Canonical Classics ← 第七十八回
第七十八回
qiūliánziqiǎnyīnshén
jīn殿diànshítándào

In Bhikshu He Pities the Children and Sends Out the Shade-Spirits · In the Golden Hall He Knows the Fiend and Discourses on the Way and Its Power

亦不回禮
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

亦不回禮 He Did Not Return The Salutation

sānzànggōngshēnshīdào:「guózhàngrénpínsēngwènxùnle。」guózhàngduānrángāozuòhuízhuǎnmiànxiàngguówángdào:「sēngjiālái?」guówángdào:「dōngtángcháochāishàng西tiānjīngzhějīnláidàoyànguānwén。」sānzànggōngshēnshīdào:「guózhàngrénpínsēngwènxùnle。」guózhàngduānrángāozuòhuízhuǎnmiànxiàngguówángdào:「sēngjiālái?」guówángdào:「dōngtángcháochāishàng西tiānjīngzhějīnláidàoyànguānwén。」


逐句解 Line by line

sānzànggōngshēnshīdào:「guózhàngrénpínsēngwènxùnle。」 sānzànggōngshēnshīdào:「guózhàngrénpínsēngwènxùnle。」

Tripitaka took a step forward, bent his body in salutation and said, "My lord Royal Father-in-Law, this poor monk pays his respects."

問訊 wèn xùn is the specific greeting a Buddhist monk makes — palms together, a short bow, an enquiry after the other's wellbeing. Tripitaka is offering the courtesy of his own order to a man of a different one.

guózhàngduānrángāozuòhuízhuǎnmiànxiàngguówángdào:「sēngjiālái?」 guózhàngduānrángāozuòhuízhuǎnmiànxiàngguówángdào:「sēngjiālái?」

The Royal Father-in-Law sat squarely on high and did not return the bow at all, but turned his face to the king and said, "Where is the monk from?"

The insult is complete and takes eight characters: he does not stand, does not bow, and does not address the person who spoke to him. 僧家 — the monk fellow — is third person, spoken across the room about someone standing in it.

guówángdào:「dōngtángcháochāishàng西tiānjīngzhějīnláidàoyànguānwén。」 guówángdào:「dōngtángcháochāishàng西tiānjīngzhějīnláidàoyànguānwén。」

The king said, "He is one dispatched from the Tang court in the Land of the East to fetch scriptures in the Western Heaven, and has come now to have his rescript checked and exchanged."

The king answers on Tripitaka's behalf, which completes the humiliation without anyone intending it. is chāi, dispatched — the reading six of the chapter's seven take.


總評 Commentary

The exchange establishes the pecking order before a word of argument is spoken. Tripitaka bows and is not bowed to; he speaks and is not answered; the king answers for him.

It is worth remembering what the reader knows and the room does not. The man refusing to return a monk's salutation has golden eyes with flame in them, and the gnat on the monk's hat has already seen them.