Canonical Classics ← 第三十一回
第三十一回
zhūjièhóuwáng
sūnxíngzhězhìxiángyāoguài

Zhu Bajie, Roused by Duty, Provokes the Monkey King · Sun the Pilgrim, by Wit, Subdues the Fiend

秤鉈壓斤
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

秤鉈壓斤 Small but of Substance

xíngzhěxiàodào:「yuánláiméiyǎnrènderényún:『尿suīpāosuījīnliǎngchèngtuósuīxiǎoqiānjīn。』menxiàngmàokōngyòngzǒukàngfēng穿chuānfèizhǒnghuǒxīnkōngdǐngményāoruǎnchīshígōngzánlǎosūnxiǎoxiǎojīnjié。」xíngzhěxiàodào:「yuánláiméiyǎnrènderényún:『尿suīpāosuījīnliǎngchèngtuósuīxiǎoqiānjīn。』menxiàngmàokōngyòngzǒukàngfēng穿chuānfèizhǒnghuǒxīnkōngdǐngményāoruǎnchīshígōngzánlǎosūnxiǎoxiǎojīnjié。」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhěxiàodào:「yuánláiméiyǎnrènderén xíngzhěxiàodào:「yuánláiméiyǎnrènderén

Pilgrim said with a laugh, "You have no eye for men, it seems, and cannot tell one person from another.

眼色, yǎn sè, an eye for judging people; 認不得, rèn bu de, unable to tell one from another. He is not offended, he is correcting her.

yún:『尿suīpāosuījīnliǎngchèngtuósuīxiǎoqiānjīn。』 yún:『尿suīpāosuījīnliǎngchèngtuósuīxiǎoqiānjīn。』

As the common saying goes: 'A piss-bladder, though large, has no weight; a steelyard-weight, though small, presses a thousand catties.'

The comeback is two market-stall proverbs, and they are still funny. 尿泡, suī pāo, a bladder — big and empty. Both characters take their coarse Ming vernacular readings here, suī and pāo, where standard modern Chinese would say niào pào. Against it the 秤鉈, chèng tuó, the little sliding weight on a steelyard balance, which will hold down a thousand catties. 斤兩, jīn liǎng, "catties and taels," is simply the word for weight.

menxiàngmàokōngyòngzǒukàngfēng穿chuānfèizhǒnghuǒxīnkōngdǐngményāoruǎnchīshígōng menxiàngmàokōngyòngzǒukàngfēng穿chuānfèizhǒnghuǒxīnkōngdǐngményāoruǎnchīshígōng

Those two are all show and no use: they breast the wind as they walk, they waste cloth on their clothes, they are hollow-hearted as a banked fire, soft at the crown and weak in the loins, and eat their food to no purpose.

Then he itemises his brothers, and the list is merciless. 相貌, xiàng mào, outward appearance; 抗風, kàng fēng, to breast the wind — they are so broad they have to push through it. 種火心空, zhǒng huǒ xīn kōng, hollow inside like a banked ember; 吃食無功, chī shí wú gōng, they eat to no good end. Wasting cloth on their clothes is the sort of complaint a household accountant would make.

zánlǎosūnxiǎoxiǎojīnjié。」 zánlǎosūnxiǎoxiǎojīnjié。」

But old Sun of ours, small though he is, is small and solid."

, zán, "us" — used familiarly of himself, the way a man says "yours truly." 斤節, jīn jié, compact and substantial, all in one solid piece. The whole argument in four characters: small, yes; slight, no.


總評 Commentary

Wukong's rejoinder turns the mockery over with a pair of marketplace proverbs — the empty bladder set against the little steelyard weight — answering scorn with wit in the plain coin of folk wisdom. He then repays her in kind, cataloguing his brothers' bulk as sheer useless show, breasting the wind, wasting cloth, hollow within, before claiming for himself the compact solidity the proverbs celebrate.

The passage is a fine instance of the novel's delight in common speech: its greatest hero argues in the idiom of pedlars and market stalls, and vindicates himself not by any display of power but by a homely truth about weight and worth. The comedy of scale — the small thing containing the mighty one — is the governing principle of Wukong's character, and here he states it himself, in the language of the street.