Canonical Classics ← 第二十五回
第二十五回
zhènyuánxiāngǎnzhuōjīngsēng
sūnxíngzhěnàozhuāngguàn

The Immortal Zhenyuan Pursues and Seizes the Scripture-Seeking Monk · Sun the Pilgrim Makes Great Havoc at the Five-Villages Abbey

推倒仙根
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

推倒仙根 The Ginseng Tree Cast Down

dezhēnshēnchūshénzòngyúntóutiàojiāngjìngdàorénshēnyuánchèjīnbàngwǎngshùshàngpīngpāngxiàyòu使shǐtuīshānlǐngdeshénshùtuītuīdǎoliánluòkāigēnchūdàorénduànjuécǎohuándānshèngtuīdǎoshùzàizhīérshàngxúnguǒziyǒubànyuánláizhèbǎobèijīnérluòdebàngliǎngtóushìjīnguǒdekuàngtiěyòushìjīnzhīlèisuǒqiāozhejiùzhènxiàláixiàláiyòuéryīnshàngbiānzàiméiguǒzidào:「hǎohǎohǎojiāsànhuǒ。」shōuletiěbàngjìngwǎngqiánláiháomáodǒushōushàngshēnláixiērénròuyǎnfántāikànmíngbáidezhēnshēnchūshénzòngyúntóutiàojiāngjìngdàorénshēnyuánchèjīnbàngwǎngshùshàngpīngpāngxiàyòu使shǐtuīshānlǐngdeshénshùtuītuīdǎoliánluòkāigēnchūdàorénduànjuécǎohuándānshèngtuīdǎoshùzàizhīérshàngxúnguǒziyǒubànyuánláizhèbǎobèijīnérluòdebàngliǎngtóushìjīnguǒdekuàngtiěyòushìjīnzhīlèisuǒqiāozhejiùzhènxiàláixiàláiyòuéryīnshàngbiānzàiméiguǒzidào:「hǎohǎohǎojiāsànhuǒ。」shōuletiěbàngjìngwǎngqiánláiháomáodǒushōushàngshēnláixiērénròuyǎnfántāikànmíngbái


逐句解 Line by line

dezhēnshēnchūshénzòngyúntóutiàojiāngjìngdàorénshēnyuánchèjīnbàngwǎngshùshàngpīngpāngxiàyòu使shǐtuīshānlǐngdeshénshùtuītuīdǎo dezhēnshēnchūshénzòngyúntóutiàojiāngjìngdàorénshēnyuánchèjīnbàngwǎngshùshàngpīngpāngxiàyòu使shǐtuīshānlǐngdeshénshùtuītuīdǎo

His true self sent forth a divided spirit; springing onto a cloud-head, he leapt up and away and made straight for the ginseng garden. Drawing the gold-banded cudgel, he dealt the tree a resounding blow—ping! pang!—and then, calling up the strength to push over mountains and shift ranges, he set his shoulder to the tree and toppled it clean over.

出一個神, chū yí gè shén, is sending a spirit out of the body so that the real self can act while the decoy sits still. 縱雲頭, zòng yún tóu, is springing up onto a cloud. The blow lands with a plain 乒乓, pīng pāng; then comes 推山移嶺, tuī shān yí lǐng, "push over mountains and shift the ranges," a stock phrase for enormous strength.

liánluòkāigēnchūdàorénduànjuécǎohuándān liánluòkāigēnchūdàorénduànjuécǎohuándān

Pitiful!—the leaves fell, the boughs split wide, the roots were heaved from the soil, and the Daoists' herb of the reverted elixir was cut off at the source.

The narrator stops the prose here and drops into two balanced seven-character lines, cued by 可憐, kě lián — "the pity of it." 草還丹, cǎo huán dān, is the tree's alchemical name, the "herb of the reverted elixir": 還丹, huán dān, is cinnabar cycled through the furnace and brought back purified, the great prize of Daoist alchemy. So is huán, "to return," not the everyday adverb hái. Giving the tree its loftiest title at the exact moment it falls is the storyteller twisting the knife.

shèngtuīdǎoshùzàizhīérshàngxúnguǒziyǒubàn shèngtuīdǎoshùzàizhīérshàngxúnguǒziyǒubàn

Once the Great Sage had toppled the tree, he searched the branches for the fruit—but where was there to be found even half a one?

Two in one sentence, read two different ways. 那大聖 is , "that," simply pointing. 那裡得有半個 is , a question used as a flat denial — "where would there be even half a one?" meaning there were none — with as , "could." Modern Chinese splits these between and ; Ming printing let one character do both jobs.

yuánláizhèbǎobèijīnérluòdebàngliǎngtóushìjīnguǒdekuàngtiěyòushìjīnzhīlèisuǒqiāozhejiùzhènxiàláixiàláiyòuér yuánláizhèbǎobèijīnérluòdebàngliǎngtóushìjīnguǒdekuàngtiěyòushìjīnzhīlèisuǒqiāozhejiùzhènxiàláixiàláiyòuér

For it turned out that these treasures drop at the touch of metal; and as both ends of his cudgel are sheathed in gold—and iron, besides, belongs to the five metals—so at a blow they were shaken down; and once down, meeting earth, they sank straight into it.

This is the chapter's bit of invented physics, and it is worked out with real care. The fruit's rule is 遇金而落, yù jīn ér luò, "meets metal and falls," and once down, 遇土而入, it sinks into earth. Wukong's cudgel is capped with gold at both ends, and iron counts among the 五金, wǔ jīn, the five metals: gold, silver, copper, iron and tin. So every blow both shakes fruit loose and dooms it. This is the 五行 system of five agents applied as engineering. 敲著 takes as zhe, marking the action in progress.

yīnshàngbiānzàiméiguǒzi yīnshàngbiānzàiméiguǒzi

And so on the ground above there was left not a single fruit.

上邊, shàng biān, "up above" — the tree and the surface of the ground, as against everything now swallowed underneath.

dào:「hǎohǎohǎo dào:「hǎohǎohǎo

He said, "Good, good, good!

The triple is Wukong's tic when something has gone exactly as badly as he wanted. Listen for it again when the lacquer comes out.

jiāsànhuǒ。」 jiāsànhuǒ。」

"Now let everyone's fire die down."

散火, sàn huǒ, is colloquial for breaking up a gathering and letting the heat go out of a quarrel: show's over, everyone go home. He says it having just made the quarrel unfixable.

shōuletiěbàngjìngwǎngqiánláiháomáodǒushōushàngshēnlái shōuletiěbàngjìngwǎngqiánláiháomáodǒushōushàngshēnlái

He put away the iron cudgel, came straight back to the front, gave the hair a shake, and drew it up onto his body once more.

One shake and the decoy is a hair again, back on his body. Every hair-transformation ends this way; it is the magic's tidying-up.

xiērénròuyǎnfántāikànmíngbái xiērénròuyǎnfántāikànmíngbái

Those others, with their fleshly eyes and mortal frames, saw nothing of it clearly.

肉眼凡胎, ròu yǎn fán tāi — "eyes of flesh, a womb-born frame" — is the standard phrase for people who simply cannot see what is going on in front of them. The sting is that it covers the pilgrims too: Sanzang, Bajie and Wujing sat there through the whole errand and noticed nothing.


總評 Commentary

The felling is narrated with a strange precision. The manfruit drops at the touch of metal and vanishes into earth, so a metal-capped cudgel both dislodges every fruit on the tree and guarantees that none can be recovered. Metal fells, earth swallows: the five-agents system, usually a scheme for thinking about the cosmos, is here used as plain mechanics, and it explains why the boys will not find so much as half a fruit left.

The single verse line is where the storyteller shows his hand. He calls the tree 草還丹, "herb of the reverted elixir," its highest alchemical title, in the same breath as he reports its roots coming out of the ground — and prefaces it with 可憐, "the pity of it," so the reader feels the size of the loss a beat before the two boys do.

Then the tone drops straight back down. 大家散火 — good, good, good, everyone go home — is petty triumph in a handful of words, and the mismatch between what has just been destroyed and how casually he says it is the whole of Wukong's character in this chapter.