Canonical Classics ← 第三十一回
第三十一回
zhūjièhóuwáng
sūnxíngzhězhìxiángyāoguài

Zhu Bajie, Roused by Duty, Provokes the Monkey King · Sun the Pilgrim, by Wit, Subdues the Fiend

妖怪暗疑
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

妖怪暗疑 The Fiend’s Secret Doubt

guàiháizàiyínān殿diàn宿jiǔwèixǐngzhèngshuìmèngjiāntīngdeyǒurénjiàomíngjiùfānshēntáitóuguānkànzhǐjiànyúnduānshìzhūjièshāshàngèrrényāoyāoguàixīnzhōngànxiǎngdào:「zhūjiè便biànleshāshàngshìbǎngzàijiāzěnmechūláidehúnjiāzěnmekěnfàngdeháiérzěnmedàoshǒuzhèshìzhūjièchūjiāozhànjiāngláiruòrènlezhèfàntóujiùaguàiháizàiyínān殿diàn宿jiǔwèixǐngzhèngshuìmèngjiāntīngdeyǒurénjiàomíngjiùfānshēntáitóuguānkànzhǐjiànyúnduānshìzhūjièshāshàngèrrényāoyāoguàixīnzhōngànxiǎngdào:「zhūjiè便biànleshāshàngshìbǎngzàijiāzěnmechūláidehúnjiāzěnmekěnfàngdeháiérzěnmedàoshǒuzhèshìzhūjièchūjiāozhànjiāngláiruòrènlezhèfàntóujiùa


逐句解 Line by line

guàiháizàiyínān殿diàn宿jiǔwèixǐng guàiháizàiyínān殿diàn宿jiǔwèixǐng

The fiend was still in the Hall of Silver Peace, not yet sobered from the night's wine.

宿酒未醒, sù jiǔ wèi xǐng, not yet awake from the previous night's drink. The chapter's villain is introduced to us, at his moment of decision, with a hangover.

zhèngshuìmèngjiāntīngdeyǒurénjiàomíngjiùfānshēntáitóuguānkànzhǐjiànyúnduānshìzhūjièshāshàngèrrényāo zhèngshuìmèngjiāntīngdeyǒurénjiàomíngjiùfānshēntáitóuguānkànzhǐjiànyúnduānshìzhūjièshāshàngèrrényāo

In the midst of sleep and dream he heard someone calling his name; he turned over, raised his head to look, and saw that up in the clouds it was the two, Zhu Bajie and Sha the Monk, hallooing.

睡夢間, shuì mèng jiān, in the middle of sleep; 吆喝, yāo he, to shout, to halloo — a rough, carrying sort of noise, exactly what wakes a man who does not want to be woken.

yāoguàixīnzhōngànxiǎngdào:「zhūjiè便biànleshāshàngshìbǎngzàijiāzěnmechūlái yāoguàixīnzhōngànxiǎngdào:「zhūjiè便biànleshāshàngshìbǎngzàijiāzěnmechūlái

The fiend thought secretly in his heart, "Zhu Bajie, well and good; but Sha the Monk I bound fast at home — how has he got out?

And now the novel does something it does rarely and well: it lets the adversary think. 暗想, àn xiǎng, to reason inwardly; , bǎng, to bind; 得出來, dé chū lái, to manage to get out, with read . His first objection is a good one.

dehúnjiāzěnmekěnfàng dehúnjiāzěnmekěnfàng

How should my wife be willing to release him?

渾家, hún jiā, is the ordinary colloquial word for "my wife" — homely rather than grand, and he uses it throughout. His second objection is also good.

deháiérzěnmedàoshǒu deháiérzěnmedàoshǒu

And how should my children have come into his hands?

His third: 得到, dé dào, to come into somebody's hands. Three sound reasons in three lines, and every one of them correct.

zhèshìzhūjièchūjiāozhànjiānglái zhèshìzhūjièchūjiāozhànjiānglái

This is likely that Zhu Bajie, unable to get me out to fight him, has hit upon this device to snare me forth.

So he reaches the right conclusion for the right reasons — and it does him no good at all. 不得, bù dé, unable to; , , to tether, to snare; 將此計, jiāng cǐ jì, by means of this device.

ruòrènlezhèfàntóujiùa ruòrènlezhèfàntóujiùa

If I take this bait, I shall have to fight him.

認泛頭, rèn fàn tóu, to swallow a bait — a 泛頭 being a trumped-up pretext, a lure floated out to see who bites.


總評 Commentary

The passage turns to the demon's interior and finds him no fool. His drunken doze broken by the shouting, he reasons shrewdly through the improbabilities — Sha Seng bound, his wife loyal, the children safe — and rightly suspects a lure to draw him out of his stronghold. Letting an adversary have a moment of genuine mind is a favourite device of the novel, and here it raises the stakes by showing the trap very nearly seen through.

His hesitation over whether to take the bait poises the episode on a knife-edge, and prepares the decisive consideration of the next passage, where a hangover and a fear of losing face tip him toward the fatal course of going home to check. That his very caution walks him into the deeper snare is the fine irony the whole sequence is built on.