Canonical Classics ← 第八十六回
第八十六回
木mù母mǔ助zhù威wēi征zhēng怪guài物wù
金jīn公gōng施shī法fǎ滅miè妖yāo邪xié

The Wood Mother Lends His Strength to Fight the Monster · The Metal Lord Works His Art to Destroy the Fiend

山場平處
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

山場平處 Which One Is Your Chief

這zhè大dà聖shèng與yǔ八bā戒jiè急jí退tuì幾jǐ步bù,到dào那nà山shān場chǎng平píng處chù,抵dǐ住zhù群qún妖yāo,喝hè道dào:「那nǎ個gè是shì出chū名míng的de頭tóu兒ér?那nǎ個gè是shì拿ná我wǒ師shī父fù的de妖yāo怪guài?」这zhè大dà圣shèng与yǔ八bā戒jiè急jí退tuì几jǐ步bù,到dào那nà山shān场chǎng平píng处chù,抵dǐ住zhù群qún妖yāo,喝hè道dào:「那nǎ个gè是shì出chū名míng的de头tóu儿ér?那nǎ个gè是shì拿ná我wǒ师shī父fù的de妖yāo怪guài?」


逐句解 Line by line

這zhè大dà聖shèng與yǔ八bā戒jiè急jí退tuì幾jǐ步bù,到dào那nà山shān場chǎng平píng處chù,抵dǐ住zhù群qún妖yāo,喝hè道dào:「那nǎ個gè是shì出chū名míng的de頭tóu兒ér? 这zhè大dà圣shèng与yǔ八bā戒jiè急jí退tuì几jǐ步bù,到dào那nà山shān场chǎng平píng处chù,抵dǐ住zhù群qún妖yāo,喝hè道dào:「那nǎ个gè是shì出chū名míng的de头tóu儿ér?

The Great Sage and Bajie fell back a few quick paces to a level place on the mountain clearing, held the pack of fiends off, and shouted, "Which of you is the chief they all talk about?

Falling back to level ground is a real tactical choice and the novel treats it as one. 山場 is a clearing on a hillside — a genuine place, so 場 keeps the ordinary chǎng here, and the same character will take a different reading a few passages on where it counts a bout of fighting instead. 那 is nǎ, which — a question, not a pointing word.

那nǎ個gè是shì拿ná我wǒ師shī父fù的de妖yāo怪guài?」 那nǎ个gè是shì拿ná我wǒ师shī父fù的de妖yāo怪guài?」

Which is the fiend that took my master?"

The second 那 is nǎ as well. Wukong asks two questions and they are not the same question: who is in charge, and who did it. He is expecting two different answers and he will get one creature claiming both.


總評 Commentary

Wukong's two questions are a piece of professional practice. Identify the commander, identify the culprit, and if they are the same creature the fight is simple. He has done this in dozens of chapters and it usually works.

The retreat to level ground is worth a moment. Wukong could fight anywhere. Bajie could not, and Wukong is picking the terrain for his brother without saying so.