Canonical Classics ← 第七十八回
第七十八回
qiūliánziqiǎnyīnshén
jīn殿diànshítándào

In Bhikshu He Pities the Children and Sends Out the Shade-Spirits · In the Golden Hall He Knows the Fiend and Discourses on the Way and Its Power

走了傍門
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

走了傍門 Gone Off By A Side Door

xíngzhědào:「jìngshuōdeyǒushīqiěshuìjiàomíngděnglǎosūntóngjìncháokànguózhàngdehǎodǎiruòshìrénzhǐkǒngzǒulepángménzhīzhèngdàocǎiyàowéizhēndàilǎosūnjiāngxiāntiānzhīyàozhǐhuàguīzhèngxíngzhědào:「jìngshuōdeyǒushīqiěshuìjiàomíngděnglǎosūntóngjìncháokànguózhàngdehǎodǎiruòshìrénzhǐkǒngzǒulepángménzhīzhèngdàocǎiyàowéizhēndàilǎosūnjiāngxiāntiānzhīyàozhǐhuàguīzhèng


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhědào:「jìngshuōdeyǒu xíngzhědào:「jìngshuōdeyǒu

Pilgrim said, "Wujing speaks with reason.

說得有理 — said with sense in it. is the reduced de, hooking the verb to the judgement on it. Wukong uses Sha Monk's religious name, Wujing, which he does when he is taking him seriously.

shīqiěshuìjiàomíngděnglǎosūntóngjìncháokànguózhàngdehǎodǎi shīqiěshuìjiàomíngděnglǎosūntóngjìncháokànguózhàngdehǎodǎi

"Master, go to sleep. Tomorrow let old Monkey go with you into court and see whether this Royal Father-in-Law is good or bad.

is jiào again, the sleeping one — the second of the chapter's two. 好歹 hǎo dǎi is a single word made of its own opposites, good-and-bad, meaning which of the two something turns out to be.

ruòshìrénzhǐkǒngzǒulepángménzhīzhèngdàocǎiyàowéizhēndàilǎosūnjiāngxiāntiānzhīyàozhǐhuàguīzhèng ruòshìrénzhǐkǒngzǒulepángménzhīzhèngdàocǎiyàowéizhēndàilǎosūnjiāngxiāntiānzhīyàozhǐhuàguīzhèng

"If he is a man, I only fear he has gone off by a side door and does not know the true way, and takes the gathering of drugs for the real thing; then let old Monkey bring him round to the right path with the essentials of the primal teaching.

is páng, at the side — not the bàng that means to lean on something. 傍門, the side door, is the standing term for a heterodox path: the practices that look like the real discipline and lead nowhere. is wéi, takes X AS Y. 先天 xiān tiān is "prior to heaven" — the original state before the world was differentiated, and the goal of serious inner alchemy as against the swallowing of compounds.


總評 Commentary

Wukong's first response to the problem is not to fight anybody. It is to offer to teach. If the Royal Father-in-Law is a human being who has taken a wrong turning, the Great Sage proposes to sit him down and explain where he went wrong.

The distinction he draws is a real one and the novel takes it seriously throughout. There is an inner alchemy that works on the practitioner's own nature and an outer one that gathers and swallows substances, and this book consistently treats the first as the discipline and the second as the side door. The king's whole tragedy is that he has bought the second.

It is also worth noticing that Wukong — who was himself a Daoist adept long before he was a Buddhist pilgrim, and who stole and ate the elixir of immortality in the first ten chapters of this book — is the one qualified to make the distinction. He has done both.