Canonical Classics ← 第五十八回
第五十八回
二èr心xīn攪jiǎo亂luàn大dà乾qián坤kūn
一yì體tǐ難nán修xiū真zhēn寂jì滅miè

Two Minds Throw the Great Cosmos into Confusion · One Body Cannot Cultivate the True Nirvana

劈頭打死
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

劈頭打死 One Blow To The Head

大dà眾zhòng一yì發fā上shàng前qián,把bǎ缽bō盂yú揭jiē起qǐ,果guǒ然rán見jiàn了le本běn像xiàng,是shì一yí個gè六liù耳ěr獼mí猴hóu。孫sūn大dà聖shèng忍rěn不bú住zhù,掄lūn起qǐ鐵tiě棒bàng,劈pī頭tóu一yí下xià打dǎ死sǐ,至zhì今jīn絕jué此cǐ一yì種zhǒng。如rú來lái不bù忍rěn,道dào聲shēng:「善shàn哉zāi!善shàn哉zāi!」大dà众zhòng一yì发fā上shàng前qián,把bǎ钵bō盂yú揭jiē起qǐ,果guǒ然rán见jiàn了le本běn像xiàng,是shì一yí个gè六liù耳ěr猕mí猴hóu。孙sūn大dà圣shèng忍rěn不bú住zhù,抡lūn起qǐ铁tiě棒bàng,劈pī头tóu一yí下xià打dǎ死sǐ,至zhì今jīn绝jué此cǐ一yì种zhǒng。如rú来lái不bù忍rěn,道dào声shēng:「善shàn哉zāi!善shàn哉zāi!」


逐句解 Line by line

大dà眾zhòng一yì發fā上shàng前qián,把bǎ缽bō盂yú揭jiē起qǐ,果guǒ然rán見jiàn了le本běn像xiàng,是shì一yí個gè六liù耳ěr獼mí猴hóu。 大dà众zhòng一yì发fā上shàng前qián,把bǎ钵bō盂yú揭jiē起qǐ,果guǒ然rán见jiàn了le本běn像xiàng,是shì一yí个gè六liù耳ěr猕mí猴hóu。

The assembly came forward all together and lifted the alms bowl up; and sure enough they saw the original form — a Six-Eared Macaque.

一發, all at once, all together. 果然見了本像 answers 大眾不知 in the passage before: they can see it now, once it has been shown to them.

孫sūn大dà聖shèng忍rěn不bú住zhù,掄lūn起qǐ鐵tiě棒bàng,劈pī頭tóu一yí下xià打dǎ死sǐ,至zhì今jīn絕jué此cǐ一yì種zhǒng。 孙sūn大dà圣shèng忍rěn不bú住zhù,抡lūn起qǐ铁tiě棒bàng,劈pī头tóu一yí下xià打dǎ死sǐ,至zhì今jīn绝jué此cǐ一yì种zhǒng。

The Great Sage Sun could not contain himself. He swung up his iron rod and with one blow split his head and killed him — and from that day to this the kind has been extinct.

The chapter began with Wukong expelled for killing when he had been told not to, and it ends with him doing it again in front of the Buddha. In 劈頭一下 the word boundary falls between 劈頭 and 一下, so the 一 behaves normally rather than as part of a set phrase. 一種 takes zhǒng, a species.

如rú來lái不bù忍rěn,道dào聲shēng:「善shàn哉zāi!善shàn哉zāi!」 如rú来lái不bù忍rěn,道dào声shēng:「善shàn哉zāi!善shàn哉zāi!」

The Tathāgata could not bear it, and said: "Alas! Alas!"

善哉 is the Sanskrit sādhu, and it ordinarily means "it is well" or "well said" — a word of approval. Here it is spoken by a Buddha who 不忍, could not bear what he had just watched, and the doubled cry carries grief instead.


總評 Commentary

Wukong kills him, and he kills him having been told not to a hundred characters earlier. 悟空休動手,待我與你擒他 was explicit, and 忍不住 — could not contain himself — is the narration's whole account of why he ignored it. The chapter opened with him expelled for killing when he had been told not to, and closes with him doing it again in front of the Buddha.

至今絕此一種 is the sentence that gives the act its weight. Not one creature but a kind — one of the four monkeys outside the ten classes, named by the Tathāgata five passages ago as a species — is ended with a single blow. The taxonomy that identified him also measured what was destroyed.

善哉!善哉! is the Buddha's response, and the doubling is grief rather than praise: 如來不忍, he could not bear it. The chapter has spent nearly five thousand characters establishing that the false Pilgrim was a real being with a place in the order of things, however far outside the ten classes, and the one figure who understood what he was is the only one who mourns him.