Canonical Classics ← 第八十六回
第八十六回
zhùwēizhēngguài
jīngōngshīmièyāoxié

The Wood Mother Lends His Strength to Fight the Monster · The Metal Lord Works His Art to Destroy the Fiend

還省柴
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

還省柴 Boiling Him Saves Firewood

yòushuō:「zhǔlechīháishěngchái。」yòudào:「běnshìzhīháizhuóxiēyánéryānyānchīdechángjiǔ。」xíngzhězàiliángzhōngtīngjiànxīnzhōngdào:「shīyǒushénqíngzhèbānsuànchī?」yòushuō:「zhǔlechīháishěngchái。」yòudào:「běnshìzhīháizhuóxiēyánéryānyānchīdechángjiǔ。」xíngzhězàiliángzhōngtīngjiànxīnzhōngdào:「shīyǒushénqíngzhèbānsuànchī?」


逐句解 Line by line

yòushuō:「zhǔlechīháishěngchái。」 yòushuō:「zhǔlechīháishěngchái。」

Another said, "Boiling him saves firewood."

Ten characters, and the argument has reached economics. is shěng, to save or economise — the chapter's only occurrence of this character, and it is being used to make a point about fuel.

yòudào:「běnshìzhīháizhuóxiēyánéryānyānchīdechángjiǔ。」 yòudào:「běnshìzhīháizhuóxiēyánéryānyānchīdechángjiǔ。」

Another said, "He is a rare article after all. Put some salt on him and cure him and he will keep a long time."

著些鹽兒 takes as zhuó, to apply — one of only three places in the chapter that reading is right. 吃得長久 again takes as cháng for duration. The proposal is to treat him as preserved stock, which is exactly what the strips drying in the sun outside already are.

xíngzhězàiliángzhōngtīngjiànxīnzhōngdào:「shīyǒushénqíngzhèbānsuànchī?」 xíngzhězàiliángzhōngtīngjiànxīnzhōngdào:「shīyǒushénqíngzhèbānsuànchī?」

Pilgrim, hearing this from up in the beams, was greatly enraged in his heart and said, "What deadly grudge has my master with you, that you should plot to eat him like this?"

appears twice in this line at its ordinary reading, inside the beams and inside the heart, against the four places in this chapter where the same character means struck by something. is shén, what — Wukong's question is rhetorical and it is also, for him, a real one.


總評 Commentary

Four fiends, four proposals: fry, steam, boil, cure. It is a genuine culinary discussion with genuine trade-offs — flavour against fuel against shelf life — and the subject of it is tied to a tree in the garden.

Wukong's fury takes an odd shape. He does not ask how they dare; he asks what grudge they have. He is looking for a motive, and there is not one. They want to eat his teacher because eating him is useful, and that is all.