Canonical Classics ← 第八十五回
第八十五回
xīnyuán
zhǔtūnchán

The Mind-Ape Envies the Wood Mother · The Fiend Lord Plots to Swallow the Chan

不得自專
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

不得自專 The Son May Not Act Alone

xíngzhědào:「xiōngshūyún:『zàizhuān。』shīyòuzàishuígǎnxiān?」xíngzhědào:「xiōngshūyún:『zàizhuān。』shīyòuzàishuígǎnxiān?」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhědào:「xiōng xíngzhědào:「xiōng

Pilgrim said, "Brother, do not raise it.

He refuses, which is the last thing needed to make his brother determined. 莫題, do not bring it up, is the same verb the narrator uses when dropping a thread of the story.

shūyún:『zàizhuān。』 shūyún:『zàizhuān。』

The old books say: while the father lives, the son may not act on his own authority.

is here, the son — a full noun in a classical quotation, not the weak zi that ends a colloquial word like blockhead. In 不得 the is , the modal may. The shape is 不得 in front of a verb, not after one, and the two read differently. The line paraphrases a rule from the Book of Rites about a son's independence while his father lives.

shīyòuzàishuígǎnxiān?」 shīyòuzàishuígǎnxiān?」

And the master is right here. Who would dare go on ahead?"

He applies the classical rule to the pilgrimage, casting Tripitaka as the father. It is a real argument, correctly used, deployed entirely in bad faith.


總評 Commentary

Pilgrim quoting the classics to stop his brother doing the thing he wants his brother to do is the best-built move in the chapter. The refusal is what makes it irresistible.

It also puts the fault somewhere useful. If Bajie goes now, he goes in defiance of a quoted rule, which means that when he comes back beaten there is a ready answer for why he has no case.