Canonical Classics ← 第三十一回
第三十一回
zhūjièhóuwáng
sūnxíngzhězhìxiángyāoguài

Zhu Bajie, Roused by Duty, Provokes the Monkey King · Sun the Pilgrim, by Wit, Subdues the Fiend

不看僧面
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

不看僧面 For the Buddha’s Sake

xíngzhědào:「fánshìcuānsuōshìdehǎojiùyòuxúnlǎosūnzěndeyuánshuōláidàixiángleyāojīngbàolezhīchóujiùhuíde。」shāsēngjìnqiánguìxiàdào:「arényún:『kànsēngmiànkànmiàn。』xiōngzhǎngshìdàowànwàngjiùjiùruòshìmennéngjiùgǎnyuǎndeláifèngqǐng。」xíngzhědào:「fánshìcuānsuōshìdehǎojiùyòuxúnlǎosūnzěndeyuánshuōláidàixiángleyāojīngbàolezhīchóujiùhuíde。」shāsēngjìnqiánguìxiàdào:「arényún:『kànsēngmiànkànmiàn。』xiōngzhǎngshìdàowànwàngjiùjiùruòshìmennéngjiùgǎnyuǎndeláifèngqǐng。」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhědào:「fánshìcuānsuōshìdehǎojiùyòuxúnlǎosūnzěnde xíngzhědào:「fánshìcuānsuōshìdehǎojiùyòuxúnlǎosūnzěnde

Pilgrim said, "You, forever egging things on — you are his favourite, his prized disciple; if you will not save him, why come seeking old Sun?

攛唆, cuān suō, to instigate, to egg somebody on — and it is a fair charge, since it was Bajie who talked Tripitaka into the banishment in the first place. 得意, dé yì, favoured, prized: "his pet disciple," said with some acid.

yuánshuōláidàixiángleyāojīngbàolezhīchóujiùhuíde。」 yuánshuōláidàixiángleyāojīngbàolezhīchóujiùhuíde。」

I told you at the outset: once the fiend was subdued and the insult to me avenged, I would go back."

He is still holding to the terms he set on Flower-Fruit Mountain — subdue the fiend, avenge the insult, go home. ( once more xiáng.) Everyone in the scene knows he will not go, including him.

shāsēngjìnqiánguìxiàdào:「arényún:『kànsēngmiànkànmiàn。』 shāsēngjìnqiánguìxiàdào:「arényún:『kànsēngmiànkànmiàn。』

Sha Seng came forward and knelt, saying, "Brother, the ancients said: 'If not for the monk's sake, then for the Buddha's.'

So Sha Seng kneels and produces the winning proverb. 不看僧面看佛面, bù kàn sēng miàn kàn fó miàn — "if not for the monk's sake, then for the Buddha's" — is an appeal past the person who offended you to the thing he stands for. It is still in daily use, and it is exactly the right instrument here, because the person who offended Wukong is the monk in question.

xiōngzhǎngshìdàowànwàngjiùjiù xiōngzhǎngshìdàowànwàngjiùjiù

Since you, elder brother, are come to this place, I beg you a thousand times to save him.

兄長, xiōng zhǎng, "elder brother," respectfully — read zhǎng, senior.

ruòshìmennéngjiùgǎnyuǎndeláifèngqǐng。」 ruòshìmennéngjiùgǎnyuǎndeláifèngqǐng。」

Had we the power to save him ourselves, we should never have dared come so far to entreat you."

奉請, fèng qǐng, respectfully to entreat; 許遠, xǔ yuǎn, such a distance — the same phrase Bajie used of his fruitless walk in the first chapter of this quarrel. The concession is total: we came all that way because we cannot do it ourselves.


總評 Commentary

The plea comes round a second time, and Sha Seng makes it differently. Where Bajie wheedled, Sha Seng kneels and argues — and the proverb he reaches for is precisely the right tool, because it offers a way of doing a favour for a man you are still angry with. Look past the monk to the Buddha behind him. His own admission that the disciples simply cannot manage it is offered in the same spirit: humility used as leverage, and none the less sincere for that.

Wukong's grumbling reply, needling Bajie as the master's pampered favourite even while he recalls his own vow to leave once the demon was down, keeps the resolution suspended one beat longer for the sake of the comedy. But the appeals are cumulative and their logic is irresistible, and the passage brings the Great Sage to the edge of the relenting that the next one completes.