Canonical Classics ← 第三十一回
第三十一回
zhūjièhóuwáng
sūnxíngzhězhìxiángyāoguài

Zhu Bajie, Roused by Duty, Provokes the Monkey King · Sun the Pilgrim, by Wit, Subdues the Fiend

父子之仇
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

父子之仇 A Teacher for a Day

xíngzhědào:「zhèguàizhīwéishīzhōngshēnwéi』?『宿zhīchóu』?shānghàishīzěnmeláijiùhài便biànquèyòubèiqiánmiànhòushìzěndeshuō?」yāoguàidào:「cháng?」xíngzhědào:「shìzhūjièshuōde。」guàidào:「yàoxìnzhūjièjiānzhezuǐyǒuxiēhuìshuōlǎoshétóuzěntīng?」xíngzhědào:「zhèguàizhīwéishīzhōngshēnwéi』?『宿zhīchóu』?shānghàishīzěnmeláijiùhài便biànquèyòubèiqiánmiànhòushìzěndeshuō?」yāoguàidào:「cháng?」xíngzhědào:「shìzhūjièshuōde。」guàidào:「yàoxìnzhūjièjiānzhezuǐyǒuxiēhuìshuōlǎoshétóuzěntīng?」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhědào:「zhèguàizhīwéishīzhōngshēnwéi』? xíngzhědào:「zhèguàizhīwéishīzhōngshēnwéi』?

Pilgrim said, "You vile fiend — what should you know of 'a teacher for a single day is a father for a lifetime'?

And here the proverb comes back. 一日為師終身為父 — "a teacher for a single day is a father for a lifetime" — is the exact line Bajie used on him near the start of the chapter, quoting the White Dragon Horse. Wukong was moved by it there; he wields it as a weapon here.

宿zhīchóu』? 宿zhīchóu』?

Or of 'between father and son no grudge lasts overnight'?

The second maxim follows from the first. 父子無隔宿之仇, fù zǐ wú gé sù zhī chóu, "between father and son no grudge lasts overnight" — 隔宿, gé sù, over a night. Having made Tripitaka a father by the first proverb, he uses the second to cancel the quarrel. It is a neat piece of reasoning, and it is also how he lets himself off having been thrown out.

shānghàishīzěnmeláijiù shānghàishīzěnmeláijiù

You have done my master harm — how should I not come to save him?

傷害, shāng hài: to injure, to do harm to.

hài便biàn hài便biàn

That you harmed him might be let pass—

便也罷, biàn yě bà, "that might have been let pass." Watch what he is about to say is worse than harming his master.

quèyòubèiqiánmiànhòushìzěndeshuō?」 quèyòubèiqiánmiànhòushìzěndeshuō?」

but that you should revile me behind my back and to my face besides — what account is there of that?"

背前面後, bèi qián miàn hòu, behind the back and to the face alike — the same phrase he used on the crag. Kidnapping Tripitaka was forgivable; the insult was not. The chapter has been honest about this from the start.

yāoguàidào:「cháng?」 yāoguàidào:「cháng?」

The fiend said, "When did I ever revile you?"

何嘗, hé cháng, "when did I ever?" — and the answer, which only the reader knows, is never.

xíngzhědào:「shìzhūjièshuōde。」 xíngzhědào:「shìzhūjièshuōde。」

Pilgrim said, "It was Zhu Bajie who told me."

Six words, and the whole quarrel rests on them.

guàidào:「yàoxìn guàidào:「yàoxìn

The fiend said, "Do not believe him.

, xìn: to believe, to trust.

zhūjièjiānzhezuǐyǒuxiēhuìshuōlǎoshétóuzěntīng?」 zhūjièjiānzhezuǐyǒuxiēhuìshuōlǎoshétóuzěntīng?」

That Zhu Bajie, with his jutting snout, is something of a tale-bearer — how can you heed him?"

尖著嘴, jiān zhe zuǐ, with the snout stuck out — the "-ing" form. 老婆舌頭, lǎo pó shé tou, "an old wife's tongue," meaning idle gossip and tale-bearing. The demon's assessment of Bajie is not only shrewd, it is exactly right — and Wukong will not hear it.


總評 Commentary

Wukong grounds his return in two proverbs of the filial bond — the teacher who is a father for life, the father and son whose quarrels do not survive a night — the very commonplaces Bajie used on him at the start of the chapter, now turned outward as the justification of the rescue. The rhetoric dignifies what is, at bottom, a matter of wounded pride: he can forgive harm done to his master more readily than an insult to himself.

The turn to the reported insult exposes the true spring of his fury, and the demon's denial quietly confirms what the reader has known for fifty passages: the whole tirade was Bajie's invention. The fiend's counter, that Bajie is a tale-bearer with a gossip's tongue, is nearer the mark than he can possibly know, and gives the confrontation a last twist of irony before it turns to blows.