Canonical Classics ← 第八十三回
第八十三回
xīnyuánshídāntóu
chàháiguīběnxìng

The Mind-Ape Knows the Elixir Head · The Fair Girl Returns to Her Original Nature

紙狀兒
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

紙狀兒 Another Plaint On Paper

kuàngzhuàngyòushìqīnggàodeqiěshuōzěndegào?」xíngzhěxiàodào:「yǒuzhǔzhāngzhèpáiwèixiāngzuòzhèngjiànlìngwàizàibèizhǐzhuàngér。」jièdào:「zhuàngérshàngzěnmexiěkuàngzhuàngyòushìqīnggàodeqiěshuōzěndegào?」xíngzhěxiàodào:「yǒuzhǔzhāngzhèpáiwèixiāngzuòzhèngjiànlìngwàizàibèizhǐzhuàngér。」jièdào:「zhuàngérshàngzěnmexiě


逐句解 Line by line

kuàngzhuàngyòushìqīnggàode kuàngzhuàngyòushìqīnggàode

Besides, is an accusation before the throne a thing to be laid lightly?

豈是 is how could it be, a rhetorical question that already contains its own no. 輕易 is lightly, easily — still the ordinary modern word.

qiěshuōzěndegào?」 qiěshuōzěndegào?」

Tell me first: how do you mean to accuse him?"

Bajie asks for the pleading. He has moved in three lines from objecting to the plan to auditing it.

xíngzhěxiàodào:「yǒuzhǔzhāngzhèpáiwèixiāngzuòzhèngjiànlìngwàizàibèizhǐzhuàngér。」 xíngzhěxiàodào:「yǒuzhǔzhāngzhèpáiwèixiāngzuòzhèngjiànlìngwàizàibèizhǐzhuàngér。」

Pilgrim laughed. "I have it worked out. I shall make these tablets and this incense burner my evidence, and get up another plaint on paper besides."

證見 is what is seen and testified to — an older form of the modern word for evidence. 紙狀兒 is a plaint written out on paper, as against the physical exhibits: Pilgrim has grasped that a case needs both an object and a document.

jièdào:「zhuàngérshàngzěnmexiě jièdào:「zhuàngérshàngzěnmexiě

Bajie said, "What will you write on the plaint?

Bajie is now fully engaged as junior counsel, which is a sentence nobody expected to write about him.


總評 Commentary

The plan gets better every time somebody objects to it. Bajie warns about false accusation, so Pilgrim adds reasoning; Bajie asks how he means to do it, so Pilgrim adds a written pleading.

It is a good picture of how this trio actually works. Pilgrim supplies the nerve, Bajie supplies the objections, and the objections are what turn the nerve into a plan.