Canonical Classics ← 第八十一回
第八十一回
zhènhǎixīnyuánzhīguài
hēisōnglínsānzhòngxúnshī

At the Sea-Calming Monastery the Mind-Ape Knows the Fiend · In the Black Pine Wood the Three Seek Their Master

在這寺裡
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

在這寺裡 A Fiend Inside The Monastery

xíngzhědào:「jiàoquèwèishénme?」zhòngsēngdào:「lǎozhīshìshānláideyāoxiézàizhèxíngzhědào:「jiàoquèwèishénme?」zhòngsēngdào:「lǎozhīshìshānláideyāoxiézàizhè


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhědào:「jiàoquèwèishénme?」 xíngzhědào:「jiàoquèwèishénme?」

Pilgrim said, "If you are not reckoning it up, then what are you weeping for?"

is wèi here, for what reason, and is shén — the two together give the ordinary word for why.

zhòngsēngdào:「lǎozhīshìshānláideyāoxiézàizhè zhòngsēngdào:「lǎozhīshìshānláideyāoxiézàizhè

The monks said, "Your reverence, we do not know from which mountain the fiend has come that is here in this monastery."

is , which — they genuinely do not know its origin, so this is a real question word and not a pointing one.


總評 Commentary

At last. Pilgrim finally asks the right question, and the answer lands in nineteen characters.

The phrasing is precise about the limits of what they know. Not a fiend from the mountain, but a fiend from they-know-not-which mountain — they have worked out what is happening without ever having seen it.

For the reader this is not news. We have known since the first line of the chapter, and have watched her be given a straw bed behind the guardian kings. The monks are telling Pilgrim something we have been waiting eighty passages for him to notice.