Canonical Classics ← 第六十回
第六十回
牛niú魔mó王wáng罷bà戰zhàn赴fù華huá筵yán
孫sūn行xíng者zhě二èr調tiáo芭bā蕉jiāo扇shàn

The Bull Demon King Breaks Off the Fight for a Splendid Banquet · Sun the Pilgrim Contrives the Second Fetching of the Banana-Leaf Fan

咬響鋼牙
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

咬響鋼牙 Grinding His Steel Teeth

牛niú王wáng聞wén言yán,心xīn如rú火huǒ發fā,咬yǎo響xiǎng鋼gāng牙yá罵mà道dào:「你nǐ說shuō你nǐ不bù無wú禮lǐ,你nǐ原yuán來lái是shì借jiè扇shàn之zhī故gù。一yí定dìng先xiān欺qī我wǒ山shān妻qī,山shān妻qī想xiǎng是shì不bù肯kěn,故gù來lái尋xún我wǒ,且qiě又yòu趕gǎn我wǒ愛ài妾qiè。常cháng言yán道dào:『朋péng友yǒu妻qī,不bù可kě欺qī;朋péng友yǒu妾qiè,不bù可kě滅miè。』你nǐ既jì欺qī我wǒ妻qī又yòu滅miè我wǒ妾qiè,多duō大dà無wú禮lǐ?上shàng來lái吃chī我wǒ一yí棍gùn。」牛niú王wáng闻wén言yán,心xīn如rú火huǒ发fā,咬yǎo响xiǎng钢gāng牙yá骂mà道dào:「你nǐ说shuō你nǐ不bù无wú礼lǐ,你nǐ原yuán来lái是shì借jiè扇shàn之zhī故gù。一yí定dìng先xiān欺qī我wǒ山shān妻qī,山shān妻qī想xiǎng是shì不bù肯kěn,故gù来lái寻xún我wǒ,且qiě又yòu赶gǎn我wǒ爱ài妾qiè。常cháng言yán道dào:『朋péng友yǒu妻qī,不bù可kě欺qī;朋péng友yǒu妾qiè,不bù可kě灭miè。』你nǐ既jì欺qī我wǒ妻qī又yòu灭miè我wǒ妾qiè,多duō大dà无wú礼lǐ?上shàng来lái吃chī我wǒ一yí棍gùn。」


逐句解 Line by line

牛niú王wáng聞wén言yán,心xīn如rú火huǒ發fā,咬yǎo響xiǎng鋼gāng牙yá罵mà道dào:「你nǐ說shuō你nǐ不bù無wú禮lǐ,你nǐ原yuán來lái是shì借jiè扇shàn之zhī故gù。 牛niú王wáng闻wén言yán,心xīn如rú火huǒ发fā,咬yǎo响xiǎng钢gāng牙yá骂mà道dào:「你nǐ说shuō你nǐ不bù无wú礼lǐ,你nǐ原yuán来lái是shì借jiè扇shàn之zhī故gù。

Hearing this, the Bull King's heart flared as with fire. He ground his steel teeth till they rang, and railed, "You said you had done no discourtesy — and the whole cause of it turns out to be the borrowing of the fan!"

咬響 is to grind the teeth hard enough to be heard. 你不無禮 points back to the apology three passages ago: the Bull King now rereads the whole thing as groundwork for the request.

一yí定dìng先xiān欺qī我wǒ山shān妻qī,山shān妻qī想xiǎng是shì不bù肯kěn,故gù來lái尋xún我wǒ,且qiě又yòu趕gǎn我wǒ愛ài妾qiè。 一yí定dìng先xiān欺qī我wǒ山shān妻qī,山shān妻qī想xiǎng是shì不bù肯kěn,故gù来lái寻xún我wǒ,且qiě又yòu赶gǎn我wǒ爱ài妾qiè。

"Assuredly you first insulted my mountain wife; my mountain wife, I suppose, would not consent; and so you came seeking me, and chased my beloved concubine into the bargain."

一定 takes yí before the falling tone of 定. 山妻 is the humble form for one's own wife, used twice here. And the reconstruction he offers is entirely correct.

常cháng言yán道dào:『朋péng友yǒu妻qī,不bù可kě欺qī;朋péng友yǒu妾qiè,不bù可kě滅miè。』 常cháng言yán道dào:『朋péng友yǒu妻qī,不bù可kě欺qī;朋péng友yǒu妾qiè,不bù可kě灭miè。』

The common saying has it: the wife of a friend is not to be wronged; the concubine of a friend is not to be slighted.

A proverb, quoted in its own marks, and still current: a friend's wife is not to be wronged, a friend's concubine not to be slighted. The two halves are identical in build — 朋友 plus a person, 不可 plus a verb — with no escalation between them. Both instances of 不 take bù before the dipping tone of 可.

你nǐ既jì欺qī我wǒ妻qī又yòu滅miè我wǒ妾qiè,多duō大dà無wú禮lǐ?上shàng來lái吃chī我wǒ一yí棍gùn。」 你nǐ既jì欺qī我wǒ妻qī又yòu灭miè我wǒ妾qiè,多duō大dà无wú礼lǐ?上shàng来lái吃chī我wǒ一yí棍gùn。」

"You have wronged my wife and slighted my concubine both. How great an incivility is that? Come up and take a stroke of my staff!"

The proverb's two halves are applied in order, 欺 to the wife and 滅 to the concubine, so the charge arrives as a formal syllogism with the maxim as its major premise. 一棍 takes yí before the falling tone of 棍.


總評 Commentary

The Bull King's reasoning is sound, and that is what makes the passage work. He infers from the request that the courtesy preceding it was instrumental; he infers from the order of events that the Great Sage went to the Rākṣasī first, was refused, and came to him only as a fallback; and he infers that the pursuit of the Jade-Faced Princess was part of the same errand. Every inference is correct. We have watched each step.

The proverb is the hinge. Quoted as received wisdom, it supplies a general rule under which both grievances fall, and he applies it at once and in order — the wife wronged, the concubine slighted. What began as a domestic quarrel is thereby raised to a breach of the code between sworn brothers, which is the one ground on which he can strike a man he has just pardoned.

It is worth noting what the pardon was actually worth. Granted three passages ago on the strength of old acquaintance, it lasts exactly as long as the Great Sage refrains from asking for anything. The novel is precise about this: friendship among these figures is real, and it is also a currency, and the Great Sage has just spent his entire balance on a request that has not even been answered yet.