Canonical Classics ← 第三十八回
第三十八回
yīngérwènzhīxiézhèng
jīncānxuánjiànjiǎzhēn

The Infant Questions His Mother and Learns the Crooked from the Upright · Metal and Wood, Probing the Mystery, Perceive the False and the True

官事對頭
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

官事對頭 A Suit With a Plaintiff

quèjiàotàishàngláihuánghòuchūláirènwénduōguānjiànzhǔlǎosūnxiōngmendòngshǒuzhècáishìyǒuduìtóudeguānshìhǎo。」tángsēngwényánàndào:「zhǐjièkěn。」xíngzhěxiàodào:「shuōduǎnzěnmejiùzhīkěnzhǐxiàngjiàoshíyìngbànshíchén便biànlezhèdànpíngsāncùnlànzhīshéshuōshìzhūjièjiùshìzhūjiǔjièyǒuběnshìjiàogēnzhezǒu。」tángsēngdào:「basuíjiào。」quèjiàotàishàngláihuánghòuchūláirènwénduōguānjiànzhǔlǎosūnxiōngmendòngshǒuzhècáishìyǒuduìtóudeguānshìhǎo。」tángsēngwényánàndào:「zhǐjièkěn。」xíngzhěxiàodào:「shuōduǎnzěnmejiùzhīkěnzhǐxiàngjiàoshíyìngbànshíchén便biànlezhèdànpíngsāncùnlànzhīshéshuōshìzhūjièjiùshìzhūjiǔjièyǒuběnshìjiàogēnzhezǒu。」tángsēngdào:「basuíjiào。」


逐句解 Line by line

quèjiàotàishàngláihuánghòuchūláirènwénduōguānjiànzhǔlǎosūnxiōngmendòngshǒu quèjiàotàishàngláihuánghòuchūláirènwénduōguānjiànzhǔlǎosūnxiōngmendòngshǒu

'Then we will have the prince come forward to weep for his father, the queen come out to know her husband, and the host of civil and military officers behold their sovereign — and old Sun and his brothers will set to.'

Three witnesses, each supplying a different kind of proof: 哭父, a son weeping for his father; 認夫, a wife identifying her husband; 見主, the officials looking at their sovereign. Only then do the brothers start swinging. = jiào, 'to have someone do'; 太子: = .

zhècáishìyǒuduìtóudeguānshìhǎo。」 zhècáishìyǒuduìtóudeguānshìhǎo。」

'That is what it means to have a case with a plaintiff — a suit worth pressing.'

有對頭的官事: a lawsuit with a proper opposing party, 對頭 being the adversary on the other side of the case. A charge nobody brings is no charge at all — which is why the body and the witnesses have to arrive together.

tángsēngwényánàndào:「zhǐjièkěn。」 tángsēngwényánàndào:「zhǐjièkěn。」

Hearing this, the Tang Monk was secretly pleased, and said: 'I only fear Bajie will not be willing to go.'

暗喜, secretly delighted — because the plan sends somebody else down the well. 只怕: 'my one worry is.' 不肯 = .

xíngzhěxiàodào:「 xíngzhěxiàodào:「

The Pilgrim said with a laugh: 'What did I say?'

Wukong pounces. The worry itself is the evidence.

shuōduǎn shuōduǎn

'I said you shield your own.'

One line, and the case is closed on the master.

zěnmejiùzhīkěn zěnmejiùzhīkěn

'How do you know already that he won't go?'

How could you possibly know what Bajie will say, unless you have been thinking about him? 不肯 = .

zhǐxiàngjiàoshíyìngbànshíchén便biànle zhǐxiàngjiàoshíyìngbànshíchén便biànle

'You need only do as you did when I called you and got no answer — just for half an hour.'

And the favor he asks is perfect: do exactly what you just did to me — lie there and don't answer — for half an hour, so I can work on Bajie undisturbed. 不答應 has as yìng, 'to answer.' 便了: 'and that's all' ( = le).

zhèdànpíngsāncùnlànzhīshéshuōshìzhūjièjiùshìzhūjiǔjièyǒuběnshìjiàogēnzhezǒu。」 zhèdànpíngsāncùnlànzhīshéshuōshìzhūjièjiùshìzhūjiǔjièyǒuběnshìjiàogēnzhezǒu。」

'When I go, with nothing but my three cùn of unrotting tongue, never mind Pig Eight-Prohibitions — were he Pig Nine-Prohibitions, I'd still have the skill to talk him into following me.'

三寸不爛之舌 — 'a three-cùn tongue that never rots' — is the standing Chinese phrase for irresistible persuasion, and it is still in daily use; the (cùn) is the Chinese measure of roughly a finger-joint, left in Chinese here because English has no borrowed name for it. Then the joke: 八戒 means 'Eight Prohibitions,' the eight monastic vows, so 豬九戒 — 'Pig Nine-Prohibitions' — simply adds one, as if piety came in sizes. 教他跟著: talk him into coming along ( = jiào; = zhe).

tángsēngdào:「basuíjiào。」 tángsēngdào:「basuíjiào。」

The Tang Monk said: 'Very well — go and call him as you please.'

也罷, 'oh, very well' — the sound of a man giving up ( = ba). 隨你: suit yourself.


總評 Commentary

The second half of the plan completes its courtroom logic. The recovered body will be met by a full slate of witnesses — the weeping prince, the wife who knows her husband, the assembled court — so that the confrontation becomes a public trial rather than a private brawl. Wukong's own phrase names the principle: a suit with a plaintiff is a suit worth pressing. Evidence alone is not enough; somebody has to bring the charge.

The comic thread tightens around Tripitaka. His fear that Bajie won't cooperate is turned against him instantly — proof, Wukong crows, that he shields his own. And the favor Wukong then asks is a small gem: the master need only feign sleep and give no answer, exactly as he had a moment before, so that Wukong may work on the pig without interference.

The boast that closes the passage — that a three-cùn tongue could talk even a 'Pig Nine-Prohibitions' into line — sets up the recruitment scene. The chapter has been building through these nested negotiations toward its central set-piece, and it is about to arrive: the drafting of the world's most reluctant accomplice.