Canonical Classics ← 第七十回
第七十回
妖yāo魔mó寶bǎo放fàng煙yān沙shā火huǒ
悟wù空kōng計jì盜dào紫zǐ金jīn鈴líng

The Fiend's Treasure Looses Smoke, Sand and Fire · Wukong by Stratagem Steals the Purple-Gold Bells

不解其意
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

不解其意 He Cannot Make Out The Meaning

行xíng者zhě聽tīng了le,暗àn喜xǐ道dào:「妖yāo精jīng也yě有yǒu存cún心xīn好hǎo的de。似sì他tā後hòu邊biān這zhè兩liǎng句jù話huà,說shuō『天tiān理lǐ難nán容róng』,卻què不bú是shì個gè好hǎo的de?但dàn只zhǐ說shuō金jīn聖shèng皇huáng后hòu一yí向xiàng無wú緣yuán,未wèi得dé沾zhān身shēn,此cǐ話huà卻què不bù解jiě其qí意yì。等děng我wǒ問wèn他tā一yí問wèn。」行xíng者zhě听tīng了le,暗àn喜xǐ道dào:「妖yāo精jīng也yě有yǒu存cún心xīn好hǎo的de。似sì他tā后hòu边biān这zhè两liǎng句jù话huà,说shuō『天tiān理lǐ难nán容róng』,却què不bú是shì个gè好hǎo的de?但dàn只zhǐ说shuō金jīn圣shèng皇huáng后hòu一yí向xiàng无wú缘yuán,未wèi得dé沾zhān身shēn,此cǐ话huà却què不bù解jiě其qí意yì。等děng我wǒ问wèn他tā一yí问wèn。」


逐句解 Line by line

行xíng者zhě聽tīng了le,暗àn喜xǐ道dào:「妖yāo精jīng也yě有yǒu存cún心xīn好hǎo的de。 行xíng者zhě听tīng了le,暗àn喜xǐ道dào:「妖yāo精jīng也yě有yǒu存cún心xīn好hǎo的de。

Pilgrim listened, and said to himself with quiet pleasure: "So even fiends may keep a good heart in them."

暗喜 is pleasure kept to oneself, which it has to be — he is sitting on the man's despatch bag at the time. 存心 is the heart a person keeps, the settled disposition rather than a passing mood: what the courier has is not a good impulse but a good character.

似sì他tā後hòu邊biān這zhè兩liǎng句jù話huà,說shuō『天tiān理lǐ難nán容róng』,卻què不bú是shì個gè好hǎo的de? 似sì他tā后hòu边biān这zhè两liǎng句jù话huà,说shuō『天tiān理lǐ难nán容róng』,却què不bú是shì个gè好hǎo的de?

"Take those last two sentences of his, where he says Heaven's principle will never allow it — is that not a good one?"

The single quotation marks belong to the edition, setting the courier's own phrase off inside Wukong's sentence. 難 is nán, hard to, exactly as it was when the courier said it a moment ago.

但dàn只zhǐ說shuō金jīn聖shèng皇huáng后hòu一yí向xiàng無wú緣yuán,未wèi得dé沾zhān身shēn,此cǐ話huà卻què不bù解jiě其qí意yì。等děng我wǒ問wèn他tā一yí問wèn。」 但dàn只zhǐ说shuō金jīn圣shèng皇huáng后hòu一yí向xiàng无wú缘yuán,未wèi得dé沾zhān身shēn,此cǐ话huà却què不bù解jiě其qí意yì。等děng我wǒ问wèn他tā一yí问wèn。」

"Only what he said about the Golden Sage Empress — no luck all this while, and never a hand laid on her — that I cannot make out the sense of. Let me put him a question."

解 is jiě, to untie, and so to work out — the same character that unties a knot unties a meaning. The tail runs six characters and carries no he-said of its own, so it goes in with the sentence before it. The same 等我 frame closed the previous scene.


總評 Commentary

Wukong's reaction is a compliment, and it is paid to nobody. A fiend has said something true about Heaven, and he notes the fact with something close to approval — even fiends may keep a good heart in them — which is a generous reading of a man who has just laid out a plan to sack a city.

But what he actually takes away is the puzzle. Out of everything the courier said — six dead women, a war tomorrow, a kingdom to be taken — the sentence that stops him is the one nobody was meant to notice: three years, and never once able to touch her. The whole plot turns on that clause, and he is the only listener who hears it as a question rather than as background.