行者實供 The Pilgrim Confesses the Theft
三藏道:「徒弟息怒。我們是出家人,休打誑語,莫吃昧心食。果然吃了他的,陪他個禮罷,何苦這般抵賴?」行者見師父說得有理,他就實說道:「師父,不干我事。是八戒隔壁聽見那兩個道童吃甚麼人參果,他想一個兒嘗新,著老孫去打了三個,我兄弟各人吃了一個。如今吃也吃了,待要怎麼?」明月道:「偷了我四個,這和尚還說不是賊哩。」八戒道:「阿彌陀佛!既是偷了四個,怎麼只拿出三個來分,預先就打起一個偏手?」那獃子倒轉胡嚷。三藏道:「徒弟息怒。我们是出家人,休打诳语,莫吃昧心食。果然吃了他的,陪他个礼罢,何苦这般抵赖?」行者见师父说得有理,他就实说道:「师父,不干我事。是八戒隔壁听见那两个道童吃甚么人参果,他想一个儿尝新,着老孙去打了三个,我兄弟各人吃了一个。如今吃也吃了,待要怎么?」明月道:「偷了我四个,这和尚还说不是贼哩。」八戒道:「阿弥陀佛!既是偷了四个,怎么只拿出三个来分,预先就打起一个偏手?」那呆子倒转胡嚷。
逐句解 Line by line
Sanzang said, "Disciple, let your anger cool.
The master's first move is always to cool the room. 息怒 is xī nù, "rest your anger."
"We are men who have left the household life. Utter no lying words, and eat no food that shames the conscience.
Sanzang answers a shouting match with the rulebook. 出家人, chū jiā rén, is one who has "left the household" — the ordinary term for a monk or nun. 誑語, kuáng yǔ, is false speech, one of the gravest breaches of the monastic precepts. 昧心 is mèi xīn, "to darken the heart": food eaten 昧心 is food your conscience knows you should not be eating.
"If you truly ate them, then make him a proper apology and have done—why keep up this stubborn denial?"
陪他個禮, péi tā gè lǐ, is to make him a formal apology; the verb 陪…禮, péi lǐ, is also written 賠禮. 抵賴, dǐ lài, is to deny a fault flat out — still the word today for someone caught red-handed and brazening it out.
The Pilgrim, seeing that his master spoke with reason, then told the truth: "Master, the fault is not mine.
Reason works on Wukong where scolding never does. 說得有理, shuō de yǒu lǐ, is "spoke sense," with the toneless linking 得, de. 不干我事, bù gān wǒ shì, is "none of my business," and it is still exactly how you say that.
"It was Bajie who, through the wall, heard those two Daoist lads eating some ginseng fruit or other. He took a fancy to try one for its novelty and had me, old Sun, go knock down three; we three brothers ate one apiece.
The confession is exact: he names the instigator, the count, and who ate what. 隔壁, gé bì, is "through the wall" — Bajie was eavesdropping from next door. 著 here is zhuó, the verb "to have someone do something," and this character is the chapter's great chameleon: zhe when it marks an action still going on, zháo when it marks one that has hit its target, zhuó when it sends somebody off on an errand, as here. 嘗新, cháng xīn, is trying something for the novelty of it.
"Now that they are eaten and gone, what would you have us do about it?"
吃也吃了 shrugs the whole thing off: eaten is eaten. 待要, dài yào, is not "want to" here but a rhetorical "so what would you have me do about it?"
Bright Moon said, "He stole four of mine, and still this monk says he is no thief!"
Bright Moon corrects the count upward — four, not three. 還 is the adverb hái, "still, even so," not the huán of 還丹, the "reverted elixir" that will shortly give the tree its grandest name. The 哩 at the end is li, a particle that plants a sentence firmly, something like "and there he stands saying…"
Bajie said, "Amitābha!
阿彌陀佛 is Ēmítuó Fó, the Buddha Amitābha, whose name gets used the way an English speaker says "Lord have mercy" — piety as punctuation. In the mouth of the pig who ate the missing fourth fruit, it is the best-timed prayer in the book.
"Since four were stolen, how is it that only three were brought out to share—did you not palm off one for yourself beforehand?"
Here is the joke. Bajie ate the fourth fruit himself, and now he uses the boys' own count to accuse Wukong of holding one back. 分 is the verb fēn, "to share out," not the noun fèn, "a portion, one's lot." 偏手, piān shǒu, is skimming a bit off the top before the split — the cut a dishonest middleman takes.
So the blockhead turned the tables and blustered on.
獃子, dāi zi, "blockhead," is the narrator's fixed label for Bajie, used the way a sitcom keeps one running nickname per character. 倒轉 is dào zhuǎn, "to flip it round," the guilty man turning prosecutor; note that 倒 is dào for "reverse" but dǎo in 推倒, "to topple," which is what Wukong is about to do to the tree. 胡嚷, hú rǎng, is blustering noise.
Wukong's confession is a small marvel of exactness. He names the instigator (Bajie, listening at the wall), the count (three knocked down, one apiece), and disclaims the surplus. It is the trickster telling plain truth — and he only does it once his master has stopped scolding and appealed instead to the precept against lying.
Then Bajie opens his mouth. He ate the uncounted fourth fruit; he now pivots to accuse the boys of skimming a share, and prefaces the accusation with the name of the Buddha. The guilty party is loudest in the reckoning, which is a joke old enough to be permanent. The narrator lets it stand without comment beyond a dry 那獃子倒轉胡嚷, "the blockhead turned the tables and blustered on."
Note what has and has not happened. Four fruits are gone and everyone now knows it; the master has offered an apology on his disciples' behalf; the boys have their confession. This is the last moment in the chapter when the quarrel could still have been settled by saying sorry.