Canonical Classics ← 第三十八回
第三十八回
yīngérwènzhīxiézhèng
jīncānxuánjiànjiǎzhēn

The Infant Questions His Mother and Learns the Crooked from the Upright · Metal and Wood, Probing the Mystery, Perceive the False and the True

芭蕉標井
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

芭蕉標井 The Plantain Marks the Well

jièdào:「qiětànzuòshénkuàigànmendemǎimàilái。」xíngzhěsuīrángǎnkǎiquèliúxīnxiǎngtángsēngdemèngláishuōjiāoshùxiàfāngshìjǐngzhèngxíngzǒuguǒjiànzhūjiāoshēngdemàoshèngzhònghuātóngzhēnshìjièdào:「qiětànzuòshénkuàigànmendemǎimàilái。」xíngzhěsuīrángǎnkǎiquèliúxīnxiǎngtángsēngdemèngláishuōjiāoshùxiàfāngshìjǐngzhèngxíngzǒuguǒjiànzhūjiāoshēngdemàoshèngzhònghuātóngzhēnshì

zhǒnglíngmiáoxiùtiānshēngxìngkōngzhǒnglíngmiáoxiùtiānshēngxìngkōng
zhīzhīchōupiànzhǐjuǎnfāngcóngzhīzhīchōupiànzhǐjuǎnfāngcóng
cuìqiāntiáodānxīndiǎnhóngcuìqiāntiáodānxīndiǎnhóng
liángchóuqiáocuìqièqiūfēngliángchóuqiáocuìqièqiūfēng
zhǎngyǎngyuándīngzāipéizàohuàgōngzhǎngyǎngyuándīngzāipéizàohuàgōng
jiānshūchéngmiàoyònghuīyǒugōngjiānshūchéngmiàoyònghuīyǒugōng
fènglíngníngluánwěijiǒngxiāngtóngfènglíngníngluánwěijiǒngxiāngtóng
rángrángqīngyāndàndànlóngrángrángqīngyāndàndànlóng
qīngyīnzhēyǒuyǐngshàngliánlóngqīngyīnzhēyǒuyǐngshàngliánlóng
hóngyànkāncōng鸿hóngyànkāncōng
shuāngtiānxínggǎocuìyuèménglóngshuāngtiānxínggǎocuìyuèménglóng
jǐnxiāoyánshǔyóuhōngjǐnxiāoyánshǔyóuhōng
kuìtáolěngluòfěnqiángdōngkuìtáolěngluòfěnqiángdōng

逐句解 Line by line

jièdào:「qiětànzuòshén jièdào:「qiětànzuòshén

Bajie said: 'And what's the good of sighing over it?'

且嘆他做甚: 'and what's the good of sighing over it?' Bajie has no patience with scenery. = shén, 'what.'

kuàigànmendemǎimàilái。」 kuàigànmendemǎimàilái。」

'Let's get on with our business.'

買賣, the 'business' again — he has not stopped thinking about the treasure for a moment. 快幹去來: let's get on with it.

xíngzhěsuīrángǎnkǎiquèliúxīnxiǎngtángsēngdemèngláishuōjiāoshùxiàfāngshìjǐng xíngzhěsuīrángǎnkǎiquèliúxīnxiǎngtángsēngdemèngláishuōjiāoshùxiàfāngshìjǐng

The Pilgrim, though moved, kept his wits about him and recalled the Tang Monk's dream, which said that the well lay beneath the plantain tree.

留心: kept his wits about him. He is moved by the ruin and still remembers the one useful detail from the drowned king's dream in the previous chapter — the well is under the plantain. = xíng.

zhèngxíngzǒuguǒjiànzhūjiāoshēngdemàoshèngzhònghuātóng zhèngxíngzǒuguǒjiànzhūjiāoshēngdemàoshèngzhònghuātóng

As they walked on, sure enough they saw a plantain, grown lush and thriving, unlike all the other plants and trees.

One plant thriving in a dead garden is a marker, and they both see it. 一株芭蕉: a single plantain, the broad-leaved banana relative. 生得茂盛: grown lush ( = de).

zhēnshì zhēnshì

Truly it was:

真是, 'truly it was' — the tag introducing the display poem on the plantain that follows, a long regulated piece in the 排律 form, where the parallel couplets simply keep going.

zhǒnglíngmiáoxiùtiānshēngxìngkōng zhǒnglíngmiáoxiùtiānshēngxìngkōng

A single numinous shoot, gracefully fair, / by nature born with a hollow, empty core.

一種靈苗秀: one shoot with spirit in it, and a fair one. 天生體性空: hollow by nature. The plantain's stalk has no pith — it is leaf wrapped round leaf round nothing — which made it the stock emblem of Buddhist emptiness, . Peel it to find the core and you find there is no core, which is rather the point.

zhīzhīchōupiànzhǐjuǎnfāngcóng zhīzhīchōupiànzhǐjuǎnfāngcóng

Stalk after stalk unfurls a sheet like paper; / leaf after leaf rolls up its fragrant cluster.

抽片紙捲芳叢: each stalk draws out a sheet like paper, each leaf rolls up its fragrant cluster. Plantain leaves really were used as writing surfaces, and the poem will come back to that.

cuìqiāntiáodānxīndiǎnhóng cuìqiāntiáodānxīndiǎnhóng

A thousand kingfisher-green threads, fine and slender; / one cinnabar heart, a single point of red.

翠縷丹心: kingfisher-green threads for the leaf veins, a cinnabar heart for the unopened bud. Two colors, and the poem has painted the plant.

liángchóuqiáocuìqièqiūfēng liángchóuqiáocuìqièqiūfēng

Forlorn, it grieves in the night rain; / wan and worn, it shrinks from the autumn wind.

The plantain personified — forlorn in the night rain, shrinking from the autumn wind. Its huge thin leaves tear easily, which is why it became the standard Chinese emblem of beautiful frailty.

zhǎngyǎngyuándīngzāipéizàohuàgōng zhǎngyǎngyuándīngzāipéizàohuàgōng

Its nurture owes to primal, sturdy strength; / its planting, to the craft of Creation itself.

長養: to nurture and bring on ( = zhǎng). 造化工 is the workmanship of Creation itself — nature as the craftsman who planted it.

jiānshūchéngmiàoyònghuīyǒugōng jiānshūchéngmiàoyònghuīyǒugōng

Sealed in letters, it serves a wondrous use; / brushed and splashed, it works a marvelous art.

緘書揮灑: 'sealed in letters' and 'brushed and splashed.' The leaf as writing paper again, this time in the calligrapher's hands. There is a famous story of a Tang monk too poor for paper who practiced his brushwork on plantain leaves, and the poem is leaning on it.

fènglíngníngluánwěijiǒngxiāngtóng fènglíngníngluánwěijiǒngxiāngtóng

How could the phoenix-plume be its equal? / The simurgh's tail is far from its like.

鳳翎鸞尾: the phoenix-plume and the simurgh's tail, two of the most beautiful things the tradition can name — and neither of them, the poem claims, is a match for a banana leaf. = ; = xiāng.

rángrángqīngyāndàndànlóng rángrángqīngyāndàndànlóng

Thin dew drips in glistening beads; / light mist enfolds it, faint and pale.

薄露輕煙: thin dew and light mist ( = , 'thin'). 瀼瀼 is dew hanging heavy and dripping.

qīngyīnzhēyǒuyǐngshàngliánlóng qīngyīnzhēyǒuyǐngshàngliánlóng

Its green shade curtains the window and door; / its jade shadow climbs the blind and lattice.

遮戶牖上簾櫳: the shade curtains the doorway, the shadow climbs the lattice. Planted by a window on purpose, then — that green light through paper screens is one of the pleasures the plant was grown for.

hóngyànkāncōng 鸿hóngyànkāncōng

It will not let the wild geese roost; / how could it serve to tether a jade-piebald steed?

不許棲鴻雁: too flimsy to bear a goose landing on it. 何堪繫玉驄: and far too flimsy to tie a horse to ( = , 'to tether'; 玉驄 is a jade-piebald mount). The poem is listing what the plantain is no good for, which turns out to be its best argument. = .

shuāngtiānxínggǎocuìyuèménglóng shuāngtiānxínggǎocuìyuèménglóng

Under frost-skies its form is withered; / on moonlit nights its hue is dim and blurred.

槁悴: withered under frost. 朦朧: blurred by moonlight. Two more ways of being faint.

jǐnxiāoyánshǔyóuhōng jǐnxiāoyánshǔyóuhōng

It serves but to dispel the summer's heat, / and is fit still to shelter from the sun's glare.

What it is good for, modestly stated: shade in high summer, a screen against the glare.

kuìtáolěngluòfěnqiángdōng kuìtáolěngluòfěnqiángdōng

Ashamed to lack the peach's and plum's bright color, / it stands neglected east of the whitewashed wall.

愧無桃李色 — 'ashamed to lack the color of peach and plum.' Peach and plum are the tradition's byword for showy popularity; the plantain has no blossom to speak of and stands out of the way by the whitewashed wall, unlooked-at. The poem has spent thirteen couplets praising a plant for being overlooked, which is exactly the note the chapter needs at this moment.


總評 Commentary

Bajie's brisk 'what's the good of sighing?' snaps the pair back to business, and Wukong, remembering the drowned king's dream, finds the well marked by a single lush plantain. Then the novel does something wonderfully unhurried: it stops the burglary dead and spends thirteen couplets on the banana tree.

The poem is a virtuoso object-poem, a 詠物詩, working through every attribute the plant has. The hollow pithless stalk, standing for Buddhist emptiness; the broad leaves likened to sheets of writing-paper; green veins and a red bud; frailty before wind and frost; a modest usefulness as summer shade. Throughout, the plantain is personified as forlorn and unshowy, ashamed to lack the bright color of peach and plum.

Placed here, the plantain quietly rhymes with the chapter's concerns. Its hollowness invokes the emptiness the Buddhist frame keeps in view, and its neglected, flowerless endurance beside a ruined garden figures a plain worth overlooked in a kingdom gone false. The lyric pause also sharpens by contrast the grim comedy about to follow — because it is directly under this delicate, much-praised plant that the king's body is lying.