Canonical Classics ← 第二十九回
第二十九回
tuōnànjiāngliúláiguó
chéngēnjièzhuǎnshānlín

Freed from Ordeal, River-Float Comes to the Kingdom's Land · Receiving Grace, Eight Rules Turns to the Mountain Forest

洞中悲啼
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

洞中悲啼 The Captive and the Woman

qiěyánsānrénzhàndòuquèshuōzhǎnglǎozàidòngbēiliángyǎnzhōngliúlèidào:「néngazhīzàicūnzhōngféngleshànyǒutānzhuózhāigōngjìngayòuzhīzàixúnnénghuìzhīyāozàishòunànshíhuìmentuōlenànzǎolíngshān?」zhèngdāngbēifánnǎojiàndòngnèizǒuchūrénláizhedìnghúnzhuāngjiàodào:「zhǎnglǎocóngláiwèibèizàichù?」qiěyánsānrénzhàndòuquèshuōzhǎnglǎozàidòngbēiliángyǎnzhōngliúlèidào:「néngazhīzàicūnzhōngféngleshànyǒutānzhuózhāigōngjìngayòuzhīzàixúnnénghuìzhīyāozàishòunànshíhuìmentuōlenànzǎolíngshān?」zhèngdāngbēifánnǎojiàndòngnèizǒuchūrénláizhedìnghúnzhuāngjiàodào:「zhǎnglǎocóngláiwèibèizàichù?」


逐句解 Line by line

qiěyánsānrénzhàndòuquèshuōzhǎnglǎozàidòngbēiliángyǎnzhōngliúlèidào:「néngazhīzàicūnzhōngféngleshànyǒutānzhuózhāigōngjìngayòuzhīzàixúnnénghuìzhīyāozàishòunànshíhuìmentuōlenànzǎolíngshān?」 qiěyánsānrénzhàndòuquèshuōzhǎnglǎozàidòngbēiliángyǎnzhōngliúlèidào:「néngazhīzàicūnzhōngféngleshànyǒutānzhuózhāigōngjìngayòuzhīzàixúnnénghuìzhīyāozàishòunànshíhuìmentuōlenànzǎolíngshān?」

But leave aside the combat of the three. The elder, meanwhile, wept within the cave, and thinking of his disciples let the tears fall: 'Wuneng, ah — I know not in what village you have fallen among good friends and grown greedy for their almsfood; Wujing, ah — you too know not where to seek him, and can you even find him? Little did I think to fall in with a fiend and suffer this ordeal here. When shall I meet you again, escape this great affliction, and reach the Spirit Mountain betimes?'

且不言 / 卻說 cut the storyteller's camera from the battle to the captive's interior. The lament apportions pathos in parallel apostrophes to 悟能 (Eight Rules) and 悟淨 (Sha Monk); 貪著齋供 pins on Pig his besetting fault, gluttony, with 著 the verb zhuó (Buddhist 貪著, "to cleave to, be attached"). The two 那 in his questions are interrogative nǎ ("in which village," "where"). 受難 / 大難 take 難 as nàn (an ordeal); 靈山 is Gṛdhrakūṭa, Vulture Peak, the journey's goal. The four rhetorical questions sustain the elegiac register.

zhèngdāngbēifánnǎojiàndòngnèizǒuchūrénláizhedìnghúnzhuāngjiàodào:「zhǎnglǎocóngláiwèibèizàichù?」 zhèngdāngbēifánnǎojiàndòngnèizǒuchūrénláizhedìnghúnzhuāngjiàodào:「zhǎnglǎocóngláiwèibèizàichù?」

Just as he grieved and fretted, of a sudden a woman came forth from within the cave, and steadying herself against the soul-fixing post, called out: 'You there, elder — whence do you come? Why has he bound you in this place?'

The entrance interrupts the lament at its height (正當...忽見). 定魂樁 ("soul-settling stake") is the post to which Tripitaka is lashed — a lurid furnishing suited to the ogre's lair; 扶著 uses 著 as durative zhe. Her blunt interrogation (從何來 / 為何被縛; 為 the interrogative wèi) opens the recognition scene that will supply the chapter's engine, the letter home.


總評 Commentary

With a single tale-teller's turn (且不言...卻說...) the chapter pivots from the noise of battle to the stillness of the cell, and from action to interiority. Tripitaka's lament is one of the novel's set arias of self-pity, but it is finely characterized: even in extremity he cannot help imputing to Eight Rules the very appetite — 貪著齋供, a craving for almsfood — that has so often endangered the group, while to Sha Monk he grants only bafflement. The four unanswered questions build the pathos and, structurally, hold the scene open for an interruption.

That interruption is the woman's abrupt appearance from within the cave. Her plainness of speech — whence, why, bound how — is the idiom of recognition drama: she does not yet know who he is, and he does not yet know that she is no demon but a fellow captive. The 定魂樁 to which he is tied names, with grim aptness, the apparatus of the lair; and her two questions launch the exchange from which the whole remaining machinery of the chapter — the letter, the embassy to Baoxiang, the summoning of the disciples to court — will unfold.