Canonical Classics ← 第七十五回
第七十五回
xīnyuánzuāntòuyīnyáng
zhǔhuánguīdàozhēn

The Mind-Monkey Bores Through the Body of Yin and Yang · The Demon Lord Returns to the True Great Way

孤掌難鳴
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

孤掌難鳴 One Thread Makes No Cord

zhǎnglǎodào:「céngjiànshèngzhǐzhèbānhánzěngǎnqiánjìn。」shèngxiàodào:「shītōngbiànchángyándào:『dānxiànzhǎngnánmíng。』sānxiǎoyāoqiānwànjiàolǎosūnrénzěnshēngdòu?」zhǎnglǎodào:「céngjiànshèngzhǐzhèbānhánzěngǎnqiánjìn。」shèngxiàodào:「shītōngbiànchángyándào:『dān线xiànzhǎngnánmíng。』sānxiǎoyāoqiānwànjiàolǎosūnrénzěnshēngdòu?」


逐句解 Line by line

zhǎnglǎodào:「céngjiànshèngzhǐzhèbānhánzěngǎnqiánjìn。」 zhǎnglǎodào:「céngjiànshèngzhǐzhèbānhánzěngǎnqiánjìn。」

The elder said, "You have not settled it with them one way or the other. With everything left this vague, how am I to dare go on?"

含糊 — muddy, indistinct, unresolved. It is exactly the right complaint. Wukong has had a personal triumph and produced no change in the situation.

shèngxiàodào:「shītōngbiàn shèngxiàodào:「shītōngbiàn

The Great Sage laughed: "Master, you really are too inflexible."

is a vernacular intensifier, too or excessively, and 不通變 is failing to adapt to circumstances. He is being rude to a man who has just spent the afternoon praying for him.

chángyándào:『dānxiànzhǎngnánmíng。』 chángyándào:『dān线xiànzhǎngnánmíng。』

"As the saying goes: a single thread makes no cord, and one palm alone cannot clap."

Two proverbs, and the second is still in daily use — 孤掌難鳴 is what Chinese reaches for whenever somebody is being asked to manage alone. The image is exact and physical: you can wave one hand as hard as you like and it makes no sound.

sānxiǎoyāoqiānwànjiàolǎosūnrénzěnshēngdòu?」 sānxiǎoyāoqiānwànjiàolǎosūnrénzěnshēngdòu?」

"Those fiends are three, and the lesser demons number thousands upon thousands. How is old Sun single-handed to have it out with them?"

is jiào, to make somebody do — the causative. And the arithmetic is honest for once: he has seen the hall, and a hundred officers with thousands behind them is not a fight he wants.


總評 Commentary

Wukong is right, and the way he is right is out of character. He has spent the book taking on armies. Here he cites two proverbs about the impossibility of acting alone, and he does it two minutes after being told he did not fight — which means the proverbs are also an excuse.

Both sayings are about pairs, which is the point he is building toward. He does not want to be told he failed; he wants Bajie. The whole speech is a negotiation dressed as a philosophy of teamwork, and Xuanzang, to his credit, gives him exactly what he is angling for in the next breath.