Canonical Classics ← 第六十回
第六十回
niúwángzhànhuáyán
sūnxíngzhěèr調tiáojiāoshàn

The Bull Demon King Breaks Off the Fight for a Splendid Banquet · Sun the Pilgrim Contrives the Second Fetching of the Banana-Leaf Fan

不識起倒
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

不識起倒 He Knows Not Rising From Falling

shèngdào:「méngkuānēngǎnxièjìndànshàngyǒushìfèngwànwàngzhōuzhōu。」niúwángdào:「zhèsūnshídǎoráoledàoháizǒufǎnláichánshénmezhōuzhōu?」shèngdào:「méngkuānēngǎnxièjìndànshàngyǒushìfèngwànwàngzhōuzhōu。」niúwángdào:「zhèsūnshídǎoráoledàoháizǒufǎnláichánshénmezhōuzhōu?」


逐句解 Line by line

shèngdào:「méngkuānēngǎnxièjìn shèngdào:「méngkuānēngǎnxièjìn

The Great Sage said, "Since I have received so generous a pardon, my thanks are beyond telling."

不盡 is where two tone rules collide. is held at jìn throughout this project, but the automatic tone change that decides whether is or runs on the character's dictionary reading — which is jǐn, a dipping tone. So the machinery produces where the actual reading requires , and the correction has to be made by hand. It is one of only two such collisions in the chapter.

dànshàngyǒushìfèngwànwàngzhōuzhōu。」 dànshàngyǒushìfèngwànwàngzhōuzhōu。」

"But there is yet one matter with which I must trouble you, and I earnestly beg your help in it, your help in it."

奉瀆 is the humble form for imposing on a superior — literally, to sully them by offering. 一事 takes before the falling tone of . And keep an ear on the doubled 周濟周濟: it comes straight back at him in the next sentence.

niúwángdào:「zhèsūnshídǎoráoledàoháizǒufǎnláichánshénmezhōuzhōu?」 niúwángdào:「zhèsūnshídǎoráoledàoháizǒufǎnláichánshénmezhōuzhōu?」

The Bull King railed, "This ape does not know rising from falling! I let you off, and instead of going you turn back and pester me. What help, what help?"

takes both its readings four characters apart. In 起倒 it is dǎo, the falling that pairs with the rising, and the idiom 不識起倒 means to have no sense of when to stop pushing; in 倒還不走 it is dào, the adverb of the-other-way-round. is shén.


總評 Commentary

The Great Sage has been pardoned and immediately asks for a favour, and the Bull King's exasperation is the most human note he is given in the chapter. 不識起倒 — he cannot tell rising from falling — is exactly right: the Great Sage has no instinct at all for the moment when an advantage has been pushed as far as it will go.

The passage turns on one repeated phrase. 周濟周濟, begged in the second sentence, comes back as 甚麼周濟周濟 in the third, and the doubling that was deferential in the asking is contemptuous in the echo. The novel uses this trick constantly in quarrels — the opponent's own words handed back with the courtesy stripped out — and used it earlier in this same chapter when the Great Sage turned round on the Jade-Faced Princess.