Canonical Classics ← 第三十一回
第三十一回
zhūjièhóuwáng
sūnxíngzhězhìxiángyāoguài

Zhu Bajie, Roused by Duty, Provokes the Monkey King · Sun the Pilgrim, by Wit, Subdues the Fiend

編詞誆怪
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

編詞誆怪 The Fabricated Tale

zuójìncháorènqīnzěnhuíláijīnzǎobèizhūjièjiéleshāshàngyòuliǎngháiérqiǎngshìgàogèngkěnráoshuōcháozhōngrènrènwàigōngzhèbànjiànháiéryòuzhīcúnwángyòujiànláijiājiàozěnshēngshězhǐzhùshāngxīntòng。」guàiwényánxīnzhōngdào:「zhēnshìdeérzi?」xíngzhědào:「zhèngshìbèizhūjièqiǎngle。」zuójìncháorènqīnzěnhuíláijīnzǎobèizhūjièjiéleshāshàngyòuliǎngháiérqiǎngshìgàogèngkěnráoshuōcháozhōngrènrènwàigōngzhèbànjiànháiéryòuzhīcúnwángyòujiànláijiājiàozěnshēngshězhǐzhùshāngxīntòng。」guàiwényánxīnzhōngdào:「zhēnshìdeérzi?」xíngzhědào:「zhèngshìbèizhūjièqiǎngle。」


逐句解 Line by line

zuójìncháorènqīnzěnhuílái zuójìncháorènqīnzěnhuílái

Yesterday you went to court to claim your kinship — why did you not come back?

進朝認親, jìn cháo rèn qīn, to go to court and claim kinship. The complaint begins as a wife's reproach, which is good technique: reproach first, catastrophe after.

jīnzǎobèizhūjièjiéleshāshàngyòuliǎngháiérqiǎngshìgàogèngkěnráo jīnzǎobèizhūjièjiéleshāshàngyòuliǎngháiérqiǎngshìgàogèngkěnráo

This morning Zhu Bajie carried off Sha the Monk by force, and seized my two children besides; for all my bitter pleading, he would not be moved.

Every detail is chosen to enrage. , jié, to seize by force, to rob; 苦告, kǔ gào, to plead bitterly. The blame is laid squarely on Bajie — the one member of the party the demon has beaten, and therefore the one he will want to beat again.

shuōcháozhōngrènrènwàigōngzhèbànjiànháiéryòuzhīcúnwángyòujiànláijiājiàozěnshēngshě shuōcháozhōngrènrènwàigōngzhèbànjiànháiéryòuzhīcúnwángyòujiànláijiājiàozěnshēngshě

He said he would take them to court to acknowledge their grandsire; this half-day I have not seen the children, nor know whether they live or die, and you too are not come home — how am I to bear the parting?

存亡, cún wáng, whether they live or die; 怎生割捨, zěn shēng gē shě, "how am I to bear the parting" — 割捨 is literally to cut something away from yourself. The fate of the children is left hanging, which is the cruellest possible way to leave it.

zhǐzhùshāngxīntòng。」 zhǐzhùshāngxīntòng。」

And so I could not stop this grieving and weeping."

止不住, zhǐ bu zhù, unable to stop; 傷心痛哭, shāng xīn tòng kū, to grieve and weep bitterly. He has been sobbing throughout the speech, which is how it is delivered.

guàiwényánxīnzhōngdào:「zhēnshìdeérzi?」 guàiwényánxīnzhōngdào:「zhēnshìdeérzi?」

The fiend, hearing this, in a great rage said, "Are they truly my sons?"

The bait is taken. 大怒, dà nù, great wrath — and the question he asks in it is a father's question.

xíngzhědào:「zhèngshìbèizhūjièqiǎngle。」 xíngzhědào:「zhèngshìbèizhūjièqiǎngle。」

Pilgrim said, "Just so — seized and carried off by Zhu Bajie."

搶去, qiǎng qù, snatched away. Two words in the princess's voice, and the demon's judgement is gone.


總評 Commentary

Wukong's fabricated account is a small masterwork of provocation, calculated in every particular to enrage. It lays the children's seizure squarely on Bajie, dwells on the mother's helpless pleading, and leaves their fate suspended between life and death. The false grief of the previous passage now finds its object, working on the demon's paternal feeling until tenderness turns to fury.

The eruption — "Are they truly my sons?" — is the hinge on which the trap turns, because it is rage on their behalf that will shortly draw the elixir out of his mouth. Wukong's flat confirmation, delivered in his wife's voice, completes the goading. The whole exchange is a study in how the pilgrim, denied a straight fight, wins by working on his enemy's heart.