Canonical Classics ← 第五十八回
第五十八回
èrxīnjiǎoluànqiánkūn
nánxiūzhēnmiè

Two Minds Throw the Great Cosmos into Confusion · One Body Cannot Cultivate the True Nirvana

拜辭南海
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

拜辭南海 Parting From Potalaka

zhèxíngzhěshāsēngbàilezòngliǎngdàoxiángguānglenánhǎiyuánláixíngzhějīndǒuyúnkuàishāshàngxiānyúnjuéchíxíngzhějiùyàoxiānxíngshāsēngchězhùdào:「zhèděngcángtóuwěixiānāngēndàixiǎotóngzǒu。」shèngběnshìliángxīnshāsēngquèyǒuzhēnèrréntóngjiàyúnérduōshíguǒjiànhuāguǒshānzhèxíngzhěshāsēngbàilezòngliǎngdàoxiángguānglenánhǎiyuánláixíngzhějīndǒuyúnkuàishāshàngxiānyúnjuéchíxíngzhějiùyàoxiānxíngshāsēngchězhùdào:「zhèděngcángtóuwěixiānāngēndàixiǎotóngzǒu。」shèngběnshìliángxīnshāsēngquèyǒuzhēnèrréntóngjiàyúnérduōshíguǒjiànhuāguǒshān


逐句解 Line by line

zhèxíngzhěshāsēngbàilezòngliǎngdàoxiángguānglenánhǎi zhèxíngzhěshāsēngbàilezòngliǎngdàoxiángguānglenánhǎi

The Pilgrim and Sha Monk took their leave of the Bodhisattva, raised two shafts of auspicious light, and quitted the Southern Sea.

Two lights, counted separately, for two travellers leaving together. Hold on to that arithmetic: the whole chapter is about to argue over whether it is counting two travellers or one traveller doubled.

yuánláixíngzhějīndǒuyúnkuàishāshàngxiānyúnjuéchíxíngzhějiùyàoxiānxíng yuánláixíngzhějīndǒuyúnkuàishāshàngxiānyúnjuéchíxíngzhějiùyàoxiānxíng

Now the Pilgrim's cloud-somersault was swift and the Sand Monk's immortal cloud was slow to the feel, so the Pilgrim would go on ahead.

The somersault cloud is Wukong's party trick, and 觔斗 is the somersault — dǒu, though the automatic reading wants the dòu of the grain measure and the Dipper. Sha Monk's cloud is slower, or at any rate it feels slower to him: 覺遲, from jué, to feel.

shāsēngchězhùdào:「zhèděngcángtóuwěixiānāngēn shāsēngchězhùdào:「zhèděngcángtóuwěixiānāngēn

Sha Monk caught hold of him and said: "Elder Brother, there is no need of this hiding of the head and showing of the tail, of going on first to lay a root.

Sha Monk is not asking, he is accusing. 藏頭露尾 cáng tóu lù wěi — hide the head, show the tail — is still the everyday Chinese for shifty behaviour, the way English says shifty-eyed. 安根, to set a root, means to get your groundwork in early; Sha Monk thinks his brother wants a head start so he can square things before anyone arrives.

dàixiǎotóngzǒu。」 dàixiǎotóngzǒu。」

Wait for your younger brother, and we shall go together."

Eight characters, one complete sentence, and it is a plea rather than a demand — the younger brother asking not to be left behind.

shèngběnshìliángxīnshāsēngquèyǒu shèngběnshìliángxīnshāsēngquèyǒu

The Great Sage was of an honest heart at bottom; Sha Monk, however, harboured a doubt.

The narrator steps in and settles the moral facts himself: the Great Sage was honest, 本是良心; Sha Monk doubted, 卻有疑意. Nobody inside the story gets told this. The suspicion in this chapter is never the impostor's doing alone.

zhēnèrréntóngjiàyúnér zhēnèrréntóngjiàyúnér

Truly the two of them mounted the clouds and went together.

真個, truly, in very fact — the narrator vouching for what he has just described. There is a small joke in the choice, because , true, and , false, are about to become the chapter's entire business.

duōshíguǒjiànhuāguǒshān duōshíguǒjiànhuāguǒshān

In no great while the Mountain of Flowers and Fruit came into view.

The Mountain of Flowers and Fruit, 花果山, is Wukong's own home ground. He arrives at it, this once, as a stranger.


總評 Commentary

The chapter opens mid-stride, straight out of the Bodhisattva's refusal to say who is who. She has told them to go and look, and the looking starts in the second sentence. Nothing is settled by the journey itself; two figures simply move toward a place where a third is already waiting.

The squabble over the somersault cloud is the first of the chapter's many small tests of trust, and Sha Monk fails it in the direction of suspicion rather than of credulity. He will not let Wukong travel ahead unwatched. Then the narrator does something he rarely does and states the moral facts flat out: the Great Sage was honest, Sha Monk doubted. A reader who takes that sentence at face value already knows more than any character will know for the next four and a half thousand characters.

藏頭露尾 is an accusation of concealment, and it lands on the one figure in the whole episode who is concealing nothing. That is the chapter's particular cruelty. Suspicion attaches itself to the real article, because the real article is the only one whose behaviour anybody has a memory to compare it against.