsēnggǎn退tuìlezàixiǎng。」 shìdànshàngtángsēnggǎn退tuìlezàixiǎng。」

I'll not go; go by yourself. Only report to Tripitaka: having driven me off, let him think no more of me."

上覆 is to report to a superior, to convey a message upward; 趕退 is to drive off, to expel. "Having driven me off, let him think no more of me" — which is a request that only makes sense from somebody who has been thinking about very little else.

dāiziwényángǎnzhǐkǒngxìngzishíshàngliǎnggùn dāiziwényángǎnzhǐkǒngxìngzishíshàngliǎnggùn

At this the blockhead dared not press him hard, fearing that if pushed, his temper might flare and he'd fetch him a couple of blows.

苦逼 is to press somebody hard, to coerce; 逼發他性子, to provoke his temper, takes as the suffix zi; 打上兩棍 is to deal a couple of blows with the staff. Bajie stops pushing for entirely selfish reasons, and so the mission fails.

nàizhǐgàozhǎoér nàizhǐgàozhǎoér

With no help for it, he could only make his obedient farewells and set off to find the road.

In 只得, could only, the character is ; 喏喏 — murmuring "yes, yes" — takes as , the reading for obeisant assent, not the nuò of ordinary agreement. 告辭 is to take one's leave. He backs out bowing.


總評 Commentary

This is the chapter's pivotal refusal. Wukong's declaration — 天不收地不管自由自在, "Heaven takes no charge of me, Earth governs me not, free and at ease" — is the Mind-Monkey's creed of absolute liberty, and it is precisely the self-will that the pilgrimage, and the metal band clamped round his head, exist to discipline. Back on his mountain and refusing to leave it, he reasserts the untrammelled independence he was born with, and his message to Tripitaka — let him think no more of me — appears to shut the door on the quest itself.

Yet the refusal is staged so as to invite its own undoing. He protests a good deal too much; the insistence on freedom is also the injured pride of somebody who would like to be wanted, and the horse's stratagem has already anticipated exactly this. Bajie's comic deference — not daring to press, for fear of the cudgel — lightens the scene without relieving it. The Mind-Monkey has said no, and the master is still a caged tiger.