Canonical Classics ← 第八十五回
第八十五回
xīnyuán
zhǔtūnchán

The Mind-Ape Envies the Wood Mother · The Fiend Lord Plots to Swallow the Chan

這獃子胡說
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

這獃子胡說 The Blockhead Talks Nonsense

xíngzhězàipángxiàodào:「zhèdāizishuōruòzuòlezéijiùpānshàngláorénshìzàizhèkànzheshīcéng?」xíngzhězàipángxiàodào:「zhèdāizishuōruòzuòlezéijiùpānshàngláorénshìzàizhèkànzheshīcéng?」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhězàipángxiàodào:「zhèdāizishuō xíngzhězàipángxiàodào:「zhèdāizishuō

Pilgrim, standing by, laughed. "The blockhead is talking nonsense.

is páng, at the side — the same character is bàng when it means to lean on something. Five characters of denial against a completely accurate account.

ruòzuòlezéijiùpānshàngláorén ruòzuòlezéijiùpānshàngláorén

Turn thief and you will drag a whole gaolful of people in with you.

is to pull somebody down with you — specifically, in legal language, to implicate a person under interrogation. 一牢人 is a prison's worth of them. He is calling his brother the kind of criminal who informs on everybody, which does not answer the charge at all.

shìzàizhèkànzheshīcéng?」 shìzàizhèkànzheshīcéng?」

I have been here minding the master. When did I ever step aside?"

is zhe, minding and going on minding. 何曾 is the rhetorical when ever — meaning never, and is céng, at any time past. The statement is false, and the hair that made it look true has already been reabsorbed.


總評 Commentary

Three moves in thirty-five characters: dismiss the witness, attack his character, assert an alibi. Not one of them engages with what he actually did.

The alibi is the interesting one, because it is technically supportable. Something wearing his face did stand there the whole time, and he is the only person who knows it was a hair.