Canonical Classics ← 第三十回
第三十回
xiéqīnzhèng
xīnyuán

The Evil Demon Assaults the True Dharma · The Horse of the Will Recalls the Monkey of the Heart

誣僧為虎
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

誣僧為虎 Tripitaka Named the Tiger

chényīnyánjiāngjiělesuǒziráolexìngmìngdàizhejiànshāngpǎojiǎnwěiérzhīlexìngmìngzàishānzhōngxiūlezhèniánliànchéngjīngzhuānrénhàirénchénwénniányǒujīngdedōushuōshìtángláidetángsēngxiǎngshìzhèhàiletángsēnglewényǐnbiànzuòjīngdeyàngjīnzàicháozhōnghǒngpiànzhǔgōngzhǔgōngaxiùdūnshàngzuòdezhèngshìshísānniánqiántuógōngzhǔdeměngshìzhēnzhèngjīngzhīrén。」chényīnyánjiāngjiělesuǒziráolexìngmìngdàizhejiànshāngpǎojiǎnwěiérzhīlexìngmìngzàishānzhōngxiūlezhèniánliànchéngjīngzhuānrénhàirénchénwénniányǒujīngdedōushuōshìtángláidetángsēngxiǎngshìzhèhàiletángsēnglewényǐnbiànzuòjīngdeyàngjīnzàicháozhōnghǒngpiànzhǔgōngzhǔgōngaxiùdūnshàngzuòdezhèngshìshísānniánqiántuógōngzhǔdeměngshìzhēnzhèngjīngzhīrén。」


逐句解 Line by line

chényīnyánjiāngjiělesuǒziráolexìngmìng chényīnyánjiāngjiělesuǒziráolexìngmìng

At these words your servant untied the tiger's rope and spared its life.

In 故將虎解了 the marking the object is jiāng; 索子, rope, takes the suffix as zi. He has now let the tiger loose in his story, which is the whole reason it was invented.

dàizhejiànshāngpǎojiǎnwěiér dàizhejiànshāngpǎojiǎnwěiér

The tiger, bearing its arrow-wound, went off at a gallop, its tail switching behind.

In 帶著, carrying, the is zhe; 跑蹄剪尾 — hooves pounding, tail cutting the air — pictures its flight. is the pointing .

zhīlexìngmìngzàishānzhōngxiūlezhèniánliànchéngjīngzhuānrénhàirén zhīlexìngmìngzàishānzhōngxiūlezhèniánliànchéngjīngzhuānrénhàirén

Little did I know that, having got away with its life, it stayed in those mountains and, cultivating itself these several years, refined its body into a spirit — bent solely on beguiling and harming men.

得了性命 takes as , "got, kept"; 那山中 takes as pointing and as zhōng. 煉體成精, "to refine the body into a spirit," is genuine Daoist self-cultivation vocabulary — the language the novel uses seriously elsewhere — here bent to slander.

chénwénniányǒujīngdedōushuōshìtángláidetángsēng chénwénniányǒujīngdedōushuōshìtángláidetángsēng

Your servant has heard that in years past there came several scripture-seekers, all said to be a Tang monk out of Great Tang.

聞得 takes the structural as de; 都說 takes as dōu, "all say." He is building on true rumour, which is what makes the next sentence land.

xiǎngshìzhèhàiletángsēnglewényǐnbiànzuòjīngdeyàngjīnzàicháozhōnghǒngpiànzhǔgōng xiǎngshìzhèhàiletángsēnglewényǐnbiànzuòjīngdeyàngjīnzàicháozhōnghǒngpiànzhǔgōng

I surmise this tiger did the Tang monk to death, got hold of his travel-warrant, took on the very likeness of the pilgrim, and now, here at court, deceives my sovereign.

And there it is, the exact inversion of the truth. 得了他文引 takes as ; 那取經的 takes as pointing ; 朝中 takes as zhōng. 文引 is a travel-warrant, the pilgrim's passport. The demon accuses the real monk of being a beast wearing a monk.

zhǔgōngaxiùdūnshàngzuòdezhèngshìshísānniánqiántuógōngzhǔdeměngshìzhēnzhèngjīngzhīrén。」 zhǔgōngaxiùdūnshàngzuòdezhèngshìshísānniánqiántuógōngzhǔdeměngshìzhēnzhèngjīngzhīrén。」

My sovereign — the one seated there upon the embroidered stool is none other than that fierce tiger which, thirteen years ago, bore the princess on its back; he is no true scripture-seeker at all."

繡墩 is an embroidered drum-shaped stool; both instances of are pointing . He raises his arm and points at Tripitaka, and the frame closes.


總評 Commentary

The accusation completes a perfect inversion. Having narrated a tiger into existence, the demon now identifies that tiger with the pilgrim sitting on the stool — so that Tripitaka, powerless and unrecognised and about to be transformed, stands accused of being exactly the kind of creature his accuser is. The liar assigns the victim his own nature.

The vocabulary is borrowed from the novel's serious machinery: 煉體成精, a beast refining itself into a spirit, and 文引, the travel-warrant, invoked as stolen property. The fiction is dense with the authentic furniture of the pilgrimage, and that is precisely what makes it dangerous.

The pointing finger — 那繡墩上坐的, "the one seated on the embroidered stool" — is the hinge of the chapter. From it follow the king's demand that the "tiger" be exposed, and the transformation itself.