Canonical Classics ← 第八十回
第八十回
姹chà女nǚ育yù陽yáng求qiú配pèi偶ǒu
心xīn猿yuán護hù主zhǔ識shí妖yāo邪xié

The Fair Girl, Nursing the Yang, Seeks a Mate · The Mind-Ape, Guarding His Master, Knows a Fiend

也不得乾淨
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

也不得乾淨 What Harm Could It Bring

我wǒ老lǎo孫sūn也yě不bù得dé乾gān淨jìng,饒ráo我wǒ口kǒu能néng,怎zěn麼me折zhé辯biàn,也yě要yào問wèn個gè不bù應yīng。」三sān藏zàng喝hè道dào:「莫mò胡hú說shuō,終zhōng不bù然rán,我wǒ救jiù他tā性xìng命mìng,有yǒu甚shén貽yí累lěi不bù成chéng?我wǒ老lǎo孙sūn也yě不bù得dé干gān净jìng,饶ráo我wǒ口kǒu能néng,怎zěn么me折zhé辩biàn,也yě要yào问wèn个gè不bù应yīng。」三sān藏zàng喝hè道dào:「莫mò胡hú说shuō,终zhōng不bù然rán,我wǒ救jiù他tā性xìng命mìng,有yǒu甚shén贻yí累lěi不bù成chéng?


逐句解 Line by line

我wǒ老lǎo孫sūn也yě不bù得dé乾gān淨jìng,饒ráo我wǒ口kǒu能néng,怎zěn麼me折zhé辯biàn,也yě要yào問wèn個gè不bù應yīng。」 我wǒ老lǎo孙sūn也yě不bù得dé干gān净jìng,饶ráo我wǒ口kǒu能néng,怎zěn么me折zhé辩biàn,也yě要yào问wèn个gè不bù应yīng。」

and Old Monkey would not come out of it clean either. However good my mouth is, however I argued, they would still get me on doing what ought not to be done."

乾 is gān in 乾淨, clean and dry, not the qián of the first hexagram. And 不應 is a genuine article of the Ming code — doing what ought not to be done, the catch-all charge for conduct no other statute covered. Pilgrim has correctly identified that a talker always gets convicted under the vague clause.

三sān藏zàng喝hè道dào:「莫mò胡hú說shuō,終zhōng不bù然rán,我wǒ救jiù他tā性xìng命mìng,有yǒu甚shén貽yí累lěi不bù成chéng? 三sān藏zàng喝hè道dào:「莫mò胡hú说shuō,终zhōng不bù然rán,我wǒ救jiù他tā性xìng命mìng,有yǒu甚shén贻yí累lěi不bù成chéng?

Tripitaka shouted at him, "Talk no nonsense. Surely, if I save her life, what trouble could it possibly bring on us?

In 貽累 the 累 is lěi, to entangle somebody else in your trouble, not the lèi of being tired. Another bare 甚 as shén.


總評 Commentary

The catch-all clause is the best joke Pilgrim makes in the whole exchange, and it is funny because it is accurate. Every legal system has a provision for people the prosecutor dislikes, and he knows he is the sort of defendant it was written for.

His master's reply gives up on argument altogether and falls back on the shape of a rhetorical question. What trouble could it bring? He does not know. He has decided the answer is none, and he is asking in a tone that forbids anyone to supply another.