Canonical Classics ← 第七十四回
第七十四回
chánggēngchuánbàotóuhěn
xíngzhěshīwéibiànhuànéng

Long Geng Brings Word of a Fierce Demon Chief · Pilgrim Works His Powers of Transformation

卻是個謠言
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

卻是個謠言 It Was Only A Rumour

xíngzhěwényánànjīngdào:「zhèkànjiànleruòwèikànjiànzěnmejiùzhīdemíngyòuzhīhuìbiàncāngyíng?」yuánláixiǎoyāocéngjiànzhǐshìtóuzhīzěnmejiùfēnfuzhèhuàquèshìyáoyánzhuózhèděngniànxíngzhěwényánànjīngdào:「zhèkànjiànleruòwèikànjiànzěnmejiùzhīdemíngyòuzhīhuìbiàncāngyíng?」yuánláixiǎoyāocéngjiànzhǐshìtóuzhīzěnmejiùfēnfuzhèhuàquèshìyáoyánzhuózhèděngniàn


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhěwényánànjīngdào:「zhèkànjiànle xíngzhěwényánànjīngdào:「zhèkànjiànle

Hearing it, Pilgrim was startled and doubtful, and said to himself, "This creature has seen me?

暗自驚疑 is startled and suspicious in private — the whole reaction happens inside. For once Pilgrim is the one being frightened by a report.

ruòwèikànjiànzěnmejiùzhīdemíngyòuzhīhuìbiàncāngyíng?」 ruòwèikànjiànzěnmejiùzhīdemíngyòuzhīhuìbiàncāngyíng?」

And if he has not seen me, how does he know my name, and know that I can turn into a fly?"

The reasoning is sound and the conclusion will be wrong, which is the shape of nearly every argument in this chapter. He is doing what Tripitaka did with the old man: taking a coincidence for evidence.

yuánláixiǎoyāocéngjiànzhǐshìtóuzhīzěnmejiùfēnfuzhèhuàquèshìyáoyánzhuózhèděngniàn yuánláixiǎoyāocéngjiànzhǐshìtóuzhīzěnmejiùfēnfuzhèhuàquèshìyáoyánzhuózhèděngniàn

In fact the little demon had never seen him either. The demon chief had somehow given him this to say, and it was nothing but a rumour, which he had been set to chanting in this fashion.

The narrator steps in to settle it, which this book does rarely and always when a misunderstanding would otherwise run too long. 謠言 is a rumour, a thing put about. And here is zhuó, the causative — set him to it, made him say it — a different band from the four durative ones a few lines earlier.


總評 Commentary

The narrator's intervention is the structural point of the passage. We are told flatly that the demon has not seen anything, so the reader watches Pilgrim reason himself into a false conclusion knowing it is false.

What the demon chief has actually done is brief his patrols on a known enemy, which is ordinary competence. Pilgrim reads it as detection because it is uncomfortably accurate.

It is also the first time in the chapter that anybody has out-thought him, and the person who did it has not appeared yet.