Canonical Classics ← 第七十一回
第七十一回
xíngzhějiǎmíngxiángguàihǒu
guānyīnxiànxiàngyāowáng

Pilgrim Under a False Name Subdues the Monster Hou · Guanyin Shows Her Image and Puts Down the Fiend King

是人是鬼
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

是人是鬼 Are You A Man Or A Ghost

niángniangwényánzhànjīngjīngshénjiūqièqièxīnchǔzhùlèiwāngwāngdedào:「jīnshìrénshìguǐ?」xíngzhědào:「shìrénshìguǐjīnbiànzuòcāngyíngérzàixiūkuàiqǐngyāowáng。」niángniangwényánzhànjīngjīngshénjiūqièqièxīnchǔzhùlèiwāngwāngdedào:「jīnshìrénshìguǐ?」xíngzhědào:「shìrénshìguǐjīnbiànzuòcāngyíngérzàixiūkuàiqǐngyāowáng。」


逐句解 Line by line

niángniangwényánzhànjīngjīngshénjiūqièqièxīnchǔzhù niángniangwényánzhànjīngjīngshénjiūqièqièxīnchǔzhù

The moment the Queen heard this she shook and trembled, her hair as though some spirit had it by the roots; she went weak and faint, her heart like a pestle pounding.

A voice out of nowhere, and this is the reaction. The source cuts the sentence at a semicolon, but the two halves are built to the same pattern — a doubled three-character word, then a four-character comparison — so they are one sentence and stay one segment. Only the first half names her; the second simply carries on. is , like or as.

lèiwāngwāngdedào:「jīnshìrénshìguǐ?」 lèiwāngwāngdedào:「jīnshìrénshìguǐ?」

Streaming with tears, she said, "Are you a man now, or a ghost?"

Her first words are a question about what kind of thing is talking to her. 汪汪 is a doubled word for eyes brimming over — the same shape as 淚滴滴 in the next passage. is the neutral de, hooking the description onto the verb.

xíngzhědào:「shìrénshìguǐjīnbiànzuòcāngyíngérzài xíngzhědào:「shìrénshìguǐjīnbiànzuòcāngyíngérzài

Pilgrim said, "I am not a man either, and I am not a ghost either. I have turned myself into a fly, and here I am.

He answers by rejecting both options and then supplying a third, which is not obviously more comforting. is ér, a full syllable in this text rather than the swallowed suffix of modern speech.

xiūkuàiqǐngyāowáng。」 xiūkuàiqǐngyāowáng。」

"Do not be frightened. Go quickly and invite the fiend king in."

Ten characters, and both halves are orders. is the vernacular prohibitive, the everyday do-not of the period. is , pointing at a figure they both know.


總評 Commentary

Terror first, questions second. The passage opens with her whole body reacting — shaking, hair, weakness, heartbeat — before she gets a word out, and the wording of it is deliberately physical: 髮似神揪 has a spirit yanking her hair by the roots, 心如杵築 has her heart being pounded like grain under a pestle. Then, having been reduced to that, she asks a perfectly practical question.

是人是鬼 is not a figure of speech. In this world both answers are live options, and she is asking which sort of thing has got into her bedroom. Pilgrim's reply denies both and offers a third, and if you were hoping the third would be reassuring, it is a fly.

The last ten characters are the whole plot in miniature. He tells her not to be frightened and, in the same breath, orders her to go and fetch the monster who has been holding her for three years. Nothing about her comfort is being considered here. She is the way in.