Canonical Classics ← 第七十四回
第七十四回
長cháng庚gēng傳chuán報bào魔mó頭tóu狠hěn
行xíng者zhě施shī為wéi變biàn化huà能néng

Long Geng Brings Word of a Fierce Demon Chief · Pilgrim Works His Powers of Transformation

便是假的
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

便是假的 Say It Wrong And You Are False

行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ曉xiǎo得dé,快kuài說shuō來lái我wǒ聽tīng。如rú若ruò說shuō得de合hé著zhe我wǒ,便biàn是shì真zhēn的de;若ruò說shuō差chà了le一yì些xiē兒ér,便biàn是shì假jiǎ的de,我wǒ定dìng拿ná去qù見jiàn大dà王wáng處chù治zhì。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ晓xiǎo得dé,快kuài说shuō来lái我wǒ听tīng。如rú若ruò说shuō得de合hé着zhe我wǒ,便biàn是shì真zhēn的de;若ruò说shuō差chà了le一yì些xiē儿ér,便biàn是shì假jiǎ的de,我wǒ定dìng拿ná去qù见jiàn大dà王wáng处chù治zhì。」


逐句解 Line by line

行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ曉xiǎo得dé,快kuài說shuō來lái我wǒ聽tīng。 行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ晓xiǎo得dé,快kuài说shuō来lái我wǒ听tīng。

Pilgrim said, "If you know, say it out quickly and let me hear.

曉得 keeps 得 as dé, the attainment reading after a verb of knowing. The tone has hardened from question to instruction.

如rú若ruò說shuō得de合hé著zhe我wǒ,便biàn是shì真zhēn的de; 如rú若ruò说shuō得de合hé着zhe我wǒ,便biàn是shì真zhēn的de;

If what you say tallies with mine, you are genuine;

說得 has 得 unstressed as de, hanging the condition on the verb, and 合著 takes 著 as zhe — the only sealed instance of that compound reads the same way. The standard being offered is agreement with an answer Pilgrim does not have.

若ruò說shuō差chà了le一yì些xiē兒ér,便biàn是shì假jiǎ的de,我wǒ定dìng拿ná去qù見jiàn大dà王wáng處chù治zhì。」 若ruò说shuō差chà了le一yì些xiē儿ér,便biàn是shì假jiǎ的de,我wǒ定dìng拿ná去qù见jiàn大dà王wáng处chù治zhì。」

and if you are out by the smallest thing, you are false, and I shall take you straight to the king to be dealt with."

差 here is chà, wrong or off — and eight units further on the same character will be chāi, to dispatch, in a completely different sense. 處治 is to deal with in the punitive sense, what a magistrate does to somebody brought before him.


總評 Commentary

The test is unfalsifiable and everybody accepts it. Tell me what I already know, and if you agree with me you are honest — from a man who knows nothing at all.

It works because it is exactly the shape a real loyalty test takes. The person being checked cannot see the answer sheet and must assume there is one.

And the threat at the end is administrative rather than physical. Not I shall kill you but I shall take you to be dealt with, which in an organisation with tallies and a roll call is the more frightening sentence.