Canonical Classics ← 第七十回
第七十回
yāobǎofàngyānshāhuǒ
kōngdàojīnlíng

The Fiend's Treasure Looses Smoke, Sand and Fire · Wukong by Stratagem Steals the Purple-Gold Bells

金杯落地
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

金杯落地 The Golden Cup Strikes The Ground

xíngzhěwénshuōjiāngjīnbēiliánjiǔwàngkōngpiēdāngdeshēngxiǎngliàngjīnbēiluòjūnwángzháolemánggōngshēnshīdào:「shénsēngshùzuìshùzuìshìguǎrénshìledāngqǐngshàng殿diànbàixièzhǐyīnyǒuzhèfāng便biànjiǔzàijiùfèngěrshénsēngquèbēizipiēlequèshìyǒujiànguàizhī?」xíngzhěwénshuōjiāngjīnbēiliánjiǔwàngkōngpiēdāngdeshēngxiǎngliàngjīnbēiluòjūnwángzháolemánggōngshēnshīdào:「shénsēngshùzuìshùzuìshìguǎrénshìledāngqǐngshàng殿diànbàixièzhǐyīnyǒuzhèfāng便biànjiǔzàijiùfèngěrshénsēngquèbēizipiēlequèshìyǒujiànguàizhī?」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhěwénshuōjiāngjīnbēiliánjiǔwàngkōngpiēdāngdeshēngxiǎngliàngjīnbēiluò xíngzhěwénshuōjiāngjīnbēiliánjiǔwàngkōngpiēdāngdeshēngxiǎngliàngjīnbēiluò

Hearing this, Pilgrim took the golden goblet, wine and all, and flung it up into the empty air; there was a ringing clang, and the goblet came down on the ground.

here is the little word that hauls an object forward in front of its verb — jiāng, not the jiàng of a general. 噹的一聲 puts the noise before the event and the narrative obediently follows: clang first, cup landing second. And is the giveaway — to fling something away with a flick of the wrist, which is emphatically the wrong verb for a man returning a gift.

jūnwángzháolemánggōngshēnshīdào:「shénsēngshùzuìshùzuìshìguǎrénshìle jūnwángzháolemánggōngshēnshīdào:「shénsēngshùzuìshùzuìshìguǎrénshìle

The sovereign was thrown into a fluster and bent from the waist in apology: "Divine monk, pardon the fault, pardon the fault. The wrong is mine."

in 著了忙 is zháo, the reading for a state you fall into rather than one you keep up — the fluster arrives all at once. 是寡人不是了 turns on two different jobs for in five characters: the first is the ordinary is, the second is half of 不是, a fault. Roughly, it is me who is the one at fault.

dāngqǐngshàng殿diànbàixièzhǐyīnyǒuzhèfāng便biànjiǔzàijiùfèngěr dāngqǐngshàng殿diànbàixièzhǐyīnyǒuzhèfāng便biànjiǔzàijiùfèngěr

"By rights I should have asked you up into the hall and given you thanks there with due ceremony. It was only because this wine stood ready to hand that I offered it where we were."

is dāng, ought — the king is reciting the protocol he believes he has broken. 方便酒 is wine that happened to be to hand rather than wine set out for the purpose, which is exactly the distinction between opening something for a guest and pouring them what was already on the table. ends the sentence with a shrug: that is all it was.

shénsēngquèbēizipiēlequèshìyǒujiànguàizhī?」 shénsēngquèbēizipiēlequèshìyǒujiànguàizhī?」

"And now the divine monk has flung the cup away. Is that not a sign that offence has been taken?"

見怪 is to take a thing amiss, and the king asks it as a question he has already answered for himself. appears twice in sixteen characters, first adversative and then interrogative — but, and then surely-not.


總評 Commentary

The joke is a misreading, and the king makes it. A cup thrown upwards with the wine still in it is not a cup refused, but it looks exactly like one — and he has already told himself his thanks were inadequate. He supplies the insult himself, out of his own sense of falling short.

The proportions record the panic. He spent twenty-nine characters offering the wine and spends fifty-eight taking the blame for it, precisely twice as many. Inside those fifty-eight he apologises, accepts fault, explains the protocol he failed to follow, gives his reason for failing, and only then asks the question. The question comes last because he does not really want it answered.

Notice what he does not ask. The fire was announced one sentence before he began, and Wukong threw the cup on hearing it. The connection is sitting there and the king never reaches for it, because he is too busy being at fault.