Canonical Classics ← 第二十八回
第二十八回
huāguǒshānqúnyāo
hēisōnglínsānzàngféng

At Flower-Fruit Mountain the Host of Fiends Bands Together in Fellowship · In the Black Pine Forest Tripitaka Falls in with a Demon

未分勝負
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

未分勝負 No Victor Yet

sānzàibànkōngzhōngwǎngwǎngláiláizhànjīngshùshíhuífēnshèngyīnxìngmìngyàojǐnshínánjiěnánfēnjìngzhīzěnjiùtángsēngqiětīngxiàhuífēnjiěsānzàibànkōngzhōngwǎngwǎngláiláizhànjīngshùshíhuífēnshèngyīnxìngmìngyàojǐnshínánjiěnánfēnjìngzhīzěnjiùtángsēngqiětīngxiàhuífēnjiě


逐句解 Line by line

sānzàibànkōngzhōngwǎngwǎngláiláizhànjīngshùshíhuífēnshèngyīnxìngmìngyàojǐnshínánjiěnánfēn sānzàibànkōngzhōngwǎngwǎngláiláizhànjīngshùshíhuífēnshèngyīnxìngmìngyàojǐnshínánjiěnánfēn

The three of them went back and forth in mid-air, fought through several tens of bouts, and settled nothing. Each, because his very life hung on it, was truly hard to sunder and hard to part.

Several tens of bouts and nothing decided. 難解難分 — hard to loosen, hard to part — is still an everyday phrase for two people locked in something neither can get out of, from a fight to an argument. 半空中 takes zhōng; both take fēn; both take nán.

jìngzhīzěnjiùtángsēngqiětīngxiàhuífēnjiě jìngzhīzěnjiùtángsēngqiětīngxiàhuífēnjiě

In the end, there is no knowing how the Tang Monk was to be saved — so listen to the explanation in the next chapter.

畢竟且聽下回分解 — in the end there is no knowing, so listen to the next instalment. This is the storyteller's sign-off that every chapter of the novel ends on, inherited from the platform where these tales were performed for money and the audience had to be brought back tomorrow. Here it leaves the master roped to a stake and the fight undecided, which is the cliffhanger doing exactly its old job.


總評 Commentary

The chapter ends suspended at a real impasse. Two disciples and the demon, evenly matched, fight to no decision while the master stays roped to the soul-fixing stake inside. Hard to loosen, hard to part describes both the deadlock and the larger problem: this ordeal cannot be settled by the forces now on the board.

That is the design of the whole chapter. It began by letting the Mind-Monkey go, removed the pilgrims' guardian, stripped the master of every protector one sensible decision at a time, and closes by demonstrating that Bajie and Sha Monk together are not enough. The unresolved combat is an argument in narrative form: the journey cannot go on without the disciple the master threw out, and the reader is made to feel that necessity before the next chapter starts to answer it.