Canonical Classics ← 第五十八回
第五十八回
二èr心xīn攪jiǎo亂luàn大dà乾qián坤kūn
一yì體tǐ難nán修xiū真zhēn寂jì滅miè

Two Minds Throw the Great Cosmos into Confusion · One Body Cannot Cultivate the True Nirvana

毫髮不差
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

毫髮不差 The Demon Mirror Fails

玉yù帝dì即jí傳chuán旨zhǐ宣xuān托tuō塔tǎ李lǐ天tiān王wáng,教jiào:「把bǎ照zhào妖yāo鏡jìng來lái照zhào這zhè廝sī誰shuí真zhēn誰shuí假jiǎ,教jiào他tā假jiǎ滅miè真zhēn存cún。」天tiān王wáng即jí取qǔ鏡jìng照zhào住zhù,請qǐng玉yù帝dì同tóng眾zhòng神shén觀guān看kàn。鏡jìng中zhōng乃nǎi是shì兩liǎng個gè孫sūn悟wù空kōng的de影yǐng子zi,金jīn箍gū、衣yī服fú,毫háo髮fà不bù差chā。玉yù帝dì亦yì辨biàn不bù出chū,趕gǎn出chū殿diàn外wài。玉yù帝dì即jí传chuán旨zhǐ宣xuān托tuō塔tǎ李lǐ天tiān王wáng,教jiào:「把bǎ照zhào妖yāo镜jìng来lái照zhào这zhè厮sī谁shuí真zhēn谁shuí假jiǎ,教jiào他tā假jiǎ灭miè真zhēn存cún。」天tiān王wáng即jí取qǔ镜jìng照zhào住zhù,请qǐng玉yù帝dì同tóng众zhòng神shén观guān看kàn。镜jìng中zhōng乃nǎi是shì两liǎng个gè孙sūn悟wù空kōng的de影yǐng子zi,金jīn箍gū、衣yī服fú,毫háo发fà不bù差chā。玉yù帝dì亦yì辨biàn不bù出chū,赶gǎn出chū殿diàn外wài。


逐句解 Line by line

玉yù帝dì即jí傳chuán旨zhǐ宣xuān托tuō塔tǎ李lǐ天tiān王wáng,教jiào:「把bǎ照zhào妖yāo鏡jìng來lái照zhào這zhè廝sī誰shuí真zhēn誰shuí假jiǎ,教jiào他tā假jiǎ滅miè真zhēn存cún。」 玉yù帝dì即jí传chuán旨zhǐ宣xuān托tuō塔tǎ李lǐ天tiān王wáng,教jiào:「把bǎ照zhào妖yāo镜jìng来lái照zhào这zhè厮sī谁shuí真zhēn谁shuí假jiǎ,教jiào他tā假jiǎ灭miè真zhēn存cún。」

The Jade Emperor at once issued a decree summoning Devarāja Li the Pagoda-Bearer, ordering: "Take the demon-revealing mirror and shine it on these fellows, to see who is true and who false; make the false perish and the true remain."

The demon-revealing mirror is brought out — the one instrument in the cosmos designed to show a shape-changer what it really is. 教 appears twice with two jobs: first "ordered", then "make him". Both are jiào. 誰 takes the bookish shuí rather than the everyday shéi.

天tiān王wáng即jí取qǔ鏡jìng照zhào住zhù,請qǐng玉yù帝dì同tóng眾zhòng神shén觀guān看kàn。 天tiān王wáng即jí取qǔ镜jìng照zhào住zhù,请qǐng玉yù帝dì同tóng众zhòng神shén观guān看kàn。

The Devarāja took up the mirror and held it steady upon them, inviting the Jade Emperor and the host of spirits to look together.

The whole court is invited to watch, which raises the stakes of what the mirror is about to show. 觀看 puts guān and kàn side by side, two characters that each carry more than one reading and are each pinned here.

鏡jìng中zhōng乃nǎi是shì兩liǎng個gè孫sūn悟wù空kōng的de影yǐng子zi,金jīn箍gū、衣yī服fú,毫háo髮fà不bù差chā。 镜jìng中zhōng乃nǎi是shì两liǎng个gè孙sūn悟wù空kōng的de影yǐng子zi,金jīn箍gū、衣yī服fú,毫háo发fà不bù差chā。

Within the mirror were the reflections of two Sun Wukongs. Golden fillet and clothing — there was not a hair's difference between them.

毫髮不差, not a hair's difference. 差 is chā, difference, not the chāi of sending someone off on an errand — and because that makes it a first-tone syllable, the 不 before it stays bù rather than shifting to bú.

玉yù帝dì亦yì辨biàn不bù出chū,趕gǎn出chū殿diàn外wài。 玉yù帝dì亦yì辨biàn不bù出chū,赶gǎn出chū殿diàn外wài。

The Jade Emperor too could not tell them apart, and drove them out of the hall.

The fourth authority beaten, and the first to deal with the case by simply throwing it out of the building rather than passing it on.


總評 Commentary

The demon-revealing mirror is a different category of instrument from everything tried so far. The Bodhisattva looked, and looking failed; she cast the fillet spell, and the body failed to discriminate. The mirror depends on neither. It is built to show a thing's original shape regardless of what it is currently wearing — the closest the cosmos comes to a DNA test — and it is precisely the right tool for an imposture.

It shows two Sun Wukongs. This is the chapter's most important negative result, because it shuts off the obvious explanation. The false Pilgrim is not a disguised something-else; his original shape, the one the mirror exists to expose, is Sun Wukong. Whatever the answer turns out to be, it cannot be that somebody put on a costume — and the reader now knows this three thousand characters before the Buddha explains it.

毫髮不差 — not a hair's difference — is the phrase the chapter has been building toward, and it lands on the golden fillet, the one object in the cosmos fitted to one skull. The Jade Emperor's response is to drive them both out of the hall, which is less a judgement than an admission.