Canonical Classics ← 第六十八回
第六十八回
zhūguótángsēnglùnqiánshì
sūnxíngzhěshīwéisānzhégōng

At Purpuria the Tang Monk Discourses on a Former Life · Pilgrim Sun Practises as a Thrice-Broken Arm

不曾眼見
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

不曾眼見 Heard Of But Never Seen

zhòngguānàndào:「xuánzhěnmàiděngěrwéncéngyǎnjiànzàizòulái。」jìnshìdeyòugōngzòudào:「zhǔgōngsūnzhǎnglǎojiànzhǔgōngzhīmiànhuìxuánzhěnmài。」zhòngguānàndào:「xuánzhěnmàiděngěrwéncéngyǎnjiànzàizòulái。」jìnshìdeyòugōngzòudào:「zhǔgōngsūnzhǎnglǎojiànzhǔgōngzhīmiànhuìxuánzhěnmài。」


逐句解 Line by line

zhòngguānàndào:「xuánzhěnmàiděngěrwéncéngyǎnjiàn zhòngguānàndào:「xuánzhěnmàiděngěrwéncéngyǎnjiàn

The officers said with secret delight, "Taking the pulse by threads — we have heard of it with our ears, but never seen it with our eyes.

耳聞 against 不曾眼見: heard with the ear, never seen with the eye. Two organs, four characters each, and the balance is the whole of their scepticism.

zàizòulái。」 zàizòulái。」

"Let us report it again."

Four characters. 去來 pairs two words of motion to mean simply 'go'; the second carries no direction of its own.

jìnshìdeyòugōngzòudào:「zhǔgōngsūnzhǎnglǎojiànzhǔgōngzhīmiànhuìxuánzhěnmài。」 jìnshìdeyòugōngzòudào:「zhǔgōngsūnzhǎnglǎojiànzhǔgōngzhīmiànhuìxuánzhěnmài。」

The attendant went into the palace again and reported, "Your Majesty — the Elder Sun need not see Your Majesty's face. He can take the pulse by hanging threads."

reads at both sites, and is zhǎng in 孫長老.


總評 Commentary

Secret delight, the narrator says. The officers are not persuaded and they are not sceptical either — they want to watch. A famous technique that nobody in the room has ever witnessed is about to be performed on their sovereign, and their first response is curiosity.

The report that goes in has been quietly improved on the way. Pilgrim said he could work without seeing the face; the attendant tells the king that the Elder need not see it, which turns a capability into a reassurance.