Canonical Classics ← 第八十七回
第八十七回
fèngxiānjùnmàotiānzhìhàn
sūnshèngquànshànshīlín

Fengxian Prefecture Offends Heaven and Brings Drought · The Great Sage Sun Urges Goodness and Bestows Rain

豈敢推託
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

豈敢推託 How Would I Dare Refuse

xíngzhědào:「yīnguòfāngjiànjiǔhànmínzhuóláishīqiútuītuō?」lóngwángdào:「gǎntuītuōdànshèngniànzhēnyánhuàngǎnláixíngzhědào:「yīnguòfāngjiànjiǔhànmínzhuóláishīqiútuītuō?」lóngwángdào:「gǎntuītuōdànshèngniànzhēnyánhuàngǎnlái


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhědào:「yīnguòfāngjiànjiǔhànmínzhuóláishīqiútuītuō?」 xíngzhědào:「yīnguòfāngjiànjiǔhànmínzhuóláishīqiútuītuō?」

Pilgrim said, "I was passing through this district, saw a long drought and a people in misery, and sent for you specially to come and grant rain and relieve them. Why are you making excuses?"

is zhuó here — the sending sense, the one that puts somebody up to something. It is a different word from the zhe that marks a continuing state, and this chapter uses both, along with a third reading. 推託 is to fob someone off with a pretext, and Pilgrim's choice of it is an accusation rather than a question.

lóngwángdào:「gǎntuītuō lóngwángdào:「gǎntuītuō

The Dragon King said, "How would I dare make excuses?

He throws the word straight back. Repeating your accuser's own term before answering it is a very old rhetorical move and it survives intact into English.

dànshèngniànzhēnyánhuàngǎnlái dànshèngniànzhēnyánhuàngǎnlái

"When the Great Sage recites the true words and calls, I dare not fail to come.

不敢不來 is a double negative — dare not not come. Chinese uses the shape for the same purpose English does: to make obedience sound like compulsion rather than willingness. He came because he had no choice, and he wants that on record.


總評 Commentary

Pilgrim accuses the dragon of stalling, and the dragon's reply is a small masterpiece of covering oneself. He came, he says, because a summons from the Great Sage cannot be refused — which is both flattering and a careful note that his attendance was not voluntary.

Anyone who has watched a competent official explain why a request is outside their remit will recognise the technique exactly. Nothing is refused. Everything is deferred upward.