Canonical Classics ← 第七十五回
第七十五回
xīnyuánzuāntòuyīnyáng
zhǔhuánguīdàozhēn

The Mind-Monkey Bores Through the Body of Yin and Yang · The Demon Lord Returns to the True Great Way

感謝不盡
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

感謝不盡 You Did Not Fight Them

zhǎnglǎogǎnxièjìndào:「zhèfāncéngyāojīngdòume?」xíngzhědào:「céng。」zhǎnglǎodào:「zhèděngbǎoguòshānle?」xíngzhěshìhǎoshèngderénjiàohǎndào:「zěnmebǎoguòshānde?」zhǎnglǎogǎnxièjìndào:「zhèfāncéngyāojīngdòume?」xíngzhědào:「céng。」zhǎnglǎodào:「zhèděngbǎoguòshānle?」xíngzhěshìhǎoshèngderénjiàohǎndào:「zěnmebǎoguòshānde?」


逐句解 Line by line

zhǎnglǎogǎnxièjìndào:「zhèfāncéngyāojīngdòume?」 zhǎnglǎogǎnxièjìndào:「zhèfāncéngyāojīngdòume?」

The elder, thanking him beyond ceasing, said, "So this time you did not have it out with the demons?"

不盡 forces the tone of upward to . The reason is worth knowing: is fixed to a falling tone across this project, and always shifts to the rising tone before a falling one. The earlier chapters carry this exact compound nine times and read it at eight of them.

xíngzhědào:「céng。」 xíngzhědào:「céng。」

Wukong said, "I did not."

Two characters, and they are about to cost him the rest of the chapter.

zhǎnglǎodào:「zhèděngbǎoguòshānle?」 zhǎnglǎodào:「zhèděngbǎoguòshānle?」

The elder said, "Then you can't get me over the mountain?"

保不得 puts in the light de, the cannot-manage-to grammar. And this is Xuanzang being unexpectedly sharp: he has gone straight from gratitude to the practical question in one sentence.

xíngzhěshìhǎoshèngderénjiàohǎndào:「zěnmebǎoguòshānde?」 xíngzhěshìhǎoshèngderénjiàohǎndào:「zěnmebǎoguòshānde?」

Wukong was a creature who had to win, and he shouted out, "How do you mean I can't get you over the mountain?"

The narrator names the flaw outright — 好勝, fond of winning — which the book almost never does. He then repeats the master's own words back with the negation moved to the end, which is what people do when they have been stung.


總評 Commentary

The trap here is conversational rather than magical and Wukong walks into it faster than he walked into the bottle. He has just escaped a treasure of yin and yang by drilling a hole in it, and two sentences of mild scepticism from his master have him shouting.

It is worth noticing that Xuanzang is not being unreasonable. Nothing about the cave has changed: the doors are shut, the three chiefs are alive, and the road still runs through it. The disciple has had an adventure and the master has a logistics problem, and they are the same fact seen from two positions.