Canonical Classics ← 第六十七回
第六十七回
zhěngjiùtuóluóchánxìngwěn
tuōhuìdàoxīnqīng

Rescuing Tuoluo, the Meditative Nature Is Stilled · Escaping the Filth, the Heart of the Way Is Clean

打誑語
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

打誑語 Monks Telling Lies

sānzàngwényándào:「zhèhóuérfánshì便biànyàozhuāntǎnghuòyāojīngshéntōngguǎngzhùshìchūjiārénkuángme?」xíngzhěxiàodào:「shīguàiděngzàiwènlekàn。」sānzàngwényándào:「zhèhóuérfánshì便biànyàozhuāntǎnghuòyāojīngshéntōng广guǎngzhùshìchūjiārénkuángme?」xíngzhěxiàodào:「shīguàiděngzàiwènlekàn。」


逐句解 Line by line

sānzàngwényándào:「zhèhóuérfánshì便biànyàozhuān sānzàngwényándào:「zhèhóuérfánshì便biànyàozhuān

Hearing this, Tripitaka said, "This monkey. He must decide everything for himself.

自專 is to take a decision into your own hands without consulting anyone. The complaint is about procedure, not about the demon.

tǎnghuòyāojīngshéntōngguǎngzhùshìchūjiārénkuángme?」 tǎnghuòyāojīngshéntōng广guǎngzhùshìchūjiārénkuángme?」

"If that demon's powers should turn out to be great and you cannot hold him, will that not make liars of us who have left the household life?"

打誑語 is monastic vocabulary: false speech is one of the cardinal prohibitions a monk takes on at ordination. Tripitaka's worry is a broken precept rather than a broken promise, which is a heavier thing.

xíngzhěxiàodào:「shīguàiděngzàiwènlekàn。」 xíngzhěxiàodào:「shīguàiděngzàiwènlekàn。」

Pilgrim laughed and said, "Do not be vexed, Master. Let me ask a little further and see."

問了看 — "ask, and then see" — puts off the commitment without withdrawing it.


總評 Commentary

Tripitaka has been silent for a long stretch and what rouses him is not the danger but the liability. He states it in the language of the precepts: if the boast fails, the failure is a moral one and it lands on all of them.

On the evidence so far the objection is also fair. Pilgrim has now made three claims about his own capability — the cudgel, the poem and the bow — and has been asked to make good on none of them.

The answer concedes nothing and buys time. He does not say he can catch the demon; he says he will ask more questions, which is what he does for the rest of the scene.