Canonical Classics ← 第二十八回
第二十八回
huāguǒshānqúnyāo
hēisōnglínsānzàngféng

At Flower-Fruit Mountain the Host of Fiends Bands Together in Fellowship · In the Black Pine Forest Tripitaka Falls in with a Demon

四健將迎
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

四健將迎 The Four Marshals

shèngwényángèngshífēnnǎodào:「dòngzhōngyǒushénmerénzhíshì?」qúnyāodào:「háiyǒuliúèryuánshuàibēngèrjiāngjūnguǎnzheli。」shèngdào:「menbàozhīdàoshuōláile。」xiēxiǎoyāozhuàngménnèibàodào:「shèngyeláijiāle。」liúbēnwénbàomángchūménkòutóuyíngjiējìndòngshèngzuòzàizhōngjiānqúnguàiluóbàiqiándào:「shèngyejìnwénlexìngmìngbǎotángsēngwǎng西tiānjīngzǒu西fāngquèhuíběnshān?」shèngdào:「xiǎodemenzhīdàotángsānzàngshíxiánwèishàngzhuōguàiqín使shǐjìnlepíngshēngdeshǒuduànfānjiāshāyāojīngshuōxíngxiōngzuòèyàozuòzhúgǎnhuíláixiěbiǎnshūwéizhàoyǒngtīngyòngle。」shèngwényángèngshífēnnǎodào:「dòngzhōngyǒushénmerénzhíshì?」qúnyāodào:「háiyǒuliúèryuánshuàibēngèrjiāngjūnguǎnzheli。」shèngdào:「menbàozhīdàoshuōláile。」xiēxiǎoyāozhuàngménnèibàodào:「shèngyeláijiāle。」liúbēnwénbàomángchūménkòutóuyíngjiējìndòngshèngzuòzàizhōngjiānqúnguàiluóbàiqiándào:「shèngyejìnwénlexìngmìngbǎotángsēngwǎng西tiānjīngzǒu西fāngquèhuíběnshān?」shèngdào:「xiǎodemenzhīdàotángsānzàngshíxiánwèishàngzhuōguàiqín使shǐjìnlepíngshēngdeshǒuduànfānjiāshāyāojīngshuōxíngxiōngzuòèyàozuòzhúgǎnhuíláixiěbiǎnshūwéizhàoyǒngtīngyòngle。」


逐句解 Line by line

shèngwényángèngshífēnnǎodào:「dòngzhōngyǒushénmerénzhíshì?」 shèngwényángèngshífēnnǎodào:「dòngzhōngyǒushénmerénzhíshì?」

When the Great Sage heard this, his anger flared the more, and he said, “Who is in charge within the cave?”

His first question after hearing all that is administrative: who is running the place? Grief has become command. is gèng, still more; 十分 takes fēn, ten parts out of ten; 洞中 takes zhōng; 甚麼 takes shén.

qúnyāodào:「háiyǒuliúèryuánshuàibēngèrjiāngjūnguǎnzheli。」 qúnyāodào:「háiyǒuliúèryuánshuàibēngèrjiāngjūnguǎnzheli。」

The fiends said, “Marshals Ma and Liu are still here, and Generals Beng and Ba are in charge.”

The four commanders of the old kingdom, back from the novel's early chapters: the marshals and , the generals and . is hái, still — still here, when almost nothing else is. 將軍 takes jiāng. 管著 ends in the unstressed zhe, marking a state that is still going on: in charge, and have been.

shèngdào:「menbàozhīdàoshuōláile。」 shèngdào:「menbàozhīdàoshuōláile。」

Said the Great Sage, “Go and let them know I have come.”

He sends word ahead rather than walking in. The court protocol is back before the court is.

xiēxiǎoyāozhuàngménnèibàodào:「shèngyeláijiāle。」 xiēxiǎoyāozhuàngménnèibàodào:「shèngyeláijiāle。」

The little fiends rushed in through the gate to report, “Grandfather Great Sage has come home!”

那些 is , those.

liúbēnwénbàomángchūménkòutóuyíngjiējìndòng liúbēnwénbàomángchūménkòutóuyíngjiējìndòng

Hearing the news, Ma, Liu, Ben, and Ba hurried out through the gate to kowtow and usher him into the cave.

is . One name has shifted: the general written a few lines back is written here, and the edition is left as it stands.

shèngzuòzàizhōngjiānqúnguàiluóbàiqiándào:「shèngyejìnwénlexìngmìngbǎotángsēngwǎng西tiānjīngzǒu西fāngquèhuíběnshān?」 shèngzuòzàizhōngjiānqúnguàiluóbàiqiándào:「shèngyejìnwénlexìngmìngbǎotángsēngwǎng西tiānjīngzǒu西fāngquèhuíběnshān?」

The Great Sage took his seat in the midst of them, and the throng of monsters bowed in ranks before him and said, “Grandfather Great Sage, of late we heard that you had won back your life and were guarding the Tang Monk on his way to fetch the scriptures from the Western Heaven. Why do you not press on westward, but have come back instead to your own mountain?”

Two in one sentence, read two different ways: 聞得 takes the unstressed de, tacking a result onto the verb, while 得了 takes , obtained. 坐在中間 takes zhōng and jiān. The monsters ask the obvious question, and it is the one the whole chapter turns on: if you were guarding the monk to the Western Heaven, why are you here?

shèngdào:「xiǎodemenzhīdàotángsānzàngshíxiánwèishàngzhuōguàiqín使shǐjìnlepíngshēngdeshǒuduànfānjiāshāyāojīng shèngdào:「xiǎodemenzhīdàotángsānzàngshíxiánwèishàngzhuōguàiqín使shǐjìnlepíngshēngdeshǒuduànfānjiāshāyāojīng

Said the Great Sage, “My children, you do not know it — that Tang Sanzang cannot tell the worthy from the worthless. Along the whole road I caught the demons and seized the fiends for him, spending the utmost skill of my life, and time and again I struck the goblins dead;

So he tells his side, and it is a grievance with a shape: I did the work, I used everything I had, I killed what needed killing, and he could not tell good from bad. Mark the phrase 不識賢愚, cannot tell the worthy from the worthless — because the battle-poem a few passages back said the killing wind 不辨賢愚, made no such distinction either. Wukong's complaint against his master is the same charge the novel has just quietly filed against Wukong. 我為他 takes wèi, for his sake — the reading for doing something on someone's behalf. is ; 三藏 takes zàng; is jìn, used up entirely.

shuōxíngxiōngzuòèyàozuòzhúgǎnhuíláixiěbiǎnshūwéizhàoyǒngtīngyòngle。」 shuōxíngxiōngzuòèyàozuòzhúgǎnhuíláixiěbiǎnshūwéizhàoyǒngtīngyòngle。」

yet he said I did violence and worked evil, would have me no longer for his disciple, drove me back here, and set down a writ of banishment as proof, never to employ me again.”

貶書 is the writ of dismissal Tripitaka wrote out at the end of the previous chapter — a document, not a scolding, which is why it stings. 行兇 takes xíng, to commit; 為照 takes wéi, to serve as proof.


總評 Commentary

Grief hardens into grievance. Received back into his cave by the four surviving commanders and the throng of monsters, Wukong takes his old seat, and their first question — why have you left the westward road? — gives him the chance to tell his version of the rupture. It is aggrieved and one-sided: he served, he killed on duty, and he was thrown out for it by a master who cannot tell the worthy from the wicked.

This is the hinge the chapter's two threads turn on. Wukong's account — righteous demon-killing mistaken for murder — is exactly what the monkeys' suffering has just prepared the reader to accept. But the novel keeps its distance. The writ of banishment is real, and so is the fact that Wukong has chosen his wounded pride and his old crown over the discipline of the road. The marshals' welcome puts him back where he was before the pilgrimage began, and that regression is precisely what the chapter is about to price.