Canonical Classics ← 第四十五回
第四十五回
三sān清qīng觀guàn大dà聖shèng留liú名míng
車chē遲chí國guó猴hóu王wáng顯xiǎn法fǎ

At the Abbey of the Three Pure Ones the Great Sage leaves his name; in the Kingdom of Cart-Slow the Monkey King displays his magic.

我輩不能
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

我輩不能 “We Cannot”

那nà道dào士shì怎zěn麼me有yǒu那nà樣yàng本běn事shì?就jiù叫jiào,那nà龍lóng王wáng見jiàn大dà聖shèng在zài此cǐ,也yě不bù敢gǎn出chū頭tóu。道dào士shì云yún:「我wǒ輩bèi不bù能néng,你nǐ是shì叫jiào來lái。」那nà道dào士shì怎zěn么me有yǒu那nà样yàng本běn事shì?就jiù叫jiào,那nà龙lóng王wáng见jiàn大dà圣shèng在zài此cǐ,也yě不bù敢gǎn出chū头tóu。道dào士shì云yún:「我wǒ辈bèi不bù能néng,你nǐ是shì叫jiào来lái。」


逐句解 Line by line

那nà道dào士shì怎zěn麼me有yǒu那nà樣yàng本běn事shì? 那nà道dào士shì怎zěn么me有yǒu那nà样yàng本běn事shì?

How could those Daoists have any such power?

那道士 and 那樣: 那 = nà. 本事 "ability, real skill" -- and the narrator asks the question rather than a character, which is the novel dropping the pretence of suspense.

就jiù叫jiào,那nà龍lóng王wáng見jiàn大dà聖shèng在zài此cǐ,也yě不bù敢gǎn出chū頭tóu。 就jiù叫jiào,那nà龙lóng王wáng见jiàn大dà圣shèng在zài此cǐ,也yě不bù敢gǎn出chū头tóu。

Even if they called, those Dragon Kings, seeing the Great Sage here, would not dare put out their heads.

那龍王: 那 = nà. 不敢出頭: the third tone of 敢 keeps 不 at bù -- "would not dare put their heads out." Even if the Daoists called correctly, the dragons would stay hidden, because the Great Sage is standing there.

道dào士shì云yún:「我wǒ輩bèi不bù能néng,你nǐ是shì叫jiào來lái。」 道dào士shì云yún:「我wǒ辈bèi不bù能néng,你nǐ是shì叫jiào来lái。」

The Daoist said, “We cannot do it — you call them.”

我輩不能: the rising tone of 能 keeps 不 at bù. 你是叫來 "you are the one to call them" -- four words of surrender, and the first honest thing any of the three has said.


總評 Commentary

The narrator answers the question before the immortals do: of course they cannot, and even if they could, the dragons would keep their heads down with the Great Sage watching.

"We cannot do it -- you call them." It is a complete capitulation, and it is worth noticing that they do not attempt a bluff. There is no point. This is the one claim in the whole dispute that gets tested the moment it is made.