Canonical Classics ← 第二十九回
第二十九回
tuōnànjiāngliúláiguó
chéngēnjièzhuǎnshānlín

Freed from Ordeal, River-Float Comes to the Kingdom's Land · Receiving Grace, Eight Rules Turns to the Mountain Forest

西江月
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

西江月 A Chapter-Opening Lyric

shīyuēshīyuē

wàngxiǎngqiǎngmièzhēnqiúwàngxiǎngqiǎngmièzhēnqiú
běnyuánxìngqiánxiūqiánhòuběnyuánxìngqiánxiūqiánhòu
chàchéngzhèngérwànjiéchénliúchàchéngzhèngérwànjiéchénliú
ruònéngniànzhēnxiūmièjìnhéngshāzuìgòuruònéngniànzhēnxiūmièjìnhéngshāzuìgòu

逐句解 Line by line

shīyuē shīyuē

A poem runs:

Before a word of story, a poem. That is normal for this novel, and the two characters 詩曰 ("a poem runs") are the signal that one is coming. What follows is not loose verse but a set-piece lyric () written to the fixed tune-pattern 西江月, "Moon over the West River" — new words fitted to a tune the audience already knew, much as a songwriter today writes fresh lyrics over a familiar melody. Its content is the preachy, inner-alchemy verse the novel keeps borrowing from the 悟真篇 line of Daoist poetry.

wàngxiǎngqiǎngmièzhēnqiú wàngxiǎngqiǎngmièzhēnqiú

Idle fancies need not be forcibly quelled; / as for suchness — why must it be sought at all?

The lyric opens on a paradox that Chan Buddhists and inner-alchemy Daoists both liked: you cannot bully your way to enlightenment, and you cannot go shopping for it either. 妄想, stray or deluded thinking, is set against 真如 (tathatā, "suchness" — reality exactly as it is). is qiǎng here, "by force." Crushing the delusion and chasing the suchness both fail, because both are still somebody trying.

běnyuánxìngqiánxiūqiánhòu běnyuánxìngqiánxiūqiánhòu

The primal self-nature is cultivated in the Buddha's presence; / do delusion and awakening lie the one before the other?

自性 (svabhāva, "self-nature") is held to contain buddhahood already, so the cultivating happens "before the Buddha" who turns out to be your own nature. The second line then refuses to put (straying) and (waking) in any running order: waking is a turn within the same nature, not the next item on a list.

chàchéngzhèngérwànjiéchénliú chàchéngzhèngérwànjiéchénliú

Awaken, and in a kṣaṇa one attains the right; / stray, and through myriad kalpas one sinks and drifts.

Now the lyric puts a clock on the two states. is timed in a 剎那 (kṣaṇa, the briefest instant Buddhist thought will name); in 萬劫, ten thousand kalpas. Waking takes no time at all; straying takes forever. 成正 is to attain the correct fruit, 沉流 to sink in the stream of saṃsāra.

ruònéngniànzhēnxiūmièjìnhéngshāzuìgòu ruònéngniànzhēnxiūmièjìnhéngshāzuìgòu

Could a single thought accord with true cultivation, / it would extinguish sins numberless as Ganges sands.

The pay-off. 一念 — one instant of mind — brought into accord with 真修, true cultivation, is enough to dissolve every stain. 恆沙 (Gangā-vālukā, "sands of the Ganges") is the standard Buddhist way of saying "more than anyone could ever count"; 罪垢 is sins-and-grime. The lyric ends where this school always ends, on the single thought that does the whole job.


總評 Commentary

The chapter is prefaced, in the storyteller's manner, with a 西江月 lyric that mixes its sources without apology. The vocabulary is Buddhist throughout — 真如, 自性, 剎那, 萬劫, 恆沙, 罪垢 — but the idea running underneath it, that one accordant thought (一念) collapses the entire labour of cultivation, belongs to the Quanzhen and 悟真篇 tradition of inner-alchemical verse that this novel absorbs at every turn. The teaching is a quiet one: do not beat the delusion down, do not run after the suchness, because both moves misread a nature that already is what it is looking for.

Put here, the lyric works as an ironic overture. The story it introduces shows the pilgrims doing exactly what the verse warns against — , straying, rather than , waking. Tripitaka is tied to a post and weeping; Eight Rules and Sha Monk cannot win their fight. The gap between a poem that says awakening takes one instant and a journey that takes a hundred chapters is the novel's running joke and its deepest subject at the same time.