Canonical Classics ← 第三十回
第三十回
xiéqīnzhèng
xīnyuán

The Evil Demon Assaults the True Dharma · The Horse of the Will Recalls the Monkey of the Heart

意馬心猿
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

意馬心猿 The Horse of the Will and the Monkey of the Heart

quèshuōxiǎolóngqiánshuǐbànshíchéntīngjiànshēngfāngcáiyǎozherěnzhetuǐténgtiàojiāngzheyúnjìngzhuǎnguǎnháibiànzuòjiùcáoxiàliánhúnshēnshìshuǐtuǐyǒushānghénshíjiéquèshuōxiǎolóngqiánshuǐbànshíchéntīngjiànshēngfāngcáiyǎozherěnzhetuǐténgtiàojiāngzheyúnjìngzhuǎnguǎn驿háibiànzuòjiùcáoxiàliánhúnshēnshìshuǐtuǐyǒushānghénshíjié

xīnyuándōushīsànjīngōngjìndiāolíngxīnyuándōushīsànjīngōngjìndiāolíng
huángshāngsǔntōngfēnbiédàoxiāoshūzěnchénghuángshāngsǔntōngfēnbiédàoxiāoshūzěnchéng

逐句解 Line by line

quèshuōxiǎolóngqiánshuǐbànshíchéntīngjiànshēngfāngcáiyǎozherěnzhetuǐténgtiàojiāng quèshuōxiǎolóngqiánshuǐbànshíchéntīngjiànshēngfāngcáiyǎozherěnzhetuǐténgtiàojiāng

Now the little dragon lay hidden at the bottom of the water; and only after half a double-hour, hearing no sound above, did he grit his teeth and, enduring the pain of his leg, spring up and away.

半個時辰 is half a 時辰 — the day was divided into twelve of these, so one runs two of our hours and half of one is about sixty minutes. He lies on the bottom of a moat for an hour, bleeding, listening. In 咬著牙 and 忍著 the is zhe; in 跳將起去 the carrying the motion is jiāng. is pointing .

zheyúnjìngzhuǎnguǎnháibiànzuòjiùcáoxià zheyúnjìngzhuǎnguǎn驿háibiànzuòjiùcáoxià

Treading a black cloud, he made straight back to the hostel, changed again into his former horse-shape, and lay down beneath the trough.

In 踏著 the is zhe; 還變作, changed back again, takes as hái. He puts the halter back on himself. Nobody saw him go and nobody sees him return.

liánhúnshēnshìshuǐtuǐyǒushānghénshíjié liánhúnshēnshìshuǐtuǐyǒushānghénshíjié

Piteous — his whole body soaked, his leg gashed and scarred. At that hour:

The lead-in to the couplet. 傷痕 is a wound-scar; is pointing . A soaked, bruised horse lying under a feed trough is the image the verse is about to lift into cosmology.

xīnyuándōushīsànjīngōngjìndiāolíng xīnyuándōushīsànjīngōngjìndiāolíng

The Horse of the Will and the Monkey of the Heart are all dispersed; the Metal Lord and the Wood Mother are withered utterly away.

This is the chapter's title couplet, and the heart of the inner-alchemy reading that runs under the whole novel. The pilgrims double as the phases of a self being refined. 意馬, the Horse of the Will, is the dragon-horse; 心猿, the Monkey of the Heart, is Sun Wukong. 金公, the Metal Lord, and 木母, the Wood Mother, are further Five Phases names for the disciples. is dōu; 盡凋零 takes as jìn.

huángshāngsǔntōngfēnbiédàoxiāoshūzěnchéng huángshāngsǔntōngfēnbiédàoxiāoshūzěnchéng

the Yellow Dame is hurt and marred, and all is set asunder; the Way and its rightness dwindle and fail — how shall the work be brought to pass!

黃婆, the Yellow Dame — the mediating Earth phase, here Sha Wujing — completes the roster; 道義 is the Way and its rightness. 分別 takes as fēn; 怎得成, "how can it come off," takes as . Read plainly it says the party has fallen apart. Read the other way it says a person has.


總評 Commentary

This is the passage the chapter is named for, and its couplet opens out the allegory that runs half-submerged beneath the whole novel. On the inner-alchemical reading the pilgrims embody the Five Phases (五行) of a self under cultivation: 心猿, the Monkey of the Heart, is the restless mind, which is Sun Wukong; 意馬, the Horse of the Will, is intention, which is the dragon-horse; 金公 and 木母, Metal Lord and Wood Mother, and 黃婆, the Yellow Dame, are the remaining phases that mediate between them.

The force of the couplet is that it reads the plot as a psychology. With the Mind-Monkey banished and the company scattered, the phases are "dispersed" and "withered" — the cultivated self is coming apart. The wounded horse under the trough is not merely a beaten fighter but the emblem of a mind whose faculties have lost the thing that governed them. Which is why the remedy the chapter drives toward is not a rescue by force but a restoration of order: get the 心猿 back, or nothing will hold.

The closing question — 道義消疏怎得成, "how shall the work be brought off?" — is the hinge of the whole chapter. It names the impasse the second half has to break, and points unmistakably at the one absent disciple whom the horse is about to send for.