Canonical Classics ← 第三十八回
第三十八回
yīngérwènzhīxiézhèng
jīncānxuánjiànjiǎzhēn

The Infant Questions His Mother and Learns the Crooked from the Upright · Metal and Wood, Probing the Mystery, Perceive the False and the True

負屍出水
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

負屍出水 Surfacing With the Corpse

jièhuítóukànjiànshuǐjīnggōngménzháohuángdeshīshǒuhuāngdejiǎoruǎnjīncuānchūshuǐmiànbānzhejǐngqiángjiàodào:「shīxiōngshēnxiàbàngláijiùjiù。」xíngzhědào:「yǒubǎobèime?」jièdào:「yǒuzhǐshìshuǐxiàyǒujǐnglóngwángjiàotuóréncéngtuójiùsòngchūménláijiùjiànshuǐjīnggōnglezhǐzháoshīshǒuxiàdeshǒuruǎnjīnzhēngcuōdòngleyahǎodǎijiùjiùer。」xíngzhědào:「jiùshìbǎobèituóshànglái?」jièdào:「zhīleduōshǎoshíletuózěnde?」xíngzhědào:「tuóhuí。」jièdào:「huí?」xíngzhědào:「huízhōngtóngshīshuìjiào。」jièhuítóukànjiànshuǐjīnggōngménzháohuángdeshīshǒuhuāngdejiǎoruǎnjīncuānchūshuǐmiànbānzhejǐngqiángjiàodào:「shīxiōngshēnxiàbàngláijiùjiù。」xíngzhědào:「yǒubǎobèime?」jièdào:「yǒuzhǐshìshuǐxiàyǒujǐnglóngwángjiàotuóréncéngtuójiùsòngchūménláijiùjiànshuǐjīnggōnglezhǐzháoshīshǒuxiàdeshǒuruǎnjīnzhēngcuōdòngleyahǎodǎijiùjiùer。」xíngzhědào:「jiùshìbǎobèituóshànglái?」jièdào:「zhīleduōshǎoshíletuózěnde?」xíngzhědào:「tuóhuí。」jièdào:「huí?」xíngzhědào:「huízhōngtóngshīshuìjiào。」


逐句解 Line by line

jièhuítóukànjiànshuǐjīnggōngménzháohuángdeshīshǒuhuāngdejiǎoruǎnjīncuānchūshuǐmiànbānzhejǐngqiángjiàodào:「shīxiōngshēnxiàbàngláijiùjiù。」 jièhuítóukànjiànshuǐjīnggōngménzháohuángdeshīshǒuhuāngdejiǎoruǎnjīncuānchūshuǐmiànbānzhejǐngqiángjiàodào:「shīxiōngshēnxiàbàngláijiùjiù。」

Bajie quickly looked back — the gate of the Crystal Palace was gone; his hand fell upon the emperor's corpse, and, flustered till his legs went soft and his sinews numb, he shot up to the surface, clung to the well-wall, and cried: 'Brother! Reach the staff down and save me!'

一把摸著: his hand closes on it ( = zháo, marking the contact as made). 慌得: flustered to the point that ( = de). 攛出水面: shoots up to the surface. 扳著井牆: hangs on to the well-wall ( = bān; = zhe). The gate is gone, the water is back, and there is a dead emperor in his arms. = ; 不見 = .

xíngzhědào:「yǒubǎobèime?」 xíngzhědào:「yǒubǎobèime?」

The Pilgrim said: 'Is there any treasure?'

Wukong, who has worked out the whole thing from the surface, asks after the treasure. = xíng.

jièdào:「yǒuzhǐshìshuǐxiàyǒujǐnglóngwángjiàotuóréncéngtuójiùsòngchūménláijiùjiànshuǐjīnggōnglezhǐzháoshīshǒu jièdào:「yǒuzhǐshìshuǐxiàyǒujǐnglóngwángjiàotuóréncéngtuójiùsòngchūménláijiùjiànshuǐjīnggōnglezhǐzháoshīshǒu

Bajie said: 'Where's any treasure? There's only a Well Dragon-King at the bottom, who'd have me haul a dead man; I wouldn't do it, so he sent me packing out the gate, the crystal palace vanished, and now I've only got hold of this corpse.'

教我馱死人: wanted me to haul a dead man ( = jiào). Note the two readings in one speech: 那裡有 is the questioning , 'where would there be any?', while 那水晶宮 and 那個屍首 are the pointing . 摸著 = zháo.

xiàdeshǒuruǎnjīnzhēngcuōdòngle xiàdeshǒuruǎnjīnzhēngcuōdòngle

'It's frightened me till my hands are soft and my sinews numb — I can't struggle free.'

諕得: frightened to the point that ( = xià, the older writing of ; = de). 掙搓不動: cannot struggle free ( = ).

yahǎodǎijiùjiùer。」 yahǎodǎijiùjiùer。」

'Brother, come what may, save me, save me!'

好歹: come what may, one way or another. 救我救兒: save me, save me — the here is a light colloquial tag rather than a word in its own right, the vocal equivalent of a tug on the sleeve.

xíngzhědào:「jiùshìbǎobèituóshànglái?」 xíngzhědào:「jiùshìbǎobèituóshànglái?」

The Pilgrim said: 'That's the very treasure — why don't you haul it up?'

The reveal, delivered with maximum economy. That is the treasure. 那個就是寶貝 ( = ).

jièdào:「zhīleduōshǎoshíletuózěnde?」 jièdào:「zhīleduōshǎoshíletuózěnde?」

Bajie said: 'Who knows how long he's been dead — what do I want with hauling him?'

死了多少時: dead how long, exactly? A fair question from a man in the water with it.

xíngzhědào:「tuóhuí。」 xíngzhědào:「tuóhuí。」

The Pilgrim said: 'If you won't carry him, I'm going back.'

And the threat that ends every argument these two ever have. = xíng.

jièdào:「huí?」 jièdào:「huí?」

Bajie said: 'Go back where?'

回那裡去: 'back where?' ( = , the questioning reading).

xíngzhědào:「huízhōngtóngshīshuìjiào。」 xíngzhědào:「huízhōngtóngshīshuìjiào。」

The Pilgrim said: 'Back to the temple, to sleep with the Master.'

寺中: = zhōng. 睡覺: to go to sleep ( = jiào, the 'sleep' reading, not jué). He is proposing to go to bed and leave his brother clinging to a well-wall in the dark with a corpse.


總評 Commentary

The trap closes with a jolt of the marvelous. The palace vanishes, the water returns, and Bajie comes up with an emperor in his arms. His panic — legs soft, sinews numb, clinging to the well-wall and shouting for rescue — is broad physical comedy, and his account of the dragon-king's ruse is the aggrieved report of a man comprehensively outmaneuvered by someone he took for a pauper.

Wukong, who has known all along, turns the screw with a deadpan question about the treasure. When Bajie balks at the corpse he supplies the truth — that is the treasure — and then, meeting the pig's disgust, reaches for his surest weapon: the announcement that he is going back to the temple to sleep, leaving his brother stranded in the well with a body he cannot climb out past.

The exchange distils both the pair's dynamic and the chapter's method. Every stage of this recovery has been achieved by working on Bajie rather than on the problem — first greed, then fear, and now the threat of abandonment. The comedy of the reluctant corpse-bearer, bargaining on a well-wall for his own rescue, will run all the way back to the temple.