Canonical Classics ← 第四十五回
第四十五回
sānqīngguànshèngliúmíng
chēchíguóhóuwángxiǎn

At the Abbey of the Three Pure Ones the Great Sage leaves his name; in the Kingdom of Cart-Slow the Monkey King displays his magic.

我輩不能
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

我輩不能 “We Cannot”

dàoshìzěnmeyǒuyàngběnshìjiùjiàolóngwángjiànshèngzàigǎnchūtóudàoshìyún:「bèinéngshìjiàolái。」dàoshìzěnmeyǒuyàngběnshìjiùjiàolóngwángjiànshèngzàigǎnchūtóudàoshìyún:「bèinéngshìjiàolái。」


逐句解 Line by line

dàoshìzěnmeyǒuyàngběnshì dàoshìzěnmeyǒuyàngběnshì

How could those Daoists have any such power?

那道士 and 那樣: = . 本事 "ability, real skill" -- and the narrator asks the question rather than a character, which is the novel dropping the pretence of suspense.

jiùjiàolóngwángjiànshèngzàigǎnchūtóu jiùjiàolóngwángjiànshèngzàigǎnchūtóu

Even if they called, those Dragon Kings, seeing the Great Sage here, would not dare put out their heads.

那龍王: = . 不敢出頭: the third tone of keeps at -- "would not dare put their heads out." Even if the Daoists called correctly, the dragons would stay hidden, because the Great Sage is standing there.

dàoshìyún:「bèinéngshìjiàolái。」 dàoshìyún:「bèinéngshìjiàolái。」

The Daoist said, “We cannot do it — you call them.”

我輩不能: the rising tone of keeps at . 你是叫來 "you are the one to call them" -- four words of surrender, and the first honest thing any of the three has said.


總評 Commentary

The narrator answers the question before the immortals do: of course they cannot, and even if they could, the dragons would keep their heads down with the Great Sage watching.

"We cannot do it -- you call them." It is a complete capitulation, and it is worth noticing that they do not attempt a bluff. There is no point. This is the one claim in the whole dispute that gets tested the moment it is made.