Canonical Classics ← 第二十四回
第二十四回
wànshòushānxiānliúyǒu
zhuāngguànxíngzhěqièrénshēn

At the Mountain of Ten Thousand Years the Great Immortal Keeps an Old Friend · At the Abbey of the Five Villages Pilgrim Steals the Ginseng-Fruit

人參大樹
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

人參大樹 The Great Ginseng Tree

zǒuguòcàiyuányòujiàncéngméntuīkāikànchùyazhǐjiànzhèngzhōngjiānyǒugēnshùzhēnshìqīngzhīyīnsēnerquèjiāoyàngzhíshàngyǒuqiānchǐgāogēnxiàyǒuzhàngwéiyuánxíngzhězàishùxiàwǎngshàngkànzhǐjiànxiàngnándezhīshàngchūrénshēnguǒzhēnxiàngháierbānyuánláiwěijiānshàngshìkàndīngzàizhītóushǒujiǎoluàndòngdiǎntóuhuǎngnǎofēngguòchùyǒushēngxíngzhěhuānjìnànkuāchēngdào:「hǎodōng西yaguǒránhǎnjiànguǒránhǎnjiàn!」zheshùsōudeshēngcuānjiāngshànghóuziyuánláihuìshùtōuguǒzijīnziqiāolexiàguǒzideluòjiāngxiàláisuítiàoxiàláigēnxúnránjiànxiàcǎozhōngzhǎoxúngèngzōngzǒuguòcàiyuányòujiàncéngméntuīkāikànchùyazhǐjiànzhèngzhōngjiānyǒugēnshùzhēnshìqīngzhī绿yīnsēnerquèjiāoyàngzhíshàngyǒuqiānchǐgāogēnxiàyǒuzhàngwéiyuánxíngzhězàishùxiàwǎngshàngkànzhǐjiànxiàngnándezhīshàngchūrénshēnguǒzhēnxiàngháierbānyuánláiwěijiānshàngshìkàndīngzàizhītóushǒujiǎoluàndòngdiǎntóuhuǎngnǎofēngguòchùyǒushēngxíngzhěhuānjìnànkuāchēngdào:「hǎodōng西yaguǒránhǎnjiànguǒránhǎnjiàn!」zheshùsōudeshēngcuānjiāngshànghóuziyuánláihuìshùtōuguǒzijīnziqiāolexiàguǒzideluòjiāngxiàláisuítiàoxiàláigēnxúnránjiànxiàcǎozhōngzhǎoxúngèngzōng


逐句解 Line by line

zǒuguòcàiyuányòujiàncéngmén zǒuguòcàiyuányòujiàncéngmén

Passing through the vegetable garden, he came to yet another gate.

Three gates now, each opening on something stranger than the last.

tuīkāikànchùya tuīkāikànchùya

He pushed it open to look — ah!

as again, standing alone as an exclamation.

zhǐjiànzhèngzhōngjiānyǒugēnshùzhēnshìqīngzhīyīnsēnerquèjiāoyàngzhíshàngyǒuqiānchǐgāogēnxiàyǒuzhàngwéiyuán zhǐjiànzhèngzhōngjiānyǒugēnshùzhēnshìqīngzhī绿yīnsēnerquèjiāoyàngzhíshàngyǒuqiānchǐgāogēnxiàyǒuzhàngwéiyuán

— there in the very midst stood a great tree, its green boughs richly fragrant, its dark leaves deep-shadowing; the leaves were shaped like a plantain's, and it rose straight up above a thousand chǐ, its trunk seven or eight zhàng round at the root.

The tree is given in exact numbers: over a thousand chǐ tall, and seven or eight zhàng — some twenty-five metres — around the trunk. Leaves like a plantain's, broad and paddle-shaped. 中間 takes as jiān, "amid," distinct from the jiàn of 間壁, "next door," a few passages back. 卻似 takes the comparative .

xíngzhězàishùxiàwǎngshàngkànzhǐjiànxiàngnándezhīshàngchūrénshēnguǒzhēnxiàngháierbān xíngzhězàishùxiàwǎngshàngkànzhǐjiànxiàngnándezhīshàngchūrénshēnguǒzhēnxiàngháierbān

Pilgrim, leaning below the tree, looked up, and saw on a south-facing branch a single ginseng-fruit peeping out — truly just like a child.

And there it is on a south-facing branch, looking like a child. The reader has been told this twice already; this is the first time anyone sees it.

yuánláiwěijiānshàngshìkàndīngzàizhītóushǒujiǎoluàndòngdiǎntóuhuǎngnǎofēngguòchùyǒushēng yuánláiwěijiānshàngshìkàndīngzàizhītóushǒujiǎoluàndòngdiǎntóuhuǎngnǎofēngguòchùyǒushēng

Its rump-end, it turned out, bore the little stem; and there it hung nailed to the bough, its hands and feet stirring, its head nodding and rolling, and as the wind passed it seemed almost to make a sound.

The detail that makes it unbearable. 扢蒂, gē dì, is the stem-knot — and it grows from the fruit's rump, so the stalk is where the navel would be. 丁在枝頭, fixed to the branch-tip like a nail. Then the limbs stir, the head nods and rolls, and in the wind it very nearly makes a sound. Whatever Tripiṭaka thought he was refusing, the text has just conceded he had a point.

xíngzhěhuānjìnànkuāchēngdào:「hǎodōng西ya xíngzhěhuānjìnànkuāchēngdào:「hǎodōng西ya

Pilgrim, delighted past measure, praised it to himself: "What a fine thing!

Pilgrim's reaction to a fruit that looks like a struggling infant is uncomplicated delight. 歡喜不盡 carries another . here is the sentence-final particle ya, not the exclamation.

guǒránhǎnjiànguǒránhǎnjiàn!」 guǒránhǎnjiànguǒránhǎnjiàn!」

Rare indeed, rare indeed!"

罕見, hǎn jiàn, seldom seen — doubled, in the chapter's habit.

zheshùsōudeshēngcuānjiāngshàng zheshùsōudeshēngcuānjiāngshàng

Leaning on the tree, with a whoosh he shot up it.

颼的一聲, with a whoosh; 攛將上去 takes as jiāng, the directional particle.

hóuziyuánláihuìshùtōuguǒzi hóuziyuánláihuìshùtōuguǒzi

Now this monkey was, above all, a first-rate hand at climbing trees to steal fruit.

The narrator's driest line in the chapter. This monkey was, above all else, a first-rate hand at climbing trees to steal fruit — which is both a joke about his species and a precise reference to the Peach Garden of chapter 5, where he did exactly this and brought Heaven down on himself. He has learnt nothing.

jīnziqiāolexiàguǒzideluòjiāngxiàlái jīnziqiāolexiàguǒzideluòjiāngxiàlái

He gave it one rap with the golden striker, and the fruit came tumbling down with a plop.

One rap, and it falls. 撲的, with a plop; 落將下來 takes as the directional particle again.

suítiàoxiàláigēnxúnránjiànxiàcǎozhōngzhǎoxúngèngzōng suítiàoxiàláigēnxúnránjiànxiàcǎozhōngzhǎoxúngèngzōng

He leapt straight down after it to search — but it was utterly gone; he hunted through the grass on every side, and found not a trace.

And it is gone. 寂然不見, vanished without a sound; 更無蹤跡, not a trace anywhere. He has just destroyed something ten thousand years in the making by not asking one more question.


總評 Commentary

Through a third gate stands the tree, and the novel finally shows the reader what it has twice only described. Over a thousand chǐ high, seven or eight zhàng round the trunk, leaves broad as a plantain's — and on a south-facing branch, one fruit.

The description that follows is the most unsettling thing in the chapter. The stem grows from the fruit's rump, so the stalk sits where a navel would be. It hangs nailed to the branch-tip. Its hands and feet stir. Its head nods and rolls. And when the wind passes it very nearly makes a sound. Whatever we thought of Tripiṭaka's horror three passages ago, the text has quietly conceded that he had a point.

Pilgrim's response to a fruit that looks like a struggling infant is delight, and the narrator lands the chapter's driest line: this monkey was, above all else, a first-rate hand at climbing trees to steal fruit. That is a joke about his species and a pointed reference to the Peach Garden of chapter 5, where he did precisely this and brought Heaven down on himself. He shoots up, raps once — and the fruit falls and is simply gone. Not in the grass, not anywhere. Ten thousand years of growth destroyed because he did not ask one more question.