Canonical Classics ← 第五十八回
第五十八回
二èr心xīn攪jiǎo亂luàn大dà乾qián坤kūn
一yì體tǐ難nán修xiū真zhēn寂jì滅miè

Two Minds Throw the Great Cosmos into Confusion · One Body Cannot Cultivate the True Nirvana

上界分辨
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

上界分辨 Sent Up To Heaven

菩pú薩sà無wú計jì奈nài何hé,即jí令lìng諸zhū天tiān、木mù叉chā上shàng前qián助zhù力lì。眾zhòng神shén恐kǒng傷shāng真zhēn的de,亦yì不bù敢gǎn下xià手shǒu。菩pú薩sà叫jiào聲shēng「孫sūn悟wù空kōng」,兩liǎng個gè一yì齊qí答dá應yìng。菩pú薩sà道dào:「你nǐ當dāng年nián官guān拜bài弼bì馬mǎ溫wēn,大dà鬧nào天tiān宮gōng時shí,神shén將jiàng皆jiē認rèn得dé你nǐ,你nǐ且qiě上shàng界jiè去qù分fēn辨biàn回huí話huà。」這zhè大dà聖shèng謝xiè恩ēn,那nà行xíng者zhě也yě謝xiè恩ēn。菩pú萨sà无wú计jì奈nài何hé,即jí令lìng诸zhū天tiān、木mù叉chā上shàng前qián助zhù力lì。众zhòng神shén恐kǒng伤shāng真zhēn的de,亦yì不bù敢gǎn下xià手shǒu。菩pú萨sà叫jiào声shēng「孙sūn悟wù空kōng」,两liǎng个gè一yì齐qí答dá应yìng。菩pú萨sà道dào:「你nǐ当dāng年nián官guān拜bài弼bì马mǎ温wēn,大dà闹nào天tiān宫gōng时shí,神shén将jiàng皆jiē认rèn得dé你nǐ,你nǐ且qiě上shàng界jiè去qù分fēn辨biàn回huí话huà。」这zhè大dà圣shèng谢xiè恩ēn,那nà行xíng者zhě也yě谢xiè恩ēn。


逐句解 Line by line

菩pú薩sà無wú計jì奈nài何hé,即jí令lìng諸zhū天tiān、木mù叉chā上shàng前qián助zhù力lì。 菩pú萨sà无wú计jì奈nài何hé,即jí令lìng诸zhū天tiān、木mù叉chā上shàng前qián助zhù力lì。

The Bodhisattva, at her wits' end, straightway ordered the devas and Mokṣa to go forward and lend their strength.

無計奈何 — out of stratagems, and what is to be done? It is the set phrase for an authority that has run through its measures.

眾zhòng神shén恐kǒng傷shāng真zhēn的de,亦yì不bù敢gǎn下xià手shǒu。 众zhòng神shén恐kǒng伤shāng真zhēn的de,亦yì不bù敢gǎn下xià手shǒu。

But the host of spirits, fearing they might wound the true one, likewise dared not put out a hand.

The gods inherit Sha Monk's paralysis word for word: 恐傷真的, afraid of wounding the true one, and so 不敢下手, not daring to raise a hand. The scruple travels all the way up the hierarchy without anybody resolving it.

菩pú薩sà叫jiào聲shēng「孫sūn悟wù空kōng」,兩liǎng個gè一yì齊qí答dá應yìng。 菩pú萨sà叫jiào声shēng「孙sūn悟wù空kōng」,两liǎng个gè一yì齐qí答dá应yìng。

The Bodhisattva called out the name "Sun Wukong", and both of them answered together.

She calls a name — the one label in the world that ought to attach to exactly one being — and two voices answer. 答應 takes yìng, to answer; the automatic reading gives yīng, the "ought to" sense.

菩pú薩sà道dào:「你nǐ當dāng年nián官guān拜bài弼bì馬mǎ溫wēn,大dà鬧nào天tiān宮gōng時shí,神shén將jiàng皆jiē認rèn得dé你nǐ,你nǐ且qiě上shàng界jiè去qù分fēn辨biàn回huí話huà。」 菩pú萨sà道dào:「你nǐ当dāng年nián官guān拜bài弼bì马mǎ温wēn,大dà闹nào天tiān宫gōng时shí,神shén将jiàng皆jiē认rèn得dé你nǐ,你nǐ且qiě上shàng界jiè去qù分fēn辨biàn回huí话huà。」

The Bodhisattva said: "In your day you held office as Ban-Horse Plague, and when you made your great uproar in Heaven the divine generals all knew you by sight. Go up to the upper realm and have the matter argued out there."

Her reasoning is good: there are beings up in Heaven who knew Wukong personally, in a particular job, at a particular time. 弼馬溫, Ban-Horse Plague, is the derisory stable post he was fobbed off with before he wrecked the place. 神將 takes jiàng, a general, against the jiāng of 打將來 a couple of passages back. 認得 takes dé, the reading for managing to do a thing.

這zhè大dà聖shèng謝xiè恩ēn,那nà行xíng者zhě也yě謝xiè恩ēn。 这zhè大dà圣shèng谢xiè恩ēn,那nà行xíng者zhě也yě谢xiè恩ēn。

This Great Sage gave thanks for the favour, and that Pilgrim gave thanks for the favour too.

Both thank her. Eleven characters, with the verb repeated word for word across the middle, and courtesy joins the long list of things that distinguish nobody.


總評 Commentary

The Bodhisattva's reason for sending them upstairs is the most promising idea yet, and it deserves credit. She reaches past appearance to biography: there are beings in Heaven who knew Wukong personally, in a specific job, at a specific date, long before any impostor existed. Shared history ought to be harder to fake than a face.

It is also, in plain terms, a referral upward by an authority that has run out of ideas — 無計奈何 says so outright. What began as a request to borrow the eye of wisdom has turned into a transfer of jurisdiction, and the chapter's architecture is now fully visible: the same case will be carried to Heaven, then to the underworld, then at last to the Buddha, and each court will fail in its own particular way.

The sharpest thing here is the smallest. 菩薩叫聲 — she calls out the name — and 兩個一齊答應, both answer together. A proper noun is supposed to pick out exactly one being in the world. Two voices answer it. The final sentence then does the same to gratitude: both thank her, in the same words, at the same moment.