Canonical Classics ← 第三十八回
第三十八回
yīngérwènzhīxiézhèng
jīncānxuánjiànjiǎzhēn

The Infant Questions His Mother and Learns the Crooked from the Upright · Metal and Wood, Probing the Mystery, Perceive the False and the True

叩問即位
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

叩問即位 Pressing the Question of the Throne

tàikòutóudào:「qīnwènwèidēnglóngshìchēngdàoguǎguǒrén?」niángniángwényándào:「zhèháiérfēnglezuòhuángdeshìwángwènzěnde?」tàikòutóudào:「wànwàngqīnshèzuìgǎnwènshègǎnwèn。」niángniángdào:「jiāyǒuzuìshèshèkuàikuàishuōlái。」tàidào:「qīnwènsānniánqiángōngzhīshìhòusānniánēnàitóngfǒu?」tàikòutóudào:「qīnwènwèidēnglóngshìchēngdàoguǎguǒrén?」niángniángwényándào:「zhèháiérfēnglezuòhuángdeshìwángwènzěnde?」tàikòutóudào:「wànwàngqīnshèzuìgǎnwènshègǎnwèn。」niángniángdào:「jiāyǒuzuìshèshèkuàikuàishuōlái。」tàidào:「qīnwènsānniánqiángōngzhīshìhòusānniánēnàitóngfǒu?」


逐句解 Line by line

tàikòutóudào:「qīnwènwèidēnglóngshì tàikòutóudào:「qīnwènwèidēnglóngshì

The prince knocked his head to the ground and said: 'Mother, I ask you — who is it that has taken the throne and mounted the dragon?

叩頭: to kowtow, knocking the forehead on the ground. 那個 here is interrogative (那 = nǎ, 'who/which'), not the deictic nà. 太子: 子 = zǐ.

chēngdàoguǎguǒrén?」 chēngdàoguǎguǒrén?」

Who, in truth, is the one who styles himself the Solitary and the Orphaned?'

稱孤道寡: 'to call oneself the Orphan (孤) and the Solitary (寡)' — the ritual self-humbling by which a sovereign refers to himself; 稱 = chēng.

niángniángwényándào:「zhèháiérfēngle niángniángwényándào:「zhèháiérfēngle

Hearing this, the lady said: 'Has the child gone out of his wits?

發風 (= 發瘋): to fly into a fit, to rave. 孩兒: 兒 = ér.

zuòhuángdeshìwángwènzěnde?」 zuòhuángdeshìwángwènzěnde?」

He who is emperor is your own father-king — why do you ask such a thing?'

The queen's exasperation is domestic and unknowing; the dramatic irony deepens, for the 'father-king' she names is the impostor.

tàikòutóudào:「wànwàngqīnshèzuìgǎnwèn tàikòutóudào:「wànwàngqīnshèzuìgǎnwèn

The prince knocked his head again and said: 'I beg my mother to hold your son blameless, and then I will make bold to ask;

赦子無罪: 'pardon your son as guiltless' — the prince frames his forbidden question as a treason to be forgiven in advance. 子 (twice) = zǐ.

shègǎnwèn。」 shègǎnwèn。」

if you will not pardon me, I dare not ask.'

The conditional presses the queen toward a pledge before the secret is broached.

niángniángdào:「jiāyǒuzuì niángniángdào:「jiāyǒuzuì

The lady said: 'Between mother and son, what crime could there be?

子母家: 'in a household of mother and son'; the queen waves away the notion of crime between kin. 子 = zǐ.

shèshèkuàikuàishuōlái。」 shèshèkuàikuàishuōlái。」

You are pardoned, you are pardoned — out with it, quickly.'

The doubled 赦你 grants the pardon twice over, her curiosity now fully caught.

tàidào:「qīnwènsānniánqiángōngzhīshìhòusānniánēnàitóngfǒu?」 tàidào:「qīnwènsānniánqiángōngzhīshìhòusānniánēnàitóngfǒu?」

The prince said: 'Mother, I ask you this: the matter of the bedchamber three years ago, and the conjugal love of the three years since — are they the same, or not?'

The question is deliberately intimate — comparing the conjugal tenderness (恩愛) of the marriage before and after the king's supposed change. This is the hinge on which the impostor will be exposed. 太子: 子 = zǐ.


總評 Commentary

The interrogation advances by ritual increments — kowtow, plea for pardon, conditional withholding — each gesture raising the stakes before the question is spoken. The prince's rhetoric (稱孤道寡, 即位登龍) is courtly and oblique, circling the throne rather than naming his suspicion outright.

The queen's replies are pitched in unknowing domesticity: has the boy gone mad? what crime could there be between mother and son? Her very ordinariness sharpens the reader's foreknowledge — she defends a 'father-king' who is a demon wearing the true king's shape.

The prince's final question is the chapter's diagnostic instrument. By asking whether the conjugal love of the last three years matches what came before, he seeks the one thing an impostor cannot forge: the intimate warmth of a marriage. The answer, given in verse, will confirm the demon, and the whole apparatus of recognition — 邪正, false and true — turns on this most private of tests.