Canonical Classics ← 第二十三回
第二十三回
三sān藏zàng不bú忘wàng本běn
四sì聖shèng試shì禪chán心xīn

Tripitaka Does Not Forget His Origin · The Four Saints Test the Meditative Heart

天晚安歇
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

天晚安歇 Shelter at Nightfall

正zhèng走zǒu處chù,不bù覺jué天tiān晚wǎn。三sān藏zàng道dào:「徒tú弟dì,如rú今jīn天tiān色sè又yòu晚wǎn,卻què往wǎng那nǎ裡lǐ安ān歇xiē?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「師shī父fù說shuō話huà差chà了le。出chū家jiā人rén餐cān風fēng宿sù水shuǐ,臥wò月yuè眠mián霜shuāng,隨suí處chù是shì家jiā。又yòu問wèn那nǎ裡lǐ安ān歇xiē,何hé也yě?」豬zhū八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē啊a,你nǐ可kě知zhī道dào你nǐ走zǒu路lù輕qīng省shěng,那nǎ裡lǐ管guǎn別bié人rén累lèi墜zhuì?自zì過guò了le流liú沙shā河hé,這zhè一yí向xiàng爬pá山shān過guò嶺lǐng,身shēn挑tiāo著zhe重zhòng擔dān,老lǎo大dà難nán挨āi也yě。須xū是shì尋xún個gè人rén家jiā,一yì則zé化huà些xiē茶chá飯fàn,二èr則zé養yǎng養yǎng精jīng神shén,才cái是shì個gè道dào理lǐ。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「獃dāi子zi,你nǐ這zhè般bān言yán語yǔ,似sì有yǒu報bào怨yuàn之zhī心xīn。還hái像xiàng在zài高gāo老lǎo莊zhuāng倚yǐ懶lǎn不bù求qiú福fú的de自zì在zài,恐kǒng不bù能néng也yě。既jì是shì秉bǐng正zhèng沙shā門mén,須xū是shì要yào吃chī辛xīn受shòu苦kǔ,才cái做zuò得de徒tú弟dì哩li。」正zhèng走zǒu处chù,不bù觉jué天tiān晚wǎn。三sān藏zàng道dào:「徒tú弟dì,如rú今jīn天tiān色sè又yòu晚wǎn,却què往wǎng那nǎ里lǐ安ān歇xiē?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「师shī父fù说shuō话huà差chà了le。出chū家jiā人rén餐cān风fēng宿sù水shuǐ,卧wò月yuè眠mián霜shuāng,随suí处chù是shì家jiā。又yòu问wèn那nǎ里lǐ安ān歇xiē,何hé也yě?」猪zhū八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē啊a,你nǐ可kě知zhī道dào你nǐ走zǒu路lù轻qīng省shěng,那nǎ里lǐ管guǎn别bié人rén累lèi坠zhuì?自zì过guò了le流liú沙shā河hé,这zhè一yí向xiàng爬pá山shān过guò岭lǐng,身shēn挑tiāo着zhe重zhòng担dān,老lǎo大dà难nán挨āi也yě。须xū是shì寻xún个gè人rén家jiā,一yì则zé化huà些xiē茶chá饭fàn,二èr则zé养yǎng养yǎng精jīng神shén,才cái是shì个gè道dào理lǐ。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「呆dāi子zi,你nǐ这zhè般bān言yán语yǔ,似sì有yǒu报bào怨yuàn之zhī心xīn。还hái像xiàng在zài高gāo老lǎo庄zhuāng倚yǐ懒lǎn不bù求qiú福fú的de自zì在zài,恐kǒng不bù能néng也yě。既jì是shì秉bǐng正zhèng沙shā门mén,须xū是shì要yào吃chī辛xīn受shòu苦kǔ,才cái做zuò得de徒tú弟dì哩li。」


逐句解 Line by line

正zhèng走zǒu處chù,不bù覺jué天tiān晚wǎn。 正zhèng走zǒu处chù,不bù觉jué天tiān晚wǎn。

Just as they were pressing on, before they knew it evening had fallen.

A short hinge, turning the scenery back into a story: 正走處, just as they were walking along.

三sān藏zàng道dào:「徒tú弟dì,如rú今jīn天tiān色sè又yòu晚wǎn,卻què往wǎng那nǎ裡lǐ安ān歇xiē?」 三sān藏zàng道dào:「徒tú弟dì,如rú今jīn天tiān色sè又yòu晚wǎn,却què往wǎng那nǎ里lǐ安ān歇xiē?」

Sanzang said, "Disciples, the sky darkens once again — where are we to go and rest?"

In 那裡, meaning where, the 那 is the question-word nǎ rather than the pointing nà — the same two characters, two jobs, and this chapter uses both dozens of times. 安歇 is to put up for the night.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「師shī父fù說shuō話huà差chà了le。 行xíng者zhě道dào:「师shī父fù说shuō话huà差chà了le。

Pilgrim said, "Master, you speak amiss.

說話差了, you have spoken wrongly, with 差 as chà, to be off, to err.

出chū家jiā人rén餐cān風fēng宿sù水shuǐ,臥wò月yuè眠mián霜shuāng,隨suí處chù是shì家jiā。 出chū家jiā人rén餐cān风fēng宿sù水shuǐ,卧wò月yuè眠mián霜shuāng,随suí处chù是shì家jiā。

One who has left the household feeds on the wind and lodges by the water, sleeps beneath the moon and beds down in the frost — everywhere is home.

Wukong answers with a string of set phrases about homelessness: 餐風宿水 and 臥月眠霜, dine on wind and lodge by water, lie under the moon and bed down in frost. 隨處是家, everywhere is home, is the motto they add up to — and a sharp jab at a disciple who has just started pining for a roof.

又yòu問wèn那nǎ裡lǐ安ān歇xiē,何hé也yě?」 又yòu问wèn那nǎ里lǐ安ān歇xiē,何hé也yě?」

Why, then, ask where we shall lodge?"

何也, why so? And 那裡 is once more the question-word nǎ.

豬zhū八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē啊a,你nǐ可kě知zhī道dào你nǐ走zǒu路lù輕qīng省shěng,那nǎ裡lǐ管guǎn別bié人rén累lèi墜zhuì? 猪zhū八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē啊a,你nǐ可kě知zhī道dào你nǐ走zǒu路lù轻qīng省shěng,那nǎ里lǐ管guǎn别bié人rén累lèi坠zhuì?

Zhu Bajie said, "Brother — do you know how light your own travelling is? What do you care for another's weary burden?

Bajie's reply is the complaint of a man carrying the bags for somebody who is not. 輕省 (qīng shěng) is travelling light and easy; 那裡管, as if you would care, is the 那 of rhetorical questions, nǎ again; 累墜 is the drag of a heavy load on a body.

自zì過guò了le流liú沙shā河hé,這zhè一yí向xiàng爬pá山shān過guò嶺lǐng,身shēn挑tiāo著zhe重zhòng擔dān,老lǎo大dà難nán挨āi也yě。 自zì过guò了le流liú沙shā河hé,这zhè一yí向xiàng爬pá山shān过guò岭lǐng,身shēn挑tiāo着zhe重zhòng担dān,老lǎo大dà难nán挨āi也yě。

Ever since we crossed the Flowing-Sands River, all this while it has been climbing mountains and crossing ridges, my body shouldering the heavy load — hard, so hard to bear!

一向 is all this while. In 挑著 the 著 is the little zhe that keeps an action running — shouldering, and going on shouldering. 重擔, the heavy load, takes 重 as zhòng; 老大 is a colloquial intensifier, greatly, mightily; 難挨 is hard to endure.

須xū是shì尋xún個gè人rén家jiā,一yì則zé化huà些xiē茶chá飯fàn,二èr則zé養yǎng養yǎng精jīng神shén,才cái是shì個gè道dào理lǐ。」 须xū是shì寻xún个gè人rén家jiā,一yì则zé化huà些xiē茶chá饭fàn,二èr则zé养yǎng养yǎng精jīng神shén,才cái是shì个gè道dào理lǐ。」

We really must find a household: first, to beg a little tea and rice; second, to restore our spirits — that would be the sensible course."

化些茶飯 — 化 is the monk's word for begging alms. Bajie lays his case out in numbered points, 一則 and then 二則, like a man presenting a budget. Keep an eye on what he is asking for: the 人家, the household, is about to appear on cue, and it is a trap.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「獃dāi子zi,你nǐ這zhè般bān言yán語yǔ,似sì有yǒu報bào怨yuàn之zhī心xīn。 行xíng者zhě道dào:「呆dāi子zi,你nǐ这zhè般bān言yán语yǔ,似sì有yǒu报bào怨yuàn之zhī心xīn。

Pilgrim said, "Idiot! Talk like this sounds like a grumbling, resentful heart.

獃子, blockhead, is what Wukong calls Bajie roughly every time he opens his mouth. 似有 uses 似 (sì), to seem; 報怨 here stands for 抱怨, to nurse a grievance.

還hái像xiàng在zài高gāo老lǎo莊zhuāng倚yǐ懶lǎn不bù求qiú福fú的de自zì在zài,恐kǒng不bù能néng也yě。 还hái像xiàng在zài高gāo老lǎo庄zhuāng倚yǐ懒lǎn不bù求qiú福fú的de自zì在zài,恐kǒng不bù能néng也yě。

Still hankering after the idle ease of Gao Village — shirking effort, seeking no blessing — that, I fear, will not do.

還 is hái, still. 高老莊, Gao Village, is where Bajie had settled down as a live-in son-in-law until Wukong hauled him out of it five chapters back; naming it is a low blow, and an accurate one. 倚懶 is to lean on your own laziness, and 不求福 to chase no merit at all.

既jì是shì秉bǐng正zhèng沙shā門mén,須xū是shì要yào吃chī辛xīn受shòu苦kǔ,才cái做zuò得de徒tú弟dì哩li。」 既jì是shì秉bǐng正zhèng沙shā门mén,须xū是shì要yào吃chī辛xīn受shòu苦kǔ,才cái做zuò得de徒tú弟dì哩li。」

Now that you are a monk who holds to the right, you must eat bitterness and bear hardship — only so do you make a true disciple!"

沙門 is śramaṇa, a Buddhist mendicant; 秉正 is to hold to the orthodox. In 做得徒弟 the 得 is the structural de of managing to be something, not the verb dé, to get.


總評 Commentary

The chapter's comic engine starts here, in the friction between what Bajie's body wants and what Wukong's doctrine demands. Bajie complains entirely in the flesh — the weight of the pack, the endless ridges, no tea and no rice. Wukong answers entirely from the rule book: a real monk is at home anywhere and seeks hardship on purpose. That argument, flesh against spirit, is the one this novel never stops having.

The passage is thick with the vocabulary of having no home — dine on wind, sleep in frost, everywhere is home, hold to the orthodox — all of it praising the man who owns nothing and belongs nowhere. Against that, Bajie pleads the memory of Gao Village and the comfortable life he lost there. This is not idle. The trial about to be set for these four is a household, a wife, and a life of ease: exactly the thing Bajie has just been caught wishing for, out loud, in front of witnesses.

Two readings anchor the scene: the question-word 那 (nǎ) that keeps recurring in 那裡 and 那裡管, and the structural 得 (de) of managing-to-be in 做得徒弟. And the irony is laid on with a trowel: Bajie asks for a household to shelter in, and the story is about to hand him one built specifically to expose him.