Canonical Classics ← 第七十回
第七十回
妖yāo魔mó寶bǎo放fàng煙yān沙shā火huǒ
悟wù空kōng計jì盜dào紫zǐ金jīn鈴líng

The Fiend's Treasure Looses Smoke, Sand and Fire · Wukong by Stratagem Steals the Purple-Gold Bells

這一場好殺
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

這一場好殺 A Fine Battle In Mid Air

在zài半bàn空kōng裡lǐ這zhè一yì場cháng好hǎo殺shā:在zài半bàn空kōng里lǐ这zhè一yì场cháng好hǎo杀shā:

棍gùn是shì龍lóng宮gōng鎮zhèn海hǎi珍zhēn,槍qiāng乃nǎi人rén間jiān轉zhuǎn煉liàn鐵tiě。棍gùn是shì龙lóng宫gōng镇zhèn海hǎi珍zhēn,枪qiāng乃nǎi人rén间jiān转zhuǎn炼liàn铁tiě。
凡fán兵bīng怎zěn敢gǎn比bǐ仙xiān兵bīng,擦cā著zháo些xiē兒ér神shén氣qì泄xiè。凡fán兵bīng怎zěn敢gǎn比bǐ仙xiān兵bīng,擦cā着zháo些xiē儿ér神shén气qì泄xiè。
大dà聖shèng原yuán來lái太tài乙yǐ仙xiān,妖yāo精jīng本běn是shì邪xié魔mó孽niè。大dà圣shèng原yuán来lái太tài乙yǐ仙xiān,妖yāo精jīng本běn是shì邪xié魔mó孽niè。
鬼guǐ祟suì焉yān能néng近jìn正zhèng人rén,一yí正zhèng之zhī時shí邪xié就jiù滅miè。鬼guǐ祟suì焉yān能néng近jìn正zhèng人rén,一yí正zhèng之zhī时shí邪xié就jiù灭miè。
那nà個gè弄nòng風fēng播bō土tǔ諕xià皇huáng王wáng,這zhè個gè踏tà霧wù騰téng雲yún遮zhē日rì月yuè。那nà个gè弄nòng风fēng播bō土tǔ諕xià皇huáng王wáng,这zhè个gè踏tà雾wù腾téng云yún遮zhē日rì月yuè。
丟diū開kāi架jià子zi賭dǔ輸shū贏yíng,無wú能néng誰shuí敢gǎn誇kuā豪háo傑jié!丢diū开kāi架jià子zi赌dǔ输shū赢yíng,无wú能néng谁shuí敢gǎn夸kuā豪háo杰jié!
還hái是shì齊qí天tiān大dà聖shèng能néng,乒pīng乓pāng一yí棍gùn槍qiāng先xiān折zhé。还hái是shì齐qí天tiān大dà圣shèng能néng,乒pīng乓pāng一yí棍gùn枪qiāng先xiān折zhé。

逐句解 Line by line

在zài半bàn空kōng裡lǐ這zhè一yì場cháng好hǎo殺shā: 在zài半bàn空kōng里lǐ这zhè一yì场cháng好hǎo杀shā:

There in the middle air, what a fine battle this was:

The storyteller stops the action to announce a set-piece, and the poem that follows cannot be separated from this line. 場 is cháng, the counting word for something that runs its course from start to finish — a battle, a downpour, a marriage — and not the chǎng that means a place. English has nothing quite like it; the nearest thing is calling something a whole business, or a right to-do.

棍gùn是shì龍lóng宮gōng鎮zhèn海hǎi珍zhēn,槍qiāng乃nǎi人rén間jiān轉zhuǎn煉liàn鐵tiě。 棍gùn是shì龙lóng宫gōng镇zhèn海hǎi珍zhēn,枪qiāng乃nǎi人rén间jiān转zhuǎn炼liàn铁tiě。

The rod was a treasure that stilled the sea in the Dragon Palace; the spear was iron of the mortal world, smelted and smelted again.

The seven lines rhyme at all seven line-ends — tiě, xiè, niè, miè, yuè, jié, zhé — and the first line joins the scheme rather than standing outside it, which is the tighter of the two options available to a poem like this. All seven belonged to the old clipped-tone category that Chinese has since lost, so the rhyme was exact when this was written and has since drifted: five now end in -ie, one in -üe, and one, zhé, in a bare -e. It rhymes better on the page than in the mouth. Six lines run seven characters to the half and fourteen in all; one runs nine and eighteen.

凡fán兵bīng怎zěn敢gǎn比bǐ仙xiān兵bīng,擦cā著zháo些xiē兒ér神shén氣qì泄xiè。 凡fán兵bīng怎zěn敢gǎn比bǐ仙xiān兵bīng,擦cā着zháo些xiē儿ér神shén气qì泄xiè。

How should a common weapon match itself against an immortal one? At the least touch its divine force leaks away.

Here is the same character doing two jobs inside one poem. 著 in 擦著些兒 is zháo, marking contact that actually lands — the touch connects — against the zhe of 持著鐵棒 back at the chapter's opening, which marked a grip merely being held. 兒 keeps its full weight at ér rather than softening away: the line needs seven characters, and it only has seven if this one counts.

大dà聖shèng原yuán來lái太tài乙yǐ仙xiān,妖yāo精jīng本běn是shì邪xié魔mó孽niè。 大dà圣shèng原yuán来lái太tài乙yǐ仙xiān,妖yāo精jīng本běn是shì邪xié魔mó孽niè。

The Great Sage was from of old an immortal of the Grand Monad; the fiend was born an offshoot of the crooked and the wrong.

太乙 is the Grand Monad, the undivided first principle the Daoists put at the origin of things, and the line uses it as a pedigree — the way one might say a man came of an old family. 孽 answers it and means both an illegitimate branch of a family and an evil growth; the character carries both at once. Set against 仙 in the line above, a claim about morals quietly becomes a claim about breeding.

鬼guǐ祟suì焉yān能néng近jìn正zhèng人rén,一yí正zhèng之zhī時shí邪xié就jiù滅miè。 鬼guǐ祟suì焉yān能néng近jìn正zhèng人rén,一yí正zhèng之zhī时shí邪xié就jiù灭miè。

How should the goblin and the sprite come near the upright man? Let the upright stand but a moment and the crooked is snuffed out.

正 falls twice in fourteen characters, once as the upright man and once as the principle he stands for. 邪, the crooked, answers only the second; in the first half it is 鬼祟, goblins and sneaking things, that stands opposite. 一 before 正 is the adverb — once, as soon as — and it takes yí before a falling tone.

那nà個gè弄nòng風fēng播bō土tǔ諕xià皇huáng王wáng,這zhè個gè踏tà霧wù騰téng雲yún遮zhē日rì月yuè。 那nà个gè弄nòng风fēng播bō土tǔ諕xià皇huáng王wáng,这zhè个gè踏tà雾wù腾téng云yún遮zhē日rì月yuè。

That one raised the wind and flung the dust and terrified the sovereign lord; this one trod the mist and mounted the cloud and blotted out the sun and moon.

The long line of the seven, at nine characters to the half against the others' seven, and the extra pair at each end buys something specific: 那個 and 這個, that one and this one, holding both fighters on screen at the same moment. Every other line takes them one at a time. 諕 is xià, to frighten, a variant way of writing 嚇 — and not the reading a dictionary offers first.

丟diū開kāi架jià子zi賭dǔ輸shū贏yíng,無wú能néng誰shuí敢gǎn誇kuā豪háo傑jié! 丢diū开kāi架jià子zi赌dǔ输shū赢yíng,无wú能néng谁shuí敢gǎn夸kuā豪háo杰jié!

They threw their guards wide open and staked all on winning or losing. Where there is no ability, who dares call himself a hero?

架子 is the guard a fighter holds, with 子 gone light at zi; to fling it open is to stop defending and gamble everything on the attack. The second half steps outside the fight to editorialise — where there is no ability, who dares call himself a hero — and it is the only line of the seven that does.

還hái是shì齊qí天tiān大dà聖shèng能néng,乒pīng乓pāng一yí棍gùn槍qiāng先xiān折zhé。 还hái是shì齐qí天tiān大dà圣shèng能néng,乒pīng乓pāng一yí棍gùn枪qiāng先xiān折zhé。

It was the Great Sage Equal to Heaven who had the mastery: a clang, one blow of the rod, and the spear snapped first.

乒乓 exists for the sound and nothing else; the two characters are shaped to look like what they mean, and modern Chinese still uses them for table tennis. 還是 is hái shì, after all, when it comes to it. 折 is zhé, to snap, and it lands in the rhyme slot, so for once metre and meaning want the same thing.


總評 Commentary

This is a comparison poem: it settles the outcome in its first fourteen characters and then spends six more lines proving it. Rod against spear, dragon palace against mortal forge, treasure against ironmongery. Everything after the opening couplet is elaboration on a verdict already delivered.

The fifth line is the long one, eighteen characters against fourteen, and it is the only place both fighters appear at once — that one raising wind while this one treads mist. The extra pair of characters at each end is what the simultaneity costs. Everywhere else the poem takes one side at a time.

Underneath the weaponry the argument is about descent. Line three makes Wukong an immortal of the Grand Monad and the fiend an illegitimate offshoot; line four turns that into a rule, that crooked things cannot survive contact with upright ones. By the time the spear snaps, four lines have established that it was always going to. The fight demonstrates an axiom rather than deciding anything.